Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Baby names

Find baby name inspiration and advice on the Mumsnet Baby Names forum.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Curious about how to match siblings names

113 replies

MarchNowFebMum · 24/03/2009 09:08

There's often posts on here about how to pick names that 'match' the older siblings.

I may be dim but I don't get it - what are the rules of matching? Obviously Connie and Bonnie sounds hideous together but I don't get what logic people use to respond to these questions.

This is a serious question - worried I'll make a mistep with dc2!

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
BristolRabbit · 26/03/2009 16:34

I have a Max already and number two on way.

If a girl we were jokingly going to call her Minnie... but we probably wont dare! I like Mariella or Lily at the moment.

But boys names are foxing us! Any ideas for a good - "go with but not too similar" name for a brother for Max??

thell · 26/03/2009 16:34

I've heard of brothers called Richard and Ricardo - the same name in different languages, surely??!

lhg32 · 26/03/2009 16:13

I made it my mission to have childrens names that a) didnt match and b) where completely different from everyone we new.

That didnt quite work Rio DD1 is fairly unusual but DD1 wanted to name DD2 and choose Daisy. However i drew the line then and took over for the other 2 . Beau for DS3 and Serge for DS4.

nikki1978 · 26/03/2009 15:51

The same initial thing is VERY annoying. My Dad is called Neil, I am Nicola and for some weird reason he wanted to call his son Neil too. So there were 3 N Kirby's in our family and the post thing drove us all mad. As did the phonecalls asking for Neil Kirby.... 'which one senior or junior?' most of the time people didn't know

MerryMarigold · 26/03/2009 14:22

I think it's really personal what you think 'goes' but you can always ask and MNetters are not short of opinions on names!

I have an Oliver and really liked 'Blythe' for dd but it felt too modern and different compared to Oliver which is traditional and commonplace! I was looking for something which 'went' but ended up with Mirissa which is a place name and very unusual - so I guess some people would think it doesn't 'go' with Oliver, but I don't think it clashes IYSWIM. And he is Oli, she is Miri, so 'goes' better thay way.

Flossi a third 'ee' sound may be a bit much. I know I have 2 , but my other child is Jude, so no 'ee' sounds on the end of his name!

wastingmyeducation · 26/03/2009 14:19

Kathryn, it's Ted 'Theodore' Logan (and Bill S. Preston, Esquire). I may have seen that movie a few times when I was younger.

MarchNowFebMum · 26/03/2009 14:09

Leon and Dion is outrageous!

I don't see what the problem with Liam and Alfie and Matthew and Harrison are - especially the second two seem to be on the same social register (whatever that is).

The Teguela I know is nic named Tiggy - guess you have to figure that in too!

OP posts:
FleeBee · 26/03/2009 13:40

My two nephews are named Leon and Dion, I still cringe but hey my sister-in-law really likes it!!

Expecting baby 2 soon and my DD's name starts with P but pronounced as an F, I really like Poppy but concerned that 2 P names will look silly. Hope that baby is a boy as will be named after my grandfather Jack. Easy.

Flossi · 26/03/2009 12:40

Already have a Harry and Libby and thinking of katie or Jamie for the next one due soon.........what do you think!

KathrynAustin · 26/03/2009 10:38

I have Edward & William. Didn't really think about it at the time but SO many people have said "Oh, like Bill & Ted".....

It doesn't bother me, just didn't occur to me before.

The other comment we get is "Very royal names", that does get to me, like we're wanna be aristocracy!

Anyway, I still love the names and they do seem to go well together!

Strawbezza · 26/03/2009 10:19

I overheard a woman talking about "Ralph and Elaine" - I presumed they were her neighbours or in-laws or something - turns out they are her pre-school children.

Lancelottie · 26/03/2009 09:48

Grapes -- go for it! Philippa, Isabella, Victoria, Matilda, Etheldreda... no probs there, surely?

