Opinions on my girls name list!

Evelyn, Iris and Lyla are my favourite. I have a niece called Evelyn and her nn has got nothing to do with her actual name. I don't think I've ever heard anyone shorten it. The other 2 are also names I've considered :)

Lauren - very dated, 90s
Caitlin - dated
Lyla - she will get misspelt all the time and as others have said there is a lot of Lila, Lilah, Isla, Maya, Lyra etc around. Also, it just looks like it's a misspelling in an attempt to differentiate it to me which puts me off a bit.
Evelyn - pronunciation issues. It is pretty though.
Olivia - dull
Iris - very popular from around 5 years ago. There are quite a lot around if that matters to you.
Clara - lovely
Leah - really like

Lauren - really like it and, although I know lots of adult Laurens, I don't know any children with this name so it's unusual.
Caitlin - quite like it.
Lyla - like it.
Evelyn - like it.
Olivia - quite like it but feels overused currently.
Iris - love it. Trendy right now but it's beautiful and elegant.
Clara - not keen, it sounds claggy to me.
Leah - it's ok.

I'd go with Iris but none of them are bad choices, imo.

Caitlin and Iris are easily my favourites.

Prefer Clara or the Italian Chiara

Lauren - It's OK but I associate with 1990s. I don't know any under 20.
Caitlin - I've always really liked this. All the ones I know are teenagers.
Lyla - Pretty but overused along with Layla, Lola, Lyra etc.
Evelyn - I like.
Olivia - Still very popular, but I like it.
Iris - I like. Makes me think of the flower.
Clara - My favourite on your list. Love this!
Leah - Pretty and simple.

Iris, Clara or Leah for me

Lauren - not keen, feel like I went to school with quite a few, so it feels dated to me. Lorna?
Caitlin - not keen, though I like Kate. Catrin, Katrina / Catriona?
Lyla - ok, a lot of similar sounding names around. My favourites are Lyra and Leila.
Evelyn - I love Eve - short and simple
Olivia - pretty but popular. Ophelia?
Iris - love
Clara - dislike, Lara is much nicer. Cora, Cara?
Leah - see Lyla

You might also like:

Lara
Skyla
Lucinda
Sorrel
Seren
Lucia
Paloma

Love your list op!

I think my top 3 would be:

Leah
Lauren
Caitlin

Not keen on Olivia though sorry.

It's s nice list

Lauren - I like it, I know a 4 year old Lauren then several in their 30s

Caitlin - I like this two and the NN Catie. I only know two (a 5 year old and an 8 year old)

Lyla - not a fan. L names seem to be everywhere and all blend together. They feel a bit meh

Evelyn - pretty but I know loads, plus loads of Eva's and Evie's too

Olivia - I like (only know 1 5 year old and 1 toddler despite popularity). I prefer Olive though

Iris - love it but it clashes with my surname

Clara - lovely again. I don't know any

Leah - it's nicer than alot of other L names. I like that it's biblical so had history

A few suggestions that seem similar in style:

Lyra
Lorelei
Hannah
Bethany
Carla
Erica
Viola
Rebecca

I love lyla

Lauren - nice
Caitlin - nice
Lyla - sounds daft
Evelyn - nice
Olivia - nice
Iris - not for me
Clara - dull
Leah - cheap

Iris or Clara

If you like Lyla, how about Lyra? I like how it reminds me of Lyrical.

I know a few Lylas, Lilas and a lot of Islas!

Some of your names are too old fashioned for me (I'm in my 60's so some just conjure up images of old ladies from my childhood), however:
Lauren - very pretty
Caitlin - love this
Lyla - too common (at least in the school where I work, one class has 3 of various spellings but same pronunciation)
Evelyn - sorry, too old lady for me.
Olivia - pretty but well used
Iris - I like it but have a cousin Iris who is in ger late 70's, so too old lady for me.
Clara - always reminds me of my favourite book as a child, (Heidi), so yes
Leah -loved this when I was younger and still like it a lot.

It is so hard to choose, it felt like a huge responsibility when we were naming our dcs. Good luck.

Lauren - my daughters name so love it
Caitlin - No
Lyla - No, too many similar sounding like like Lyra, Lola, Layla, Myla, Mila, Maya, Mia etc, all starting to blend into one
Evelyn - Really dislike this, one of the older names I cannot get behind
Olivia - My name
Iris - No
Clara - Gorgeous, my favourite along with Lauren
Leah - Its ok, not great but not awful

Lauren - lovely
Caitlin - my favourite
Lyla - not to my taste, really
Evelyn - lovely
Olivia - awful. I cannot understand the popularity of this name at all
Iris - I find this quite harsh, somehow
Clara - lovely
Leah - lovely, my #2 from these

Lauren - like
Caitlin - LOVE
Lyla - not keen
Evelyn - not keen
Olivia - like but common
Iris - Not keen on the old lady name trend
Clara - cool name
Leah - like but boring?

Suggestions:
Hannah (could be considered boring but always loved it)
Jasmine
Coral
Orla
Eloise
Elodie

Iris, Lyla and Evelyn. Not keen on the others.

Lauren - nice enough but quite dated atm; would the more timeless Laura work for you?
Caitlin - ditto
Lyla - I don't like that spelling, Lilah is quite nice
Evelyn - OK
Olivia - OK but very popular
Iris - gorgeous name
Clara - meh
Leah - sounds pretty but looks ugly

How on earth is Lyla a ‘naughty girl’ name? What prominent ‘naughty girl’ character is named Lyla?

If you mean ‘working class people use this name so I find it gross’ then just say that and own your horrible opinions.

1. Clara
2. Leah
3. Olivia
4. Lauren