Critique my list

Robin if a boy and Robyn if a girl was my list!

Boys

Robin - its ok, just not my style
Dexter - i like it
Nathaniel - its on our list but im unsure if i like Nate
Isaac - like but dislike how popular it is
Oliver - not a fan, dislike Ollie
Elijah - nice
Jesse - not a fan at all
Caleb - I like it

Girls

Eloise - not a fan
Frances - not a fan, think it sounds too serious
Julia - ok
Esther - like it and like it shortened to Essie
Alma - like
Riva - dislike
Alessia - ok
Robyn - prefer on a girl
Morgan - prefer on a boy. Like Morgana
Louisa - nice
Eleanor - like but dislike Ellie
Isla - boring
Evelyn - ok
Margot - nice enough
Iris - lovely

Robin- find it a bit dated, and wet
Dexter- reminds me dexters lab
Nathaniel- ok
Isaac- like
Oliver - too many
Elijah- meh
Jesse- ok
Caleb- don’t like sound for some reason

Girls
Eloise- like
Frances- dated
Julia - like
Esther- like
Alma- ok
Riva- like river
Alessia - not a fan
Robyn- not fan, dated
Morgan- dislike, not pretty at all
Louisa- like
Eleanor- meh. Don’t like Ellie
Isla- too many
Evelyn- ok but not fan of Evie
Margot- growing on me, still not sure though
Iris- love this one

Love Robin for a boy or a girl - favourite from both lists.

Followed by Dexter, Oliver, Frances, Alessia and Margot.

Boys
Robin - it’s ok
Dexter - not keen. Cartoonish.
Nathaniel - like
Isaac - like
Oliver - like but too popular
Elijah - like
Jesse - it’s ok
Caleb - not keen, means dog

Girls
Eloise - it’s ok but I think of the spoilt character
Frances - it’s ok
Julia - love this!
Esther - like
Alma - sounds like a laundry detergent
Riva - don’t like
Alessia - it’s ok
Robyn - not keen
Morgan - like
Louisa - love
Eleanor - like but don’t like Ellie
Isla - too popular
Evelyn - like
Margot - a bit too trendy
Iris - a bit too trendy

I’d go with Nathaniel, Elijah or Isaac from your boys’ list and Louisa, Julia, Morgan or Evelyn for a girl.

Riva, not Rivaldo 🤣

Isaac and Iris are my favourites

Evelyn dislike anyway but there are too many Evies, Evelyn’s, Eva and Avas. Every other girl is an Evie.

I like Isla but it’s massively popular. Can’t stand Frances, wet drippy name, or Robin/Robyn.

Oliver is in the same category as Evie, it’s so overused.

I love Elijah, like Eloise and Louisa,Jesse and Caleb.

Boys
Robin ok
Dexter ok
Nathaniel lovely
Isaac lovely
Oliver done to death
Elijah love
Jesse ok
Caleb love

Girls
Eloise like
Frances dislike
Julia dislike
Esther dislike
Alma no
Riva no
Alessia love
Robyn ok
Morgan ok
Louisa like
Eleanor ok
Isla no
Evelyn no
Margot no
Iris no

Boys

Love - Isaac, Nathaniel, Jesse
Like - Robin, Elijah
Ok - Caleb, Dexter
Dislike - Oliver

Girls

Love - Julia (1st by a mile), Robyn, Isla, Iris, Louisa
Like - Eloise, Evelyn, Esther
Ok - Alma, Rivaldo, Alessia
Dislike - Frances, Morgan, Margot

One of the nicest lists I've seen in awhile, OP.

For boys, these are some of my very favourite names:

Robin
Nathaniel
Jesse
Caleb

And for girls I love:

Frances
Esther
Alma
Robyn
Eleanor

Lovely list, but isn't Morgan a boy's name? My grandfather was named Morgan. Maybe it's a unisex name and I'm embarrassing myself. But, I love Eloise and Evelyn!

Boys
Robin - Not keen
Dexter - Like
Nathaniel - Like, but prefer Nathan
Isaac - Prefer Zac
Oliver - too popular
Elijah - Not keen
Jesse - Dislike
Caleb - Favourite of your list

Girls
Eloise - Not keen
Frances - Dislike
Julia - Bit meh
Esther - Old lady
Alma - as above
Riva - love, prefer Reeva spelling
Alessia - nice
Robyn - nice
Morgan - ok
Louisa - dislike
Eleanor - bit meh
Isla - too popular
Evelyn - dislike
Margot - really dislike
Iris - nice

Boys
Robin
Dexter
Nathaniel
Isaac
Oliver
Elijah
Jesse
Caleb

They are all nice names. I'll add Felix and George.

Girls
Eloise
Frances
Julia
Esther
Alma
Riva
Alessia
Robyn
Morgan
Louisa
Eleanor
Isla
Evelyn
Margot
Iris

Not keen on Julia or Morgan. Love Eloise. Prefer Louise to Louisa. Don't like Alessia.

Though Morgan, Caleb, Jesse and Elijah I'd bin.

That's the nicest list I've seen in a while. Julia is just lovely ☺️