Please or to access all these features

Children's books

Join in for children's book recommendations.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

June children's bookclub choice: Fortunately The Milk by Neil Gaiman - apply for free copy!

56 replies

RachelMumsnet · 02/06/2014 14:01

Neil Gaiman was recently described by the Sunday Times as 'the nearest thing children's books have to a Rock Star' and 2 million twitter followers are proof of his cult status. Fortunately the Milk... is a departure from many of his darker more macabre children's stories (think Coraline, The Graveyard book) but equally as fantastical and inventive.

A dad who nips out to buy a pint of milk is delayed by, among other things, dinosaurs, time travel and 'green globby things'. With superbly anarchic illustrations from Chris Riddell, this is perfect bedtime reading for children aged 8 + as well as Gaiman-fan parents (a great gift for Father's Day).

See Neil Gaiman reading an extract and if you fancy reading this with your Dcs apply for one of 50 free copies.

Everyone who accesses a free copy will be asked to post a review, join the discussion on this thread and/or tweet about the book using #Mumsnetbookclub.

June children's bookclub choice: Fortunately The Milk by Neil Gaiman - apply for free copy!
OP posts:
Hermancakedestroyer · 22/06/2014 16:10

Book received and review posted. We loved this book and thoroughly recommend it for 8-11 year old children. Thanks for the copy.

PrincessTheresaofLiechtenstein · 21/06/2014 18:56

From ds, 8:
"I really enjoyed the book. The writing was very easy to read so everyone in my family could enjoy it. I would have preferred chapters because you don't know where to stop. I think the idea of having objects at home of everything that happened is good. The characters were very good and it really described how they were feeling. I think the illustrations are good because they give so much of an idea of what things look like and you can make a proper picture of them in your head.

I think people who like adventures should read it. I would read something by the same author."

I haven't finished the book yet myself but the few pages I read really made me laugh. Love the imagination and creativity that has gone into this.

Uptheairymountain · 20/06/2014 15:32

jj21 is spot on with silly and unbelievable - but they're the main reasons why this book is such rattlingly good fun.

It's quite a departure from some of Neil Gaiman's other, more contemplative, children's books that are written for a similar age group, such as The Graveyard Book, Od and the Frost Giants and Coraline (all of which I've read and enjoyed). That is not a bad thing; Fortunately, The Milk is an absurd and witty old-fashioned adventure that careers along at breakneck speed. Neil Gaiman must have had fun writing it, although it may not have seemed like it was fully under his control sometimes!

The premise itself is clever, a Dad telling his children about the adventures he had buying milk, and I enjoyed watching for how many times the phrase "Fortunately, the milk" came up. The action storms along with many, yes, silly and unbelievable scrapes and rescues from danger without pausing for breath. In its 140 pages the story bounces from alien abduction to pirate mayhem, from human sacrifice and volcanoes to Houyhnhnm-style ponies and vampires, culminating in the sheer chaotic collision of aliens, space police, dinosaurs and dwarfs, straight out of a screwball farce. Not to mention an encounter with a memorable time-travelling hot-air-balloonist called Professor Steg.

Chris Riddell's lovely, witty illustrations add even more pizazz to the story and make it feel amost like a graphic novel, which should encourage more reluctant readers to pick up the book.

On an adult level, there we a few things in the story that I particularly appreciated. I identified with the Dad who was oblivious to everything around him when he had his head buried in his newspaper. I liked the children's observations and comments on the story as it unfolded. Mainly, though, I was delighted by the reminder that all the inspiration needed to tell a good story can be found simply by looking around you.

Children aged 8 + should love it!

sallyc06 · 19/06/2014 16:13

Wow what a fab book, my Jakey couldn't put it down. So full of fun and witty, with lovely illustrations.

Uptheairymountain · 19/06/2014 14:56

I've got my copy, thank you! I haven't read it yet, but I've looked at the first page and the chocolate mushroom story made me laugh.

Will post the review asap.

gingercat12 · 19/06/2014 12:46

Our copy arrived yesterday as well, and DS took it to bed with him. This is our next bedtime reading (as soon as we finish Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban). DS loved the pictures and is very excited. I'll post more once we read it. In the meantime, thanks a lot.

jj21 · 18/06/2014 22:35

I was sent a copy to review by Mumsnet which came today, thank you. Aliens, pirates, dinosaurs, ponies, time travel and a volcano - there is something for all three of my children in this book. For reading aloud, there are loads of opportunities to do different voices (my favourite bit) - guaranteed laughs at bedtime. So far this is ticking all the right boxes. It works for independent reading as well, although the format with no chapters will be difficult for my middle daughter to read to herself - she likes a more structured presentation with chapters and finds it hard to stop before the end if there are no clear breaks. However, my reluctant reader, dyslexic son will find this format perfect - no chapters to show how much or how little he has read, lots of detailed pictures throughout and nice big print with plenty of spaces around it. The format is not totally unlike a graphic novel, whilst much easier to read, another plus for him.