(though be prepared for a lot of shortening if so -- I know a family of girls called Felicity, Elizabeth, Victoria and Katherine, known to all as Fizz, Liz, Vick and Kate)

Housemum · 26/03/2009 09:40

Worzel - I know another George and Grace so not so unusual a combo (assuming that your Grace is older than Geroge as you named her first so you can't be the same person!)

Alistair - LOL at Bert and ERnie (am assuming you are joking...)

I really don't like the whole same-initials thing - I knew someone who was so keen on the letter K once that their 4th was called Kristopher just so they could get another K in.

Littlepurple - know what you mean, 3 Finlays/Finleys in DD2's school year, I'm sure everyone thought it was an unusual name until they all went to school. Names go like that sometimes.

I never gave any thought to how the names went together - I think the orgiins of their names are German, Greek and French. Emma, Georgina and Amelie. I think in one of the baby name books Emma and Georgina were lumped in the same category of "Old English charm" which means DD3 should have been Amelia but I didn't like the long "ee" sound in the middle hence the French version. (She just gets called Amelia or Amy Lee by most people who read her name anyway...)

Littlepurpleprincess · 26/03/2009 08:41

Squirdle - I have a Caleb too! And I love it because it is unusual but at the same time it's really old and it's not silly unusual, if you know what I mean.

Also, steer well away from Finnley, anyone who considers it. I work in childcare and every other child I've cared for is called Finnley (or Tyler). There are bloddy MILLIONS of them. The entire country will be named either Finnley or Tyler at this rate.

g4grapes · 25/03/2009 22:53

I went with Charlotte for DD1, then had DTs both girls! Went for Elizabeth and Alexandra, following a quite unintentional english regal theme! Thinking of having a go for a fourth and have been trawling lists to find another regal female name we like, just in case! Boys names were all picked out and ready to go, but no joy so far!
Don't feel you have to theme, go with whatever you think is best, and that you like, they are your children after all!

PixiNanny · 25/03/2009 22:36

Mine and my sisters names are all English and Iranian names, and Mum is English and Dad is Iranian. My sisters names are Tina and Dana, I got stuck with the commonly more British Nikki

Linnet · 25/03/2009 21:31

My dd's names go well together one starts with a K and the other with a C (pronounced like a k) which means that although they go well together I spend half my time called the wrong child by the wrong name as they start with the same sound.

There are twins in my family called Sam and Pam, I think they're in their 40's now.

Blocka · 25/03/2009 20:42

Haha, I love this thread. I have a dd and had a name in mind if I ever get a ds - but having read all of this I think it would be out on a socio-cultural AND sounding basis. I still like the names, though!

TabithaTwitchet · 25/03/2009 20:38

I knew a couple where the dad was from Syria and the mum was Norwegian. One child had an arabic name, the other a traditional Scandinavian name. They didn't seem to go together but they did if you knew the family background.

kelsgrrr · 25/03/2009 20:06

When we picked our girls names. Abigail was very last minute but we always thought of what it could/maybe shortened to, hence we call her Abi, which we love. The other half liked Amelea potentially for our second but I was thinking two with the same intials. Nightmare when they start getting post!! Weird I know. So we went for Bonnie our other option and Amelea as a middle name. Go for names you like and dont worry about matching.

AlistairSim · 25/03/2009 19:51

We have a Bert and an Ernie.

They seem to go together quite well.

BlaDeBla · 25/03/2009 19:45

How about Sertraline for a girl and Prozac for a boy?

BeehiveBaby · 25/03/2009 19:42

I named DD1 after DH's gran and DD2 after DH's great aunt (ie his gran's sister). There are three more sisters to go through if necessary but the two we have are both Dicken's characters too, so we could go go there

blackrock · 25/03/2009 19:37

I live miles away from my sister, so matching or non so names, no longer an issue. If they don't sound great together, it doesn't matter. They could choose a terribly matched partner name (sur or fore) in adulthood.

Squirdle · 25/03/2009 19:23

In Walers!!