Active discussions

Please or to access all these features

Talk
Children's books

Join in for children's book recommendations.

Original poster

The lion, witch and the wardrobe

32 replies

coventgarden · 23/07/2010 19:06

DD is nagging to read my copy of the afore mentioned book and I have said no so far as I have had it since I was a kid and I don't trust her not to spoil it. I am also unsure of the right age for it. She can read anything but I want her to understand and enjoy it as well.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Original poster
coventgarden · 27/07/2010 19:13

OOps

Lewis Carroll is who I meant .

OP posts:
basildonbond · 27/07/2010 19:03

well it's obviously not "Chronicles of CS Lewis" then, is it?! CS Lewis wrote "The Chronicles of Narnia", Lewis Carroll wrote Alice in Wonderland - lots of Lewises, easy to get confused, but probably not if you're a publisher

Original poster
coventgarden · 27/07/2010 18:53

Yes.

OP posts:
Ponders · 27/07/2010 18:52

coventgarden, does your Chronicles of C S Lewis really have Alice in Wonderland in it???

3littlefrogs · 27/07/2010 18:47

The best EB book I read at that sort of age was "The island of adventure". (It saved me from endless boredom on a rainy caravan holiday...)

5Foot5 · 25/07/2010 17:01

I have heard there are groups of people who have vicious arguments heated debates about the correct order to read the books i.e. publication order or chronological.

Personally I am in the camp that says start with TLTWATW otherwise you spoil some of the plot - however I don't care enough to call anyone out for a fight over it

I though The Last Battle was pretty grim - really didn't like it much TBH. IIRC Susan is damned not to enjoy the after life because she decided to wear lipstick. It is a while since I read it so maybe I am hazy on the details here.

Goblinchild · 24/07/2010 13:53

Charity shops in posher areas are a good source of traditional literature at under £1
I stock my class library every year from them, over the summer.

megapixels · 24/07/2010 13:37

Oh right, the Five Find Outers. I introduced the EB's series one at a time, because there seems like there's a definite order you should read them. For example once you read Famous Five the Secret Seven seem a bit boring and for younger kids. Five Find Outers should come after FF IMO, they seem one step higher somehow. Of course your dd might be a book snob and choose to bypass EB completely .

Original poster
coventgarden · 24/07/2010 13:10

It is the complete chronicles of C S Lewis that I have.

The EB book was something about being on Holly Lane. This one

OP posts:
Meglet · 24/07/2010 11:19

I loved the magicians nephew, it has a guinea pig in it IIRC.

megapixels · 24/07/2010 11:07

What was the Enid Blyton she felt she wasn't old enough for? DD found some of the younger ones quite silly (she just couldn't get into the Faraway Tree stuff no matter how many times she/we tried, but she did enjoy the Wishing Chair ones) but she's in love with EB now that she's on Famous Five.

gherkinwithapurplemerkin · 24/07/2010 09:27

Oh not Black Beauty...Ginger going past in the knacker's cart...

Original poster
coventgarden · 24/07/2010 09:14

I may have a look for it when I go out later and keep it for a bit. She has actually told me before that she isn't old enough to read a book I gave her, an Enid Blyton one , so I think she will decide for herself and be sensible. I bought her the lady bird version of Black Beauty but I don't think she has read it yet. MIL felt she was too young for it.

OP posts:
megapixels · 23/07/2010 22:22

Anything fantasy freaks her out covent, she is quite sensitive about things she's read or watched on TV and has gone through a few phases of daily nightmares. It's been almost a year now though, might ask if she wants to try it again. She watched the movie and seemed ok with it, maybe when she read the book she imagined things to be scarier than they are.

I don't think you need to worry about your DD unless she's had a history of getting scared of these things. I don't think many children do.

Original poster
coventgarden · 23/07/2010 19:58

What freaked her out?

OP posts:
megapixels · 23/07/2010 19:51

I didn't know about The Magician's Nephew. My dd started reading it aged 7, she was completely gripped by the story, but also completely freaked out. Had to tell her to stop reading then.

OgreRebel · 23/07/2010 19:51

The Chronicles are iirc...

The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe
Prince Caspian
The Voyage of the Dawn Treader
The Silver Chair
The Horse and His Boy
The Magician's Nephew
The Last Battle

The orders in which they were written/published/anthologised are different and none are chronological to the story. You can read them several ways. Above order is the way I think they're presented usually but as is already mentioned TMN is the start of the story.

Original poster
coventgarden · 23/07/2010 19:45

Why did I not know any of this?

I have a big, fat green book called The Chronicles of C S Lewis, I think. It has Alice in Wonderland in it and I can't remember what else. Last month I bought her Dr Dolittle.

OP posts:
secunda · 23/07/2010 19:41

I would go for TLTW&TW first, because it's the best known and because Lewis did actually write it first, then went back and did TMN even though chronologically it is earlier. If she is 6 and bright I think she will like it.

OgreRebel · 23/07/2010 19:34

The Magician's Nephew is/was my favourite. It's the first in terms of chronology but wasn't written first and you don't have to read it first. Most people start with TLTW&TW.

ponceydog · 23/07/2010 19:31

she might not understand the christian analogies

3littlefrogs · 23/07/2010 19:30

The subtext isn't really apparant to a 7 year old, I don't think. They are good stories, but very much of their time.

3littlefrogs · 23/07/2010 19:29

They are all written by C S Lewis. I think there are 6 or 7 books in the series - will have to think and count!

Original poster
coventgarden · 23/07/2010 19:28

I am just conscious that while she can read any word she is only 6 and I want her to be able to understand and enjoy the book. She is very bright but even so.

OP posts:
InvaderZim · 23/07/2010 19:26

She won't have any trouble understanding it, unless you mean the subtext...?

Swipe left for the next trending thread