Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

After this there will be silence

508 replies

notsoready4school · 11/11/2023 10:13

Are we really just going to just let this happen. I was upset about the protest ban in France but at least he has finally spoken up. When is the UK going to finally say something and stop letting this happen in our name.

This is the moment we have been warning the whole world the Gaza Deputy Health Minister Dr. Youssef Abu Alreesh, currently inside al-Shifa Hospital as it is takes heavy fire from Israeli forces.
Here are his translated comments:

  • This is the moment we have been warning the whole world of, all generators are off, all power sources are out.
  • We have 39 newborns in the incubators, those babies are fighting against death.
  • No one is able to move around the compound, snipers are stationed all over the place in addition to the drones that target and kill any moving person.
  • A few minutes ago one of the engineering team was hit by a sniper, he was hit in the neck and was paralysed and he’s now about to die.
  • Part of the hospital was shelled and part of the building caught fire, we fear it will engulf the whole compound.
  • A few families tried to leave but they were targeted; now they are lying dead outside the hospital. We cannot get to them.
  • We are totally stranded, we are cut off from the outside world, and above all, we are left without any medical resources. We cannot even bury the dead.
  • Ferocious gunfire can be heard within the vicinity of the hospital, the intensive care unit received a mortar shell a few minutes ago.
  • Blood is everywhere, on the floor, we cannot even clean it.
  • In the past, the Israeli killing machine was killing and this was conveyed on TV screens. Now they are perpetrating the same killing but no one is listening, no one is watching, the whole world is standing by.
  • We are speaking with whatever is left of my phone battery, after that, we will be silent.
OP posts:
Thread gallery
27
Queucumber · 12/11/2023 08:55

You’re right, it’s Fatah in the West Bank, Hamas in Gaza and Hezbollah in Lebanon.

SinnerBoy · 12/11/2023 06:58

Queucumber · Yesterday 21:36

No, there’s hezbollah, funded by Iran.

That's Lebanon, an entirely different country.

Fatah are in the West Bank and are extremely unpopular with the Palestinians, on account of their corruption and willingness to carry out security operations for the Israelis. They do that because they're terrified of being the next Gaza.

Parkingt111 · 12/11/2023 05:31

eardefender · 11/11/2023 19:22

Bear in mind your first post is a hamas statement, I would take it with a huge pinch of salt. All staff in the hospital have always known that hamas have their headquarters below the hospital, they also know that the hostages including 30 babies are being held below the hospital. They also had 4 weeks to evacuate and there are now 4 hourly pauses. It is hamas who keep them there under duress because they need human shields. It’s hamas who can end this in an hour by surrendering and giving back the hostages.

That's not only incorrect but an incredibly bold statement to make. Please provide which credible source you have for a)all doctors know about this alleged Hamas base and b) that there are 30 hostage babies being held there along side other hostages

Oliotya · 12/11/2023 04:40

untitledmum · 12/11/2023 02:14

Hamas has tunnels under hospitals. Hamas has a weapons factory within hospitals. Hamas' gunmen are currently hiding in the Shifra Hospital and shooting at the Israeli soldiers from the hospital windows.
There are multiple irrefutable video and photo evidence of this.

Do you really think the Israeli's should stand by and say "Its a hospital let's let them shoot anti-tanks, we'll just ignore!?"

All you people here on MN, saying that Israel is bombing innocent civilians. Don't you see it? - You are asking Gaza's enemy (Israel) to be more merciful on its citizens then the Gazan leaders (Hamas). How twisted!?

I mean, Britain bombed Dresden to get rid of the Nazis, and there were no protests in Trafalgar square!!??

Somehow Israel is held up to some really unfair standards.

"You are asking Gaza's enemy (Israel) to be more merciful on its citizens then the Gazan leaders (Hamas). How twisted!?"

Actually I don't think it's twisted at all. Absolutely a democracy with international superpower backing ought to behave better than a brutal terrorist dictatorship. In fact I'd say it's twisted to suggest that they shouldn't behave better.

As for Dresden, I'll dig my great grandad up and ask him shall I?

untitledmum · 12/11/2023 02:14

Hamas has tunnels under hospitals. Hamas has a weapons factory within hospitals. Hamas' gunmen are currently hiding in the Shifra Hospital and shooting at the Israeli soldiers from the hospital windows.
There are multiple irrefutable video and photo evidence of this.

