Please or to access all these features

Paid childcare

Discuss everything related to paid childcare here, including childminders, nannies, nurseries and au pairs.

Au pair problem...I feel ridiculous posting this but

42 replies

MizZan · 27/05/2009 00:42

...our AP is really, truly eating us out of house and home, and I'm just wondering if anyone has any strategies they might recommend to help us avoid this situation in future. I've pretty much written off the current situation but am wondering if we've just been very lucky up till now, or what. Have had quite a few au pairs before and while some of them have been a little peculiar in their eating habits, we've never run across anything like this before.

AP joined us in April and announced that she liked meat and expected to have "cooked meat" for lunch every day. That was just the beginning. She is putting away at least 4 enormous meals a day (usually including a large lunch she cooks herself around 2 PM, hot dinner eaten with DCs, and a second dinner she cooks herself later on around 9 or 10 PM). Since she barely knows how to cook, this usually ends up creating huge mess in the kitchen and smells all over the house - either that or she uses up instant-type foods which I've purchased to put together for quick weeknight dinners when I'm working, which isn't very helpful. She is a nice enough girl (and fortunately only here for 7 more weeks) but eats like nothing I've ever seen. In between these meals, she's coming down for many "snacks" (sandwiches, massive bowls of cereal, crisps if we had them in the house, hunks of cheese, and massive amounts of any kind of ham or other lunch meat we have in the house (which we ourselves save for weekends as we try to get decent quality stuff and it's expensive), etc.). She literally eats more than DH and me combined.

Am somewhat at my wit's end as (a) she's constantly in the kitchen, which is making me a little nuts, (b) it's costing us a fortune, and (c) am perpetually finding we're just on the verge of running out of milk/juice/bread/cereal as well as finding that literally nothing appears to be off limits, no matter how "fancy" or expensive it might be, whether it might be something we got specifically for the children, whether we might be about to run out of it, or whatever. Our fridge is tiny so no hope of keeping a separate area for AP or anything like that - just not practical. I cannot stand guard over the kitchen cupboards and fridge to see what she's eating - and I guess the point is if she's hungry of course she should eat something...sorry to rant but I guess I'm just looking to see if this is a common experience and if anyone has any words of wisdom!

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
kittywise · 01/06/2009 20:25

When I've had aupairs I've always set out what they can eat/can't eat before hand eg the kids lunch food, unopened packets of things in the fridge.
I tell them I have to plan the week's food carefully, I'm happy to buy in more of what they want but they can't just simply help themselves without asking as it throws out my weekly shop.
I've told them to tell me if they want anything specifically for them. For example one lovely Thai AP loved chicken and lived of it and rice so I bulk bought those for her every week

BoffinMum · 01/06/2009 20:24

PS During the bulimic AP's stay our food bill went from £80-£100 a week for five people to about half as much again, and one week a memorable £185. The financial side of things is a nightmare, I do agree.

She also did this thing where she read in a magazine that eating fish three times a week was good for you, and then bought about £50 worth of it, only to completely ruin it during the cooking process because she couldn't be arsed to follow the recipe (in her mother tongue!!) so our dinner had to go in the bin.

She also used all the printer ink for her digital photos, reconfigured the family PC so it was set up as if it were her own, with lots of memory-hungry software installed, and stole all our batteries and stamps. And lost the mobile phone we lent her. And took the town bike we had lent her off road and wrecked the wheel, only to wreck it again by not parking it sensibly so it got knocked over. And left the garage door open so all our bikes were stolen.

You can probably work out why I never let them have a car ...

BoffinMum · 01/06/2009 20:10

I have had two APs who did this. One was greedy and overweight, and the other was probably bulimic, looking back (even raided the special food I had put by for Xmas, and also started underfeeding the children and eating most of their dinners herself, and they were too young to really be able to tell me - I only found out when I caught her in the act ).

The thing is, it's easy to scoff mountains of food when you're not paying for it, so I would consider simply not doing a great deal of shopping. I find that usually works. I do agree it's dispiriting though.

I am happily AP free at the moment!!

vixma · 31/05/2009 00:07

Is it possible to buy the basics then bring home main meals (food needed) when you have finished work. Crumbs, she is eating alot...hide some of the food? Neighbours fridge. Otherwise talk to her...or create a food allowence, tell her you are cutting back or taking part in a healthy eating scheme. Good luck!

Julesnobrain · 30/05/2009 23:57

When do you pay her? the reason I ask is that we pay ours on a Friday night. We then use that time or a 'feedback session ie what worked well this week/ what didn't. Could you use the next pay day to sit down and say you want to review how its going. Praise her for the positives then add in the negatives E.G We've noticed you cook after 8pm. I'm very sorry but we're not happy with this Could we request if you are hungry after your main meal at 6pm you have 1 bowl of cereal but no cooking at 10pm and then give her more positives. This is a proven management technique which I'm sure has some intelligent consultative name which I forget but I call it the feedback sandwich. Good - bad- good. Using that you should be able to put in corrective behaviour at any stage.

mananny · 30/05/2009 13:36

I think it's perfectly reasonable to sit her down and say, look you're here to live as a member or our family and our family has the following routines to keep everything running smoothly and also keep us within our family budget: we have three meals a day, breakfast, lunch and dinner, and if you're hungry at other times please do help yourself to fruit or toast or cereal. We don't have a fourth cooked meal late at night here and we are finding it's becoming expensive and a little disruptive to provide a fourth meal later at night to you when no one else in the house eats at that time.

