Israelis held hostage (part 2)

Care to elaborate?

Israeli news reporting 13 Israeli, 3 Thai and 1 Russian hostage.

I think BBC made a mistake - everyone else is still saying 13

Thought there were 14 though

Saw this on twitter but I don’t know if it’s a verified list :

1. Abigail Idan, 4
2. Ella Elyakim, 8
3. Dafna Elyakim, 15
4. Hagar Brodetz Ama, 40 and her children
5. Ofri Brodetz, 10
6. Yuval Brodetz, 8
7. Oriya Brodetz, 4
8. Chen Goldstein, 48 and her children
9. Agam Goldstein, 17

Are there more hostages due for release tomorrow?
Is the plan daily release until all are free again?

Oops, sterling I meant. Post edited.

The Red Cross do a Sterling job. They really do.

More good news

IDF says 14 Israeli hostages and three foreign nationals transferred to ICRC

The Israeli army says that, based on information it has received from the Red Cross, 14 Israeli hostages and three foreign hostages have been transferred to the Red Cross.

BBC Breaking News

A priority, I would like to think.

Probably a good idea. I suggest it's made clear it's not a continuation of thread 1 , and is only to discuss hostages held in Gaza. I will set one up regarding the topics we were discussing on thread 1, maybe?

Praying today they release the littlest hostages

I can see why people might want separate threads when it's impossible to talk about hostage release without some pushing an agenda over and over or talking about Israeli government policies which has nothing to do with the hostages and their release.

Well the post of yours that I responded to mentioned a Palestinian detainee but ok. Maybe that’s your preogative.

@Reallifelurker go back and read my original post then. You're mistaken, no generalisation just a post about one released prisoner.

I can see why people might want separate threads when it's impossible to talk about hostage release without some pushing an agenda over and over or talking about Israeli government policies which has nothing to do with the hostages and their release.

I think I'll just ignore posts not about hostage release in future since that's what I want to find out about. I can find out people's view about the Israel government on other threads.

'They'd look for them' that doesn't sound promising! Although I understand that some hostages were taken by another terrorist organisation and some by Palestinian men (unaffiliated).

I said none of what you are inferring and you know that, so why day that.
I wasn’t inferring anything. I was clarifying my point which is what you asked me to do.

I was talking about one particular man, not women and children and what that particular man was arrested for (throwing explosives) and what that particular man did on release celebrated with Hamas and put on their colours. You know that too.
It looked like you were making a generalisation to me.

Why don't you just start a thread for prisoners or detainees or whatever being released. Why post of the thread for hostages?
I suppose because the two topics are linked as they are being exchanged for each other. I’m not trying to upset anyone but that post by a pp saying everyone in Israel gets a fair trail because they’re a democracy just set me off again.

How sad segregation on MN being promoted.
Even non Jewish people are welcome on Jewish threads.
What on earth is happening in the world when most people just want peace.

Praying for this war to stop and for all to live side by side, even on MN

So sad this young lady's brother wasn't released with her.

https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/released-hostage-maya-regev-in-moderate-condition-will-undergo-a-series-of-surgeries/

If this is the only Russian hostage the Russians will be disappointed - they had 6 or 7 taken hostage and Hamas said they'd 'look for them' which didn't sound very promising at the time

But good news overall - touch wood

Hamas says it has released hostage holding Russian citizenship

Hamas says it has released a hostage who held Russian citizenship from Gaza.

The group added that it had taken the action in appreciation of Moscow’s position on the war.''

I said none of what you are inferring and you know that, so why say that?

I was talking about one particular man, not women and children and what that particular man was arrested for (throwing explosives) and what that particular man did on release celebrated with Hamas and put on their colours. You know that too.

Why don't you just start a thread for prisoners or detainees or whatever being released. Why post of the thread for hostages? Or is it to detail? I think as other poster suggested I will just ignore and read posts about hostages in future. There are numerous pro Palestine support threads. Any chance that this could be about hostages?

I've given up bothering to even read their posts now

I’m not convinced you were reading them in the first place.

Well he was released for said crime. He did put a hamas headband on and was being carried by Hamas so what's your point? It's there to see

While a lot of people detained by the Israelis may have committed some form of crime they are detained indefinitely without trial which is problematic.
Also a lot of them are apparently women and children not young men with home made bombs but it’s ok because the kids are probably going to be terrorists anyway. That is also problematic.

I've given up bothering to even read their posts now.

Are you saying he didn't throw explosive devices then?

Perhaps a thread for hostages and a separate thread for detainees would help?