Do you really think the Israeli's should stand by and say "Its a hospital let's let them shoot anti-tanks, we'll just ignore!?"

All you people here on MN, saying that Israel is bombing innocent civilians. Don't you see it? - You are asking Gaza's enemy (Israel) to be more merciful on its citizens then the Gazan leaders (Hamas). How twisted!?

I mean, Britain bombed Dresden to get rid of the Nazis, and there were no protests in Trafalgar square!!??

Somehow Israel is held up to some really unfair standards.

OneHurtSpaggettio · 12/11/2023 01:22

Jupitersstorm · 12/11/2023 00:14

100% this.

Evacuate hundreds of critically injured and disfigured people, many of whom are in intensive care, as well as babies in incubators to where exactly? To one of the other hospitals getting bombed, or…? I would love to know.

“All staff in the hospital have always known that hamas have their headquarters below the hospital, they also know that the hostages including 30 babies are being held below the hospital.”

You’re just making things up as you go along. Multiple hospital staff have refuted the claim that Hamas are there. If they are there, then they’re unaware.

As for the bit about babies being held under the hospital, that is pure fiction. I love that you claim to know where the hostages are.

When was the last pause? Do you know that, too?

You seem to think that Hamas have forced Israel to do despicable things, as if Hamas are somehow now using telekinesis to force the IDF to blow up, maim and torture Palestinian children and babies as they die slowly under rubble. As if that isn’t a choice made by their far-right, terrorist government, that’s part of all the other monstrous decisions that they make.

The fact that you have been reading the news for the past month and think that the Israeli govt give a shit about hostages says a lot. Thousands protesting in Israel disagree with you.
@eardefender

Onand · 12/11/2023 00:41

whiteduvetcover · 12/11/2023 00:38

Are you aware that Hamas continues to pour rockets on Israel?

If they care about their people, they should announce their own ceasefire. Why is the demand for a ceasefire being targeted at Israel only when Hamas is doing this too?

Exactly this. Hamas do not care about their people, not one iota. There’s a lot of propaganda and misinformation on this thread so don’t expect any reasoned response.

notsoready4school · 12/11/2023 00:41

They have requested and offered a ceasefire

OP posts:
whiteduvetcover · 12/11/2023 00:38

Are you aware that Hamas continues to pour rockets on Israel?

If they care about their people, they should announce their own ceasefire. Why is the demand for a ceasefire being targeted at Israel only when Hamas is doing this too?

notsoready4school · 12/11/2023 00:35

Stomacharmeleon · 12/11/2023 00:21

@notsoready4school apart from the black market trade coming through the tunnels eg rockets, race horses. You think it would have better priorities eg feed its people..

Also Israel provide around 13 % of drinking water. Not all.

Israel controls 100% of everything that comes in and out. It is occupied by the definitions of UN. Hamas only had control within the territory.

Who cares? What is your point? Did Israel want to kill well fed fat people and healthy children only?

OP posts:
Rubbishagain · 12/11/2023 00:30

Newbutoldfather · 11/11/2023 11:12

I am very pro Israel and their right to deal with the terrorists on their border. Even if they are targeting Hamas, who hide behind the weak like the cowards they are, this is grim.

It is also a huge mistake. The optics are terrible regardless of their motivations; there must be a more intelligent way of targeting based under hospitals without killing the sick and injured.

https://www.instagram.com/reel/CzhUSAptqf3/?igshid=Y2NkYjk0MDhjYg==
this is what the nasty vile Israeli soldiers are up to. Not a mention about hostages though. I think they don’t care much for any hostages. They just want to kill as many people as possible. Israel has forced the Palestinians into the smallest amount of land. These people are living in such close proximity. These comments you keep spewing about Hamas hiding behind civilians is ridiculous. They have no space because Israel stole Palestinians land. Israel has the most advanced spyware and surveillance technology they can find anyone if they really want to. Israel just want to continue with the genocide

Instagram

https://www.instagram.com/reel/CzhUSAptqf3/?igshid=Y2NkYjk0MDhjYg==

notsoready4school · 12/11/2023 00:30

HaveALaff · 11/11/2023 23:51

The IDF murdering innocent children and babies, it is disgusting. The fact that no israeli supporter can say that is abhorrent.