It sounds like she's being greedy and taking the pee a little. I'm jealous that she's not the size of a house eating as much as she does!

HarrietTheSpy · 29/05/2009 20:34

Also, no one on here was saying that during the main meals the AP had to eat crap food or not eat what the family was eating during that time. LIke sitting there with a plate of spam while everyone else had pasta and truffle oil. It was trying to think of a way to fund the extra meals that were also happening.

HarrietTheSpy · 29/05/2009 20:33

But the idea is that you're supposed to be part of the family as well.

Sorry but I still think what the OPs au pair is up to is unacceptable and rude and I can understand the parent's point of view very much here. I was working in Russia by the way, not an exchange student.

Laquitar · 29/05/2009 17:37

Harriet, i was talking about Ap not exchange student. APs WORK, usually hard, and they work with your DCs! My question was how can you feed your dcs healthy food-and give them good example-when you plan to feed your AP 'crap food' if they eat together?

HarrietTheSpy · 29/05/2009 08:58

I've lived in France and Italy as an exchange student with a family, and worked in Russia where I was also hosted periodically by people. In Italy - where I was offered tea and a couple of digestives for breakfast - they were being paid to have me so in principle I could have probably "helped myself" more to the fridge content.

You eat what the families offer you and pay attention to what is going on around you. If they have four meals, go ahead. Do not go and stay in someone's home if you aren't able to be observent, it's basic manners in one sense but also I agree with Milarkee part of the cultural experience.

If I had done what the OP described in this situation I would have expected to have my programme directors have a little "chat" with me about my behaviour frankly.

sunnydelight · 29/05/2009 06:14

I also don't understand why you think it's too late to say anything, 7 weeks to go is a long time. It is perfectly reasonable to say that you don't want her cooking after dinner has been cleared away - dinner is the last "proper" meal of the day, if she is still hungry later she can have a snack (list options). My, perpetually hungry, 15 year old knows what he can have to snack on, if he wants anything outside that he asks. An AP is a young person staying in your home, why are they outside the "house rules"?

iloveairplanejelly · 28/05/2009 23:21

to some extent, she may not realized. I am Australian but have lived in London for years but have still not got my head around this 'expensive foods' business. I tend to spend a fortune, but not mean to.

At home things like berries etc cost the same as apples and bananas, it takes a while to equate that - esp. if you're not doing the shopping.

Julesnobrain · 28/05/2009 20:46

Laquitar. I think the problem is that it is not an extra few pounds, that no one minds. We had a Greek AP who ate completely normally and as a result enjoyed a wide variety of good quality foods but then you have an another AP who eats the whole pinapple you brought and the 2 papayas, plus all the biscusits plus plus..... literally the day you buy them. That is just plain selfish and piggy and in the end you so resent both the sheer volume and the selfish race to eat all the good quality foods first when you have a whole family to feed then you (the host Mum) either have to simmer with resentment, hide food, or just have it out with the AP and lay down strict rules which make you look like a control freak... but !! what else are you supposed to do.

Millarkie · 28/05/2009 20:38

Surely part of the cultural experience of the au pair is to eat as 'the locals'?
And it's not 'a few pounds', our food bill is up by almost 50%. Our au pair's 'pocket money' fades into insignificance compared to the other costs of having her here.
We tend to end up with us eating more cheaply (own-brands and discount brands) in order to buy the au pair's food and stay within budget..which does make it tempting just to get rid of the au pair!

Laquitar · 28/05/2009 20:15

In many countries it is the norm to eat big hot lunch and they dont count s/w and crisps as lunch. But i don't know about 4 big meals . Was she babysitting last night?

Tbh i don't understant it when posters say 'buy her some crap'. Apart from the fact that it is rude, even from a selfish point of view how is this good for the children? how can you 'ban' 'expensive' fruits when she eats with the dcs? and is it worth for few extra pounds?

PaulaAtMummyKnowsBest · 28/05/2009 10:45

my last au pair ate too much as well

She was complaining afetr 2 weeks that none of her clothes fitted her anymore and that she had put on 5 kg and didn't know why

It is so frustrating and so very expensive.

She had other "issues" aswell though so we asked her to leave 3 months earlier than planned

LynetteScavo · 28/05/2009 09:01

I would certainly ban frying food in the evening! That would drive me up the wall. If she's hungry she can have cereal or a sandwhich - and I would also insist she leaves the kitchen spotless!

