Please or to access all these features

Paid childcare

Discuss everything related to paid childcare here, including childminders, nannies, nurseries and au pairs.

what would you do if your nanny has lots of unscheduled absences?

33 replies

MGMidget · 15/12/2008 18:01

The other day I calculated our nanny has had 11 per cent (i.e. more than one in ten) of days she should have been at work as unscheduled absence. By that I mean not pre-planned holiday but time off for sickness or personal reasons. This has been going on for nine months since we employed her. I've tried giving her a financial incentive to turn up as we now dock her pay for days off (apart from any statutory sick pay which has never kicked in so far) as we are contractually entitled to do. However, the problem lately is that she seems to have had a series of unfortunate circumstances which have clearly upset her. Family pet got ill and had to be put down, then a not immediate but not too distant family member was rushed to hospital, thought to be close to death and now her father has a potential serious illness. Each time she has taken a week off with no prior warning making it very difficult to get childcare at short notice and jeapardising my work. She seems to be so wrapped up in her own problems that she doesn't seem aware of the impact it has on me. As she is so upset by things I feel terrible raising her absences as a concern or making it a 'disciplinary' matter but frankly I can't continue to employ her if her attendance doesn't improve. Not sure how to tackle this as I don't know if others would think me totally unreasonable to expect her to turn up for work rather than grieve for her dead pet or visit a sick relative in hospital? I think the real problem is her circumstances - e.g. sick relative and dog hundreds of miles away (family pet lives with her mum). Hence the need for a week off when something happens! Hubby relunctant to let her go as thinks next nanny could be as bad or worse and we should stick with what we know and see the positives - e.g. she is good with my son when she actually turns up for work. Anyone got any thoughts what they would do in these circumstances?

OP posts:
MadamDeathstarOverBethlehem · 15/12/2008 18:31

He quit shortly after the written warning with one day's notice instead of two weeks. He expected me to beg him to stay. Instead my Team Leader and I went down to the parking lot and were doing the Happy Happy Joy Joy dance and high fiving each other.

Then we went to HR and started the paperwork for a new technician. The one we got was not only better, but turned up for work every day on time as well.

HarrietTheSpy · 15/12/2008 18:30

sorry you already explained your current arrangement re not paying her.

Can you tell her the unpaid leave isn't working for you - that you are struggling to find cover for her days off - and that you're terribly sorry but you can't accommodate it. If it were HER health or a really close relation, I'd think harder about it. But there is no way that under similar circumstances your employer would tolerate that for long, I don't see why you need to.

After a year it's more complicated to dismiss someone, so you should come to some sort of resolution soon...sorry, I know you probably know this but just in case.

Millarkie · 15/12/2008 18:29

I would not expect anyone (whatever their job) to take time off to grieve for a pet - to take it to the vet - yes, to nurse a very very sick pet - yes, but once pet has been put down I would expect gritted teeth and back to work! (Maybe I'm mean but my employers would not give me unscheduled leave for it).
Ill father I would accept for a couple of days trip, ill other-relative (assuming that closer relatives are still around) I would say not.

My first nanny ran rings round us taking days off for 'ill aunt' 'granny fell down the stairs' (her mother was available to be with granny, as was nanny's sisters but they needed the whole family by the bedside for 3 days), car stuck in mud, car spare wheel stolen, nanny was 'tired' because she was woken in the night by her toddler son (had 2 days off sick for that)....In the end I had to spell it out to her - I was appearing unreliable at my work (dh worked away most days so couldn't share the burden), and it was putting my job at risk..and therefore her job too. She didn't change and we parted (although this was made easier as we moved out of the area)

My advice would be to point out the affects on your own job, and that people are being made redundant all over the place at the moment and that you will no longer accept short notice for leave (ie. scheduled leave only) - not much you can do about sick leave that you aren't already doing!
We have changed childcarers a few times now - and all of them have been great with the kids, and with all of them I have worried about how the children will take the change - and every time, the old childcarer is forgotten very quickly and the new one accepted..children are very adaptable (more than me I find!)
Good luck.

MadamDeathstarOverBethlehem · 15/12/2008 18:29

When we started tracking the attendance of one of my employees I was shocked to find his unscheduled attendances were 7.5% of his time (not including vacation time). He got a written warning as soon as we were aware of it. My Team Leader and I knew it was bad, we didn't know it was THAT bad.

This equated to about 18 days in a year.

hollyivypoppy34 · 15/12/2008 18:24

how can the next one be worse? at the very least talk to her and agree re the holiday session - what does contract say re time off as I'd be starting to think abotu giving a warning.

MadamDeathstarOverBethlehem · 15/12/2008 18:23

You have to talk to her. If you lose your job, she will lose hers too. If she is great every other way you don't want to lose her, but if she isn't there it really doesn't matter how great she is, does it?

Can you go by the attendance policies that a company would normally have?

At my last place of work we had to track attendance. Coming in late counted as a half occurrence, missing a half day or whole day counted as a whole occurrence. When the person got up to a total of 6 they got a written warning. A written warning lasted for 6 months. If there were no more absences during the 6 months the notice would be taken out of the personnel folder.

After three written warnings in their folder they were dismissed at the next absence. Even though someone would need to come in late about 36 times to be fired, there were still people who did so, and were.

In case this sounds heartless, if they had a good reason for absences the manager would usually work with them to help resolve the situation. I had a single mother working for me who was always late in as she had to take her children to the sitter. I just moved her shift hours so she was no longer late as it worked for my department.

Personally I would be heartbroken if my pet died, but I would still go into work. Similarly we would have been given 3 days off if an immediate relative died, but a cousin, aunt or uncle would have required vacation time to attend a funeral.

Maybe start this thread again in Employment issues to find out what the norm is for attendance at a place of business.

You have to decide whether she is your friend or your employee. Given that your job depends on her doing her job, I think you have to go down the employee route and treat her accordingly.

MGMidget · 15/12/2008 18:16

Hi Harriet,
She works for me 3 days a week. I can't remember all the numbers now but she has had 11.5 days off and I calculated that as a percentage of the total number of days she should have been at work since she started, excluding pre-planned holiday dates. Given her now ill father and sick relative who has been given a couple of months to live I am fully expecting some more unscheduled leave in the near future. Apparently the 'average' unscheduled leave for a typical employee in the UK is about 3 per cent.

OP posts:
HarrietTheSpy · 15/12/2008 18:08

Midget
I'm confused by the percentage. Over the nine months, how many days has she had off?

What I would do personally is say any time off in connection with pets, other relations etc has to be taken as holiday time. Then get doctor's notices for her illness periods. Don't let her being upset put you off doing this, and your DH shouldn't worry about whether the next person would be worse. We made this mistake with our first nanny and found lovely ones subsequently.