Everyone was asking to condemn the actions of Hamas and everyone did but now when things are so obviously abhorrent and they are the perpetrators, nothing.

OP posts:
notsoready4school · 12/11/2023 00:25

winowin · 11/11/2023 21:30

@notsoready4school

Will you answer my questions?

What do you think will happen if Israel cease fire?

What will be hamsa's next move if they do?

What do you think Israel should have done after the slaughter of their civilians?

What do you think the solution is?

There's all this talk of what Israel shouldn't do but no talk of what they should have done?

Well I’m no army general or politician but you know what US has the best experience and intelligence on this, they told them not to do this and definitely could have advised them how to do it better. Especially in a way that saves their hostages and potentially lets the country move on and people heal. But the way that Israel has approached is wrong for everyone but Hamas. Wrong for the hostages, wrong for the Israelis, wrong for the Palestinians and even wrong for the Government’s standing at home. I can’t think of anything worse they could have done, can you?

OP posts:
Stomacharmeleon · 12/11/2023 00:21

@notsoready4school apart from the black market trade coming through the tunnels eg rockets, race horses. You think it would have better priorities eg feed its people..

Also Israel provide around 13 % of drinking water. Not all.

notsoready4school · 12/11/2023 00:20

Everyhow · 11/11/2023 21:17

@notsoready4school so it’s fine to kill thousands of innocent civilians as long as you’re not targeting a hospital. Ok then. And I would really question that people in Yemen who are starving and living in abject poverty can just leave whenever.

Read up about the war there before you start commenting.

OP posts:
notsoready4school · 12/11/2023 00:19

Stomacharmeleon · 11/11/2023 20:17

@notsoready4school Saudi have the sixth biggest defence budget in the world. Not powerful?

You don't need an army, just to step in or facilitate.

You need to understand more on how that defence budget works. It is a spending allowance on USA weapons, you can only go shopping there if you are using it for a cause supported by them otherwise the goods wont be delivered. Causes USA agree with are Yemen, Iran etc.

Not Israel which has lost its way so spectacularly but even then USA doesn’t do anything

OP posts:
OuiOuiMonAmiJeMappelleLafayette · 12/11/2023 00:18

Newbutoldfather · 11/11/2023 11:25

None of this would have happened without the Hamas attack, so it is easy to take sides. In the same sense, I ‘took sides’ in the war against terrorism despite the horrors of Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo Bay.

It is easy to sit in our comfortable homes in the UK and condemn Israel. As soon as a terror attack occurred in the UK, everyone on this thread deploring Israel (well maybe 99%) would expect our military to keep us and our children safe regardless of the collateral damage.

That does not mean I cannot deplore this attack close to a hospital. Sometimes friends in a fit of anger do bad things.

Completely disagree. After the Manchester Arena attack, I remember seeing a FB post with a picture of a missile with the words written on it 'Love from Manchester'. All I could think of was how awful it was, if that was to be fired it wouldn't land on the terrorists that had committed the atrocity, it would hit innocent children, just like the ones that died after the Ariana Grande concert. So no, I think you're completely wrong. Though, I do think there are people like you and they are the ones that will become the terrorists!

Jupitersstorm · 12/11/2023 00:14

eardefender · 11/11/2023 19:22

Bear in mind your first post is a hamas statement, I would take it with a huge pinch of salt. All staff in the hospital have always known that hamas have their headquarters below the hospital, they also know that the hostages including 30 babies are being held below the hospital. They also had 4 weeks to evacuate and there are now 4 hourly pauses. It is hamas who keep them there under duress because they need human shields. It’s hamas who can end this in an hour by surrendering and giving back the hostages.

100% this.

notsoready4school · 12/11/2023 00:08

winowin · 11/11/2023 21:46

@OneHurtSpaggettio
Why is it Israel's responsibility to provide food and water to Palestinians?
Do their own government, Hamas, bare no responsibility to their own people?
Or is it ok for Hamas not to give a fuck but Israeli government should?

Israel doesn’t let controls Gaza. It doesn’t allow them any ports, any trade, any means of water. What do you mean? Do you not know that?

The only reason Israel has responsibility is because after it withdrew it used controlled the area and the people have no control for anything outside of the border. It is not a ‘country’ it is completely controlled by Israel.

it is another type of occupation and that is agreed terminology.

