Please or to access all these features

Paid childcare

Discuss everything related to paid childcare here, including childminders, nannies, nurseries and au pairs.

Giving feedback after childminder interviews

29 replies

squishysquashy · 12/10/2012 13:16

I've recently interviewed a few childminders. I found 'the one' (very happy) but I now have to let the others know. I'm not sure whether I should give feedback on why I didn't choose them?

One of them I had a few issues and I'm not sure if it would be helpful to let her know about them:

  1. We thought the TV would be on too much (large widescreen in play room and reading between the lines of our discussion we thought it would be on quite regularly)

  2. She already had 3 under 5s (I know she would be 'allowed' a fourth because the youngest was a sibling) but was saying about how since the rules had changed there were no limits. I know from on here that's not correct and she may have misunderstood.

  3. She passed me a mug of hot coffee over the top of DDs head (could have easily walked up to me from a different angle).

I don't want to sound judgy and I'm not sure how I can feed these back to her in a nice way, she did seem a nice lady.

Lastly, one of the other childminders was very good, very professional and was a close contender. The main reason I didn't choose her was because I felt she would have a more teacher/pupil relationship with DD and I chose the childminder who was more towards the parent/child end of the scale. I want to give positive feedback to her as she was very good but DH thinks she would be insulted by saying this?

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
lambethlil · 12/10/2012 13:46
Grin There are so many more variables, though. If you fail an interview it's 100% down to your performance and experience, whereas appointing a childminder could come down to many factors outside the CMs control. It's great that you're getting back to them, and will be appreciated. Feedback something positive and x
squishysquashy · 12/10/2012 13:41

That's what DH says lambethlil!

But if I have an unsuccessful interview I always want to know why...

OP posts:
wishiwasonholiday · 12/10/2012 13:21

It's good that you are going to ring back, most don't bother ringing back here then I hear twisted versions from other childminders of why they didn't choose each cm.

The one with siblings would bother me though, the sibling would have to start last she can't just take new business on because she's got siblings, maybe you could somehow point this out?

The others I'm not sure what you should say though but sure someone else will.

lambethlil · 12/10/2012 13:19

Blimey. You are way overthinking this. If they ask for feedback, and it's unlikely, say you liked the way they... But decided to go with another CM.