Please or to access all these features

Paid childcare

Discuss everything related to paid childcare here, including childminders, nannies, nurseries and au pairs.

What would you do in this childcare situation? Nanny or boarding school?

133 replies

Pawslikepaddington · 16/02/2009 11:06

In three years (miles away, I know, but I'm already worrying!) I will have an 8 y/o dd. I am a single parent and I can't see that changing. For one year, I will be working 8am until 10pm almost every weekday, and so don't know what would be best.

My hours after that year will be bad, but I can bring work home, so will not be stuck in the office, so am more likely to be able to pick dd up from school and drop her off etc.

I went to a boarding school at 11, and those that boarded from 8 loved going (she would be a weekly boarder), but to me 11 seems too young, let alone 8. But on the plus side she would be able to stay on at the school then as a day pupil once this awful year was over.

Dd will have to move schools that year anyway, as we have to move out of the area we are in at the moment (she is in state at the moment, and will stay in state if we get a nanny).

A nanny seems like a much better option for me, but would they be ok with these kind of hours? They seem very long! And we would be talking a lot of money wouldn't we, as I would have to leave the house at 6.30/7am each morning, so the nanny would have to be there from 6.30am until 10pm.

This is worst case scenario hours-wise, but sadly it also looks like it will be the most likely one. I know this is a dreadful situation to put dd in, but it is for the best, or I would not be doing it. I feel dreadful about it already.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Pawslikepaddington · 16/02/2009 11:24

Thank you all-thought you were all going to beat me with a big, flaming, child-dumping brush! Am so glad there seem to be nanny-based options, am absolutely over the moon about that. If I had a live in nanny, would she be ok with still living with us during the weekends, but not working IYSWIM? Am worried an au-pair would be too inexperienced for such a long day. DD will be at f-t school, and probably brownies and swimming as after school activities. Oooh, it might mean I can stay in Cambridge if I'm lucky and commute in, as this is sounding more possible!

OP posts:
MrsWobble · 16/02/2009 11:21

you should get a live in nanny and expect to have a lot of discussion upfront about hours. You will be able to give her time off in the day when your dd is at school but you will be putting a lot of restriction on her ability to have a social life - would you require the same hours on a friday night for example?

also bear in mind that your dd will be spending a lot of her time with the nanny - and very little time with you. (This is not meant as a judgemental comment by the way - but a factual statement). I think you should therefore consider the personality of the nanny and how she would get on with your dd as a very important recruitment criteria and I think it probably restricts you to native English speakers.

We had an Australian nanny who would have suited this type of role so I think you would be able to find someone - but be realistic about what the job requires - for both the nanny's sake and, more importantly, your daughter's.

Pawslikepaddington · 16/02/2009 11:20

Thanks wooden spoon. I feel like I am letting dd down so much. I have always been there for her, which is one of the reasons I started studying in the first place, but it has taken on a momentum of its own and I feel like I am abandoning her, but want (need even) some financial security and job security for us, which this will bring, hopefully for life.

OP posts:
Coldtits · 16/02/2009 11:20

For one 8 year old girl, I can't see a nanny objecting to working 7 til 10, but you need a live in one. Then she will just be a housewife who gets paid! As your daughter will presumable be at full time school.

dustbuster · 16/02/2009 11:17

Poor you - this sounds like a stressful thing to have to deal with.

Perhaps you could have a combination of live-out nanny and live-in au pair if the hours were going to be too long?

Pawslikepaddington · 16/02/2009 11:17

I have spoken to the people I will be working for and they say that the first year (as a trainee) you are the first in and last to leave, otherwise they don't take you on at the end of it. There is another avenue I can go into, which would be much more tolerable, especially with regards to the hours, but only the top 2 or 3 students (which sadly is not me) can do it, although I am trying to get there!!

OP posts:
woodenspoon2 · 16/02/2009 11:16

F/t nanny costs much more than boarding school. Could you have a live-in nanny? - who would then have time off during the day when your daughter is at school. I imagine that is your best bet. A nanny who was studying might be happy to have the time off in the middle of the day

tootiredtothink · 16/02/2009 11:13

How do you know already what your hours will be in three years time?

If 11 seems young to you (did you enjoy it?), then 8 certainly is. You shouldn't really need to ask.

I'm sure the money you would be spending on her boarding school will cover the cost of a nanny.