FabulousBakerGirl · 28/05/2009 08:46

MizZan - I don't think it is too late to tell her things. If she dd something unacceptable with the kids you would tell her. This is a house rule and she should be told otheriwse resentment will set in and that is no good for anyone.

I au paired abroad and just can't understand this eating business.

FourArms · 28/05/2009 07:28

Our French ap always ate a lot later than we did too. If DH is away I quite often eat at 5pm with the DSs. Our ap literally couldn't eat at that time, and would just reheat food for later, or cook for herself.

Your situation does sound horrible. We only had problems with milk consumption - coffee and tea made with milk only instead of water. Fine as a treat, but not for every drink. So when 4 aps were round for a chat, we could go through 6 pints in an afternoon!

MizZan · 28/05/2009 00:19

OK, have just come home from night out with friends to find that after eating a full meal with DCs at 6 PM (salmon, couscous, veg), AP came down at 10 PM and cooked herself another meal.

Jules, think your approach is the right one re setting expectations (part of problem here is that AP seems to still be operating on home country time despite having been in the UK for 10 months) and that for the next one we will also just institute a rule that there is to be no cooking in the kitchen by APs after 8 PM as I am not happy coming home to a house that smells of fried food at all hours of day/night. Aagh. As she's been here 5 weeks already I don't feel I can tell her now all of a sudden she's not allowed to cook in the evening any more, should have set clear rules at the beginning but I first figured she'd settle in once she saw our family's usual habits, and then thought I'd circumvent the problem by just having her eat with DCs, little knowing that she would require an additional meal after that.

ah well, lessons learned for next time. Will be much stricter re food/use of kitchen and will specify 3 meals a day and what can be eaten as "snacks" if still hungry.

OP posts:
thebody · 27/05/2009 23:05

Jesus, you have my sympathy,

my teens boys eat us out of house and home but they are ours.. be totally peed off
otherwise,

Label all your own foods i.e family or kids and get in some cheap crap for her to gorge on and tell the greedy bugger to contribute some of her own, pehaps she has worms, seriously what an awfully annoying situation, especially as she is thin.. thats just not fair imo..

Julesnobrain · 27/05/2009 22:57

Hi - Poor you. I posted something similar about 8 months back. it was incredibly stressful as well as expensive and it has altered how I deal with subsequent AP's. First off I now tell them they can have any food unless it is the kids chocolate or anything labelled with my husbands name (I related to the stilton comment!!) and occasionally we do buy food X and I specifically point it out and ask her not to eat it. Secondly I now discuss with them on arrival our expectations of their eating habits by saying in England we eat cereal for breakfast with a slice of toast or sometimes eggs. For lunch we eat a sandwich, packet of crisps, piece of fruit, in the evening we eat a cooked meal, with a yoghurt/fruit for pudding, you can eat this with DC or us depending on time etc. If you want the snacks we have fruit/biscuits. I also mention we eat to a budget and if they want some special food we will consider it but if it is expensive then we may not buy it. I also cover off off that we try to do our main shop once a week and can she tell us if we have run out of XYZ food or if she's used the last of it. Because I have discovered AP's can rarely cook I make sure I cook them a meal every day which I put in the fridge, plated up for her to eat either when she wants or with DC when they have theirs. That is also a good way to control the cost. It is incredibly hard to change their habits once their established. Current AP munching her way through 24 yoghurts a week. This week when she told me she was out I told her I'd brought her 24, that I was not buying anymore until I was going to do the main shopping and that next week she needed to make them last a week. I felt really mean but we just can't afford the massive hike in food bills.

Pollyanna · 27/05/2009 20:47

(I didn't mean that to sound awful - I mean we have been lucky not to have the same problem as the OP, but that I do worry that my aps aren't eating and that they are passing on bad eating habits to my dds).

Millarkie · 27/05/2009 20:47

Willow - as for 'off limits' food, we have learnt that if we point anything out and specifically say 'that is dh's (or whoever's) favourite XXXX' then it will disappear, sure as eggs-is-eggs. (even if it has carbs in )
Much sympathy for you Mizzan. The only other thing I can think of is saying that she can have a food budget of £40 a week or something, and handing over the money for her to get her own food..but then I still think that 'your' food would get snacked on.
I asked a few questions about food/eating from my next AP's referee, she probably thinks I'm obsessed - unless she's a mumsnetter

Pollyanna · 27/05/2009 20:45

I do have food that is off limits to the ap -I menu plan and write down the food for the week (for the dcs and aps meals) and ask the ap not to eat any of that food. She is welcome to eat everything else in the fridge/cupboard, with the proviso that if she eats the last of anything, she writes it on the list.

I will also buy anything she wants if she writes it on the list. I did tell her though, that I won't buy chocolate (or the like) for her as I don't buy it for anyone else in the house.

I have been very lucky with aps though - like others, most of my aps don't seem to eat anything.

Swipe left for the next trending thread