Please or to access all these features

Baby names

Find baby name inspiration and advice on the Mumsnet Baby Names forum.

Baby name anxiety - Jack or Finn

29 replies

SJC88 · 25/11/2025 20:10

My sweet little boy (2nd child) is almost 5 months old. We didn't know the gender and looking back, didn't discuss baby names enough. We had a shortlist, but once he was born we quite quickly individually vetoed each other's choices. The only name left was Finn (my partners first choice) but I had a funny relationship with (on one hand loved it as it seemed to suit him perfectly, but was apprehensive about using an Irish name).

We however settled in Finn at 2 weeks old, but before telling everyone his name I had a real wobble and decided I couldn't call him that. Eventually we came up with a compromise name (Jack), and registered the birth at 6 weeks as Jack.

However it never sat easily and we constantly discussed changing it (to Finn or something else). I have since realised that I've perhaps not been in a great headspace. There is nothing objectively wrong with Jack, but I can't shake that it was such a last ditch selection.

I feel sadness looking back that we never got to positively announce his name as it was a real source of anguish for me. I feel I failed in the one simple thing a parent should do when they bring a child into the world! I loved my daughters name, and sad and embarassed I couldn't have the same experience for my son.

As an additional complication, I told my extended family at 3 months old we were changing it to Finn but never followed through.... so now people know him by two names!! Yikes, what a self created conundrum.

Should we change his name? If so, whats the best way to announce it? Middle name is Alexander.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
DuchessOfNarcissex · 25/11/2025 20:23

Both are nice, but I think you know he's really Finn. Get the birth certificate changed and stick to Finn.

If your surname starts with T...

goingtotown · 25/11/2025 20:21

Jack is a lovely name, too many Finn’s & Jude’s.

NuffSaidSam · 25/11/2025 20:14

Personally I prefer Finn, but Jack is also a solid name.

I'd add both in so you can tell him this story when he's older.

Jack Finn Alexander.

Day to day call him whichever suits him best.

Lemonysnickety · 25/11/2025 20:11

I adore Finn