I found the story silly and unbelievable. This almost certainly means that my children (7, 9, 10) will love it. (It only arrived today, so we have yet to road test the book as a family.) The language and imagery is imaginative and the story is fast moving, despite its silliness.
So why only 3 stars - surely the comments are worth more than 'not bad at all'? I took one off for the ending, which is fairly abrupt and somewhat predictable, but my children may feel differently about the end. It was right up there with 'it was all a dream' although it is fairly clear from a few pages into the book where this is going. But I like all loose ends tied up..... What was he really doing? I think this could be the real story!

Overall, I will read this with my kids and I know they will want to read it themselves, too. For silly bedtime fun that lets a diva mum indulge her acting urges it is great, and I think it is especially good for reluctant readers for independent reading. Thank you Mumsnet for letting us enjoy this title.

WildEyedAndHairier · 18/06/2014 20:45

Received our copy today, thank you! Do we review it on the reviews page linked above as well as here?

Permanentpanicmode · 18/06/2014 11:52

(Am PanicMode1 but can't log in on my laptop with that username since the password change for some reason).

I received the copy this morning and have just read it - I will give it to my 9 and 10 year olds later for their review, but mine is below.

I haven't ever read any Neil Gaiman but I know that he is revered for his work and is something of a 'rock star' novelist (if that's not too awful an oxymoron!). I had high hopes for the book because so many people rave about his talent, but I confess to being fairly disappointed. I wanted it to be laugh out loud funny, but to me, it felt like something which was written fairly quickly, and which was only brought to life by the excellent illustrations of Chris Riddell. I felt if you took the drawings away, then the story was fairly poor. I loved the premise of the book - the idea of how he explains away his delay on his trip to buy the milk, and the reveal of how he constructed the story from the props around him on his return, but for me this wasn't engaging or funny enough to want to read and re-read it to my younger ones (4 and 6).

I will however see what the target audience think when they are back from school and ask them to write their own reviews.

PrincessTheresaofLiechtenstein · 18/06/2014 10:41

Our copy arrived this morning, thank you! Will read it with ds over the weekend Smile

Britchic · 14/06/2014 07:34

Oh, yes please, I'd absolutely love a copy! Smile

ScarlettDarling · 13/06/2014 21:30

My kids excited to hear we're getting a copy, many thanks. We'll be back soon with our review.

sanfairyanne · 12/06/2014 21:42

i loved this book. really funny.

frazzledbutcalm · 12/06/2014 20:07

Received an email saying I'm getting a copy! Can't wait, ds is soooo excited! Thank you mumsnet! Smile

gildedlily · 12/06/2014 11:18

Big thank you - just heard I'm getting a copy. Looking forward to reading it to my boys

NataliaMumsnet · 10/06/2014 12:51

This giveaway is now closed. We will contact those selected to receive a free copy via email. Be sure to let us know your thoughts on the book.

WildEyedAndHairier · 03/06/2014 22:11

I'd love a copy please. DS is nearly 8 and this sounds like something he would really enjoy.

CMOTDibbler · 03/06/2014 22:07

We loved this!

Beehatch · 03/06/2014 22:07

Someone mentioned the book on here recently and I've been meaning to look out for it. Sounds just up DDs street!

MrsMot · 03/06/2014 22:02

Oh this book is so so so good. We read it a few months ago, bloody brilliant!!!

Panicmode1 · 03/06/2014 22:01

I'd love a copy too - desperate to stop my DS reading Minecraft comics!

almondfinger · 03/06/2014 21:50

I'd love a copy please. Love Neil Gaiman.

millililli · 03/06/2014 21:22

Haven't come across this one before, but sounds great

Uptheairymountain · 03/06/2014 18:52

Ooh, I haven't seen this book.

I absolutely adore Neil Gaiman's work, especially some of his GNs like Harlequin Valentine.

DD particularly loves Chu's Day, but we find it hard to read her other favourite, Blueberry Girl, without me turning into a snivelling mess Grin.

RunsWithScissors · 03/06/2014 18:25

Fingers crossed, love NG and would love to get my dd as a fan as well.