Where is Hind ?

A British organisation has done some investigation about what happened

“From the tank position indicated by the greatest alignment between entry and exit holes, we concluded that the shooter would have had a clear view of the car and its passengers. In other words, they would have been aware of the presence of two children.
“

https://forensic-architecture.org/investigation/the-killing-of-hind-rajab

https://twitter.com/abierkhatib/status/1785511323968610361

cnn is getting some backlash today

Investigation . From wp about what happened to hind. It’s behind paywall

https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/interactive/2024/hind-rajab-israel-gaza-killing-timeline/

JP talks about the WP report without paywall
https://m.jpost.com/israel-hamas-war/article-797629

www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/2/26/hind-rajab-were-israeli-troops-in-the-area-where-6-year-old-was-killed

Here's an article from The Times of Israel stating that the IDF said they weren't in the vicinity.

www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/idf-no-troops-were-operating-in-area-where-6-year-old-gazan-girl-was-killed-earlier-this-month-initial-probe/

I know many posters would like to believe this is true but given the evidence, it's a lie.

There was also the remains of the tank shell found in the ambulance sent to rescue Hind.

twitter.com/EuroMedHR/status/1756636671901057109

@EasterIssland Apologies, yes.

I believe it’s this the report you mean ?
https://twitter.com/palinfoen/status/1761752916514472080

That Al Jazeera analysis is pretty persuasive. Poor Hind.

They lie and they lie and they lie and they lie.

Idf says they weren’t in the proximity when hind was killed. That’s not what satellite images apparently show
https://twitter.com/BonsaiSky/status/1761536944641560627

Thanks for sharing this and highlighting the far and devastating impact the death of one child can have. To be in Gaza right now with as you say all those empty chairs, must be for most people like a living nightmare. The suffering of 12,000 chairs must surely be far greater than the sum of those empty chairs. Are any children still receiving an education, are there even any chairs left to sit on.

I am sorry for your loss, your son’s loss, and your community’s loss.

I've just seen this post on social media.
I can't find any sources for the new audio they found. Has anyone heard or read anything about it?

🚨^Brand new audio of the sweet Palestinian girl, Hind, who saw the Israel military murder her entire family in their car, and called for help.

Here we hear Hind describe soldiers approaching her in a tank before they slaughtered her as well.

This murder alone should’ve shocked the conscience of the world so much that everything stopped. ^

You are being flippant about a child reading the Quoran before dying? Why?

@etmoiandme I don't consider replying to people as a pile on. I just felt a thread about the murder of a child didn't need the comment that was made.

Maybe threads about individuals, especially children shouldn't be here at all. This is someone's daughter, grandaughter, sister, niece, cousin, friend discussing them on such an emotive board doesn't feel right to me. In saying that though I understand the importance of showing the people behind the statistics. It's all just so difficult

Fair enough. Apologies I was mainly referring to your original post I just thought it was a bit petty given the subject matter of the thread. No problem with people disagreeing with me.

This pile-on is completely unwarranted. If you'd actually taken the time to read @Humdingerydoo's posts you'd see she has shown more nuance and more humanity towards 'both sides' of the conflict than most posters across all these threads (her post about Hind is there upthread for you to refer to incidentally). And she certainly doesn't make it all about her.

I very much didn't make it about myself. I was replying to a poster who was calling me incredibly offensive and inappropriate. I have a right to reply to personal attacks.

Actually, you are right. They didn't say Israel's right to exist, they did specify Israel's governments actions. My apologies.

The rest of my post still stands, that they've grouped us all together based on one comment, which is a ridiculous thing to do.

So sorry about your loss. The death of a child is devastating and you're right it has a far reaching impact. You grieve the loss of the child and the loss of what they could have been. I hope your child and classmates get the help and support they'll need ❤

How they manage to put one foot in front of the other when faced with a level of grief that is unimaginable.
Shock and survival. They don't have time to grieve yet but they will and it will be so traumatic and they won't get the therapeutic support they'll need

Why are you making it all about you? This thread is about the suffering and murder of Hind

I was thinking the same thing because a child I know passed away recently too and the absolute devastation caused by that one death made me think about the thousands of children in Gaza who have been killed. The tragedy of it is incalculable.

I saw pictures in the papers today of children digging around in rubble, and holding out bowls for food and it's just shocking. Yesterday I saw a photo of four very small children, dead from a bombing. These children should be in school, they should be playing with their friends and they should have homes and families and all the comforts we expect for our children. They've lost their homes, their schools, their families in many cases, others have been maimed and over 12000 have lost their lives. And it goes on and on and on with no end in sight.

@Humdingerydoo Supporting Israel's right to exist and supporting the current military effort to obliterate Gaza aren't actually the same thing. Most people with a functioning moral compass seem to manage a modicum of concern about the deaths of civilians like Hind.

I was at a funeral this morning of a child, a friend and classmate of my child. The effect that the loss of this child has had on the community was clear to see. Family, neighbours, friends, classmates, teammates, teachers, coaches, parents of the children affected and many more. Hundreds of people all coming together to honour this poor child who will never get to see adulthood. It was a lot, so much grief and loss.

Hind, Layan,Sidra and 1000s and 1000s more children, all gone forever, all leaving the same holes in their communities that the child whose funeral I attended today has. It is incomprehensible how Gaza can ever recover from this. How they manage to put one foot in front of the other when faced with a level of grief that is unimaginable.

My child is dreading school on Monday and being faced with the empty chair of his friend. Gaza will have over 12,000 empty chairs if they ever get back to school. I know this is a bit of a pointless ramble but I'm just so sad this afternoon, so much pointless loss, so much avoidable grief, so many empty chairs and so many children like my son left grieving over them.

The op clearly stated that they were referring to people who still support the Israeli governments actions. Nowhere did they say people who support Israel’s right to exist. Unless you are implying that these two groups of people are the same? Now that would be quite the generalisation.