Score out of ten!

Penelope - would you use the full name?
Elizabeth - classic, many nick names
Clementine - yes quite innocent
Hermione - Harry Potter
Phoebe - I like
Madeline - too sweet
Zoey - people may think it's a nickname. Can be hard to live up to
Felicity - elderly person name
Beatrice - Princess, quite okay but I don't really like any one th enick names
Best for me: Phoebe

Boys
Toby - too biblical?
Digby - no, to me like a dog's name
Lochlan - Scottish connection? How des it go with your surname?
James - classic but that can make it a boring choice. Ages well.
Oscar - Wilde. Good.
Charles - too common IHMO
Zachary - Quinto
Maxwell - I like
James - as above
Caspian - considered this but for ever the Narnia connection and sea connection

Best for me: Maxwell

We have similar taste in girls names, I never usually find so many of our shortlisted names on one list!

Girls
Penelope 8
Elizabeth 1
Clementine 8
Hermione 8
Phoebe 8
Madeline 2
Zoey 3
Felicity 2
Beatrice 8

Boys
Toby 3
Digby 1
Lochlan 2
James 1
Oscar 3
Charles 1
Zachary 5
Maxwell 6
James 1
Caspian 9

Digby 0
Toby feels weak to me
All the rest are solid though I agree s/be Zoe and Madeleine

Penelope - 4, dislike Penny as nn and feel like the full name is a bit of a mouthful and slightly horsey. Prefer Daphne.
Elizabeth - 6 - bit dull but versatile, like Beth as nn
Clementine - 8, really growing on me. You may also like Camille.
Hermione - 3 - too 'Harry Potter' and horsey, and reminds me of Hermes delivery service
Phoebe - 10 - gorgeous, I have one
Madeline - 9 - but spelt and pronounced Madeleine. Not keen on Maddy as nn
Zoey - 5 - spelt Zoe. Nice meaning, bit dated. Eve? Zahara?
Felicity - 4 - ok, bit horsey. Florence? Fleur?
Beatrice - 6 - would give Beatrix a 7, sounds stronger

Toby - 1 - so wet
Digby - 1 - awful, sounds dredged up from an Enid Blyton book
Lochlan - 5 - meh
James - 3 - dull
Oscar - 4 - overdone
Charles - 2 - Charlie is sweet, Charles just reminds me of the soon to be king
Zachary - 6
Maxwell - 5, will be Max, bit dated
Caspian - 7, very Narnia but quite like it

5 Penny 2 for Penelope
8 Elizabeth
9 Clementine
6 Hermione
7 Phoebe
8 Madeline
6 Zoey
7 Felicity
8 Beatrice

Boys
5 Toby
4 Digby
4 Lochlan
5 James
5 Oscar
6 Charles
6 Zachary
5 Maxwell
James
1 Caspian

Girls
Penelope 3/10
Elizabeth 2/10
Clementine 5/10
Hermione 4/10
Phoebe 7/10
Madeline 8/10
Zoey 6/10
Felicity 9/10
Beatrice 9/10

Boys
Toby 8/10
Digby 0/10
Lochlan 5/10
James 5/10
Oscar 5/10
Charles 2/10
Zachary 7/10
Maxwell 2/10
Caspian 9/10

Girls
Penelope 8
Elizabeth 7
Clementine 9
Hermione 2
Phoebe 2
Madeline 1
Zoey 1 (Zoe is better)
Felicity 3
Beatrice 3

Boys
Toby 1
Digby 1 digby is a dog
Lochlan 1 isn’t it Lachlan??
James 8
Oscar 8
Charles 8
Zachary 8
Maxwell 6
James
Caspian 1

Girls
Penelope 9
Elizabeth 6
Clementine 10
Hermione 4
Phoebe 4
Madeline 5
Zoey 4
Felicity 3
Beatrice 2

Boys
Toby1
Digby 2
Lochlan 7
James 7
Oscar 5
Charles 4
Zachary 8
Maxwell 7
James 7
Caspian 10

Girls
Penelope - 3 mainly because I dislike the ways it could be shortened and pene means penis in Spanish
Elizabeth - 5 ok but slightly boring
Clementine - 5 very fruity but I like Clemmy/clean as a shortened version
Hermione - 1
Phoebe - 7
Madeline - 7
Zoey - 5 I prefer spelt as Zoe
Felicity - 9 I think this is lovely
Beatrice - 1 I simply read it as 'beat rice'

Boys
Toby - 9 good name for all ages, Tobias good as longer name
Digby - 1
Lochlan - 6
James - 2 but because of my own negative personal associations
Oscar - 7
Charles - 5
Zachary - 8
Maxwell - 6, prefer Maxim
Caspian - 8

Felicity
Lachlan

Girls
Penelope 4 - nice name but she’ll be Penny and it’s so wet.
Elizabeth 8 - lovely, but a lot of them about
Clementine - 5 - nice enough, slightly twee, popular
Hermione - 6 - I don’t love it but it’s got personality
Phoebe - 6 - ok but Pheeeeebs
Madeline 6 - ok, you have to be ok with Mandy
Zoey - 7- much prefer Zoe spelling but it’s fun and sparky
Felicity - 9 - mid century classic but sparkly, quite popular but not overused.
Beatrice - 7 - - v nice, quite a lot of them about

Boys
Toby - 5 - bit wet, much Prefer Tobias (8/10)
Digby - 6/10 - not v keen but it’s got personality
Lochlan - 6 - Lachlan (9/10) much nicer
James - 6 - dull but fine
Oscar - 5 - I think it’s had it’s day
Charles - 6 lovely but he’ll be Charlie and there are a lot of them
Zachary - 7 - nice, slightly prefer Zachariah
Maxwell - 0! It’s a brand of coffee, or possibly a dog, Maximilian (8) is nice, Maxim also fine
Caspian - 6 - I think it’s a bit fussy, I like Cassian though (8)