OP posts:
OneHurtSpaggettio · 12/11/2023 00:01

HaveALaff · 11/11/2023 23:51

The IDF murdering innocent children and babies, it is disgusting. The fact that no israeli supporter can say that is abhorrent.

The most I saw was that it was a “mistake” because the “optics of it don’t look good” - as in, it’s only bad because, from a PR perspective, it might harm Israel.

HaveALaff · 11/11/2023 23:51

The IDF murdering innocent children and babies, it is disgusting. The fact that no israeli supporter can say that is abhorrent.

OneHurtSpaggettio · 11/11/2023 23:48

From the Red Cross about Al-Quds hospital:

We are deeply alarmed to hear that the Palestine Red Crescent Society (PRCS) teams at the Al-Quds hospital have again this morning been told to immediately evacuate the hospital. Hospitals are places of help and refuge; they must be protected at all cost.

PRCS’s Al-Quds hospital in Gaza city is caring for hundreds of injured people and bed-ridden, long-term patients. Evacuating patients, including those in intensive care, on life-support and babies in incubators, is close to, if not impossible in the current situation. Our teams also report violent attacks and shelling very close to the hospital further endangering people. Al-Quds Hospital is operated by PRCS, a component of the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement, and together with other medical missions and facilities are protected under international humanitarian law.

We are deeply concerned about the safety of patients, health care workers and the thousands who have taken refuge in Al-Quds Hospital. Healthcare workers should never be put in front of the impossible dilemma of leaving patients behind or risking their lives staying in the hospital.

https://www.ifrc.org/article/ifrc-statement-evacuation-order-al-quds-hospital-gaza

@Stomacharmeleon so even if there has been a pause, it may not be at times when doctors and medical staff need to leave. They also can’t leave knowing that they may not be able to return. Or if they do leave anyway, they are making the decision to leave an already intensely overwhelmed hospital and all of their patients, to save their own life, which must be a horrific decision to be forced to make.

IFRC statement on the evacuation order of Al Quds hospital in Gaza | IFRC

We are deeply alarmed to hear that the Palestine Red Crescent Society (PRCS) teams at the Al-Quds hospital have again this morning been told to immediately evacuate the hospital. Hospitals are places of help and refuge; they must be protected at all co...

https://www.ifrc.org/article/ifrc-statement-evacuation-order-al-quds-hospital-gaza

OneHurtSpaggettio · 11/11/2023 23:35

“We are surrounded, we cannot bury our dead. We are going to create a mass grave within the hospital compound,” he told Al Jazeera.

“We do not have any equipment or machinery to dig the grave. We have to bury these bodies otherwise epidemics will break out. These bodies have been lying on the street for days.”
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/11/11/we-are-minutes-away-from-death-gazas-al-shifa-hospital-under-attack

‘We are minutes away from death’: Gaza’s al-Shifa Hospital under attack

Palestinian health officials say babies in incubators are fighting for their lives as Israel lays siege to the compound.

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/11/11/we-are-minutes-away-from-death-gazas-al-shifa-hospital-under-attack

Stomacharmeleon · 11/11/2023 23:31

What's happening with the four hour windows? Have they started yet? Can people leave then? I mean staff and people able to leave clearly.

OneHurtSpaggettio · 11/11/2023 23:27

Doctors Without Borders have said that Israel’s constant bombardment of Al Shifa has meant that no medical staff who want to leave the hospital are able to do so safely.

https://edition.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/israel-hamas-war-gaza-news-11-11-23/h_7a910ee72765394b924b5db36a40fcae

Constant bombardment is keeping staff and patients from evacuating Gaza's largest hospital as resources run thin, according to Doctors Without Borders. Israel's military has acknowledged clashes with Hamas operatives around the Al-Shifa Hospital, but denied firing on or laying siege to the medical center.

CNN - Live updates: Israel-Hamas war, Gaza evacuations, Saudi summit, hospital crisis

Hostilities around Al-Shifa Hospital “have not stopped,” Doctors Without Borders says

Hostilities around Al-Shifa Hospital Saturday “have not stopped,” according to Médecins Sans Frontières, also known as Doctors Without Borders.

https://www.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/israel-hamas-war-gaza-news-11-11-23/h_797bbe3a0ff8668316a949f483bcfc72

Swipe left for the next trending thread