Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Baby names

Find baby name inspiration and advice on the Mumsnet Baby Names forum.

Name regret - too much pressure for a miracle baby?

84 replies

FFSparenting · 31/05/2022 16:48

I keep obsessing about my baby's name and wonder if anyone on here felt the same. Maybe it's common to feel this way but this is my first and most likely only baby due to a long journey with fertility issues, multiple losses and failed IVF. I then found myself pregnant naturally out of nowhere after having accepted I would be child free. I now have an amazing baby son who is lovely and doing really well. He is my miracle and the miracle of our family as he is the only grandchild on either side.

We could not decide on name throughout the pregnancy, I had many girls names I would have loved but could not settle on a boys name. Not one that really sparkled and felt right.

We could not decide even after he was born and were getting close to the deadline so settled on a name that I thought I wouldn't regret because it is solid and classic. But perhaps because of my fertility issues the name had to be so special that it was impossible to find one that felt right? I get quite 'meh' responses to his name which I find quite gutting and I find myself not using it and using silly nicknames instead. Does anyone else feel like this? Am I over thinking it?

The name is Jack. I can't help feel there was something better for him and it's casting a shadow over what is an absolute miracle given all our hurdles to have him.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Mariposista · 31/05/2022 17:07

Not all children have names that 'mean' something. The parents give them a name that they like, that will serve them for life, and that's it. Jack is a lovely name - short, sensible, suits a young child, teenager, adult and elderly man. Enjoy being a mum to Jack after such a long time of hoping, and stop worrying.

Caszekey · 31/05/2022 17:03

What reaction are you hoping for? Because is you have a "oh wow", "oh that's cool" type name, I can guarantee you'll also get "what?", "why?" and "poor kid" comments too

Staynow · 31/05/2022 17:02

Jack is a great name because it works at any age and is a classic. I thought you were going to say you'd given him a completely out there name because he was such a miracle, Horatio Quentin Tarquin the third or something. Remember his name doesn't define him, he is the one that will make the name memorable.

rnsaslkih · 31/05/2022 17:00

You’ve given your child a name that can go absolutely anywhere from a prison to a palace. Easy to spell. Easy to pronounce. Timeless. And, in the times we live in, it will be ungoogle-able - even better.

Therefore it’s perfect. It’s highly rated for a reason - people like it.

don’t worry any more about it. It’s great.

HaggisBurger · 31/05/2022 16:56

I think you might be overthinking it yes. Jack is an absolutely lovely name for the reasons you said. To get honest, I don’t think anyone gets any tremendous reactions to baby names, unless negative. Particularly boys names.it’s one of those things that we as parents obsess over and other people are matter of fact in.

I don’t mean to be at all unkind but I don’t think the nature of his being an only grandchild, etc etc hould mean he has an extra special name. All babies are miracles and putting this extra pressure on yourself doesn’t sound that great for you. Enjoy your beautiful miraculous little Jack. I bet he’s just gorgeous 😀

Miriam101 · 31/05/2022 16:53

It's a lovely name; there's absolutely nothing meh about it. Kindly, if this is really "casting a shadow" over your lovely son, maybe there is more at play here: how are your anxiety levels? I don't mean that in a patronising way but speaking from experience I know how anxiety (which can often rear its head post-natally) has a tendency to make one obsess over relatively trivial things rather than the Big Issue at root, whatever that may be. In your case, is it perhaps that you feel pressure to make everything absolutely perfect for this child who so miraculously came into your life? I may be totally wide of the mark of course. But, honestly, Jack is a lovely name.

Kanaloa · 31/05/2022 16:53

So I wouldn’t find the ‘meh’ reactions ‘quite gutting.’ Your baby’s name isn’t for other people and you really can’t expect others to be excited about it. It’s just not that interesting to most people.

Kanaloa · 31/05/2022 16:52

Jack is a lovely name. It’s sensible, sturdy, will suit him as a baby, boy, and a man. A name is to serve the child. He should wear his name, not the other way round. I’ve looked after lots of Jacks, and every one was memorable to me. It really doesn’t matter that the name isn’t ‘special,’ it belongs to a special boy.

As for getting ‘meh’ responses, most people in real life won’t really react much to someone else’s name. You just say ‘oh who’s this? Jack, hello Jack.’

Sally872 · 31/05/2022 16:51

Lovely name, one of my favourites.

But if you really don't like and have another option dh also likes better then change it.