Rate my names

Boys

Arthur - ok, quite overused. Hate Art.
Bodhi - bit daft, but don't hate it.
Elias/Eli - cannot stand Eli, the ultimate whine of a name, sorry.
Fletcher - No.
Fraser - great
James - great, good short forms too.
Marley - no
Ozzy - short for Oscar is a great choice, you get cool plus the classic option
Rez - no
Spencer - ok. Classic and underused, I want to love it but don't actually like the sound very much.
Teddy - feels daft and babish as the full name
Tommy - ok if Thomas, again just a bit babyish for an adult
Vinnie - if Vincent, yes

Girls

Cali - if short for Caroline yes
Delilah - ok
Elsie - depressing, also the retro granny names now sound a bit over.
Florence - like
Marley - no
Nancy - lovely
Noa - no
Norah - no
Oliana - no
Penelope - lovely
Ronnie - no

You've got a good few names in there that would be brilliant as short forms of longer classic names. Go down this road, as you get the name you like plus they get options!

Arthur old man boring
Bodhi cool
Elias/Eli good quite biblical
Fletcher ok quite American, the boy in liar liar
Fraser good
James great
Marley like the film
Ozzy only as a NN, too osbornes
Rez not a name, do you mean rex? That's ok
Spencer Diana, which spoils an ok name
Teddy bear, no, ted is fine, loads of Theodore's ATM
Tommy gun, Robinson, no
Vinnie gangster

Girls

Cali the VW van but ok
Delilah good if you can stomach the connotations
Elsie too old lady
Florence no
Marley fine
Nancy stop copying David Cameron!
Noa will have a life time of saying no h
Norah fine
Oliana great but might get asked of russian
Penelope fine, bit Kardashian
Ronnie no

Arthur - lovely. Very popular now but for good reason
Bodhi - naff
Elias/Eli be- lovely and much less popular
Fletcher - don't like. And Fletch is awful
Fraser - lovely. Again not popular
James - I'm not a fan as I find it dull. But better than Fletcher
Marley - don't like at all
Ozzy - don't like at all though don't mind as shortened form of Oscar
Rez - do you mean Rex? I quite like Rex. Rez is awful though
Spencer - it's ok
Teddy - it's ok
Tommy - it's ok
Vinnie - don't like at all

Cali - I really like Callie but don't like Cali.
Delilah - not keen
Elsie - lovely
Florence - lovely
Marley - don't like at all
Nancy - lovely
Noa - not keen
Norah - it's ok
Oliana - don't like at all. Reminds me of oleaginous which means oily/greasy
Penelope - so popular right now
Ronnie - don't like at all

Boys

Arthur- lovely
Bodhi - no
Elias/Eli - love
Fletcher - no
Fraser - no
James - yes, used to find it a bit bland but like it more now
Marley - no
Ozzy - would love it as a nn for Oscar or Oswin
Rez - no
Spencer - no
Teddy - like Ted but not Teddy
Tommy - like Tom or Thomas but not Tommy
Vinnie - ok as a nn for Vincent

Girls

Cali- I’d spell it Callie, I like the sound
Delilah - ok
Elsie ok
Florence no
Marley no
Nancy - really like it
Noa- no
Norah- ok
Oliana- no
Penelope- lovely
Ronnie - no

BOYS

Eli is the boys name we have picked out, so of course I love it!

I find Arthur, James and Tommy a bit plain. Bodhi sounds like a child trying to say Brody to me. Teddy would work on a baby but I can't imagine it on any other age. Not a fan of Fraser, Ozzy or Vinnie. I like the others.

GIRLS

The only names I don't like are Elsie, Nancy and Norah. I adore Penelope and Noa! I've never heard of Oliana but it's lovely. Delilah in the Bible wasn't a good person, so that's something to be mindful of, though I still really like the name.

Arthur, Eli and James for the boys. I also like Tommy and Teddy but would use Thomas/Edward to give a more grown up option. I really like Florence and Penelope, and quite like Norah too.

I only like Elias/Eli, Arthur, Nancy and Norah.

Arthur - lovely name, like nn Art, getting more popular though.
Bodhi - bit hippy, not really a fan, can't imagine shouting Bodhi in for his dinner.
Elias/Eli - nice
Fletcher - nice
Fraser - good, strong name
James - strong name, can't go wrong. Not keen on Jamie tho.
Marley - don't like.
Ozzy - like as a nn, not sure about full name. Also feel like not anyone could be an Ozzy, so might not suit them.
Rez - not a fan.
Spencer - nice
Teddy - not a fan.
Tommy - nice.
Vinnie - OK.

Girls

Cali - fine.
Delilah - again, can't imagine opening the door and shouting Delilahhhh!
Elsie - OK.
Florence - OK.
Marley - don't like.
Nancy - OK.
Noa - OK.
Norah - don't like.
Oliana - don't like.
Penelope - like this.
Ronnie - don't like.

Out of your list I don’t mind:

Boys

Fletcher
Spencer

Girls

Not keen on any

Arthur - I like it but it is too popular for me. Would make a lovely middle name

Bodhi - i like it, but think you would need a certain personality to pull it off. It wouldn't suit all teenage boys / men

Elias/Eli - I really like it. Love Eli as a NN and Elias or Elijah as the full name

Fletcher - I usually don't like surnames as first names but I do live Fletcher

Fraser - not a fan. I just think of the TV show

James - lovely classic

Marley - not a fan at all, seems very faddy

Ozzy - ok as a NN for Oscar but not as a given name. Like Bodhi I think you would need to be a certain type of person to pull it off

Rez - awful

Spencer - not a fan

Teddy - awful. I really don't get the love

Tommy - Thomas yes but I can't stand Tommy

Vinnie - not for me

Cali - I like it but spelt Callie
Delilah - lovely
Elsie - I like but again wouldn't suit everyone
Florence - love it but too popular for me
Marley - dislike
Nancy - dislike
Noa - no, everybody would assume she's a boy
Norah - beautiful
Oliana - it's ok
Penelope - nice enough just not for me
Ronnie - I like as a NN for Veronica

Arthur - nice enough, very popular
Bodhi - not a fan, sorry
Elias/Eli - nice
Fletcher - dislike
Fraser - dislike
James - nice
Marley - okay.. doesn't sound very serious
Ozzy - no - too nicknamey
Rez - did you mean Rex? Dislike sorry - too much of a dog's name / dinosaur
Spencer - dislike
Teddy - no - too nicknamey
Tommy - go for Tom, nn Tommy
Vinnie - go for Vincent, nn Vinnie

Girls

Cali - nice
Delilah - too frilly
Elsie - okay
Florence - dislike
Marley - dislike, not serious enough sounding
Nancy - dislike
Noa - okay
Norah - nice
Oliana - dislike a lot
Penelope - dislike
Ronnie - not a fan sorry

I like Tommy and Cali but none of the others

Arthur - Very popular
Bodhi - No.
Elias/Eli - No. too whiny
Fletcher - No
Fraser - Yes
James - would use
Marley - for a dog
Ozzy - no
Rez - no
Spencer - no
Teddy - no
Tommy - ok if short for Thomas
Vinnie - definitely not

Cali - no
Delilah - - definitely not
Elsie - no
Florence - ok
Marley - definitely not
Nancy - yes
Noa - definitely not
Norah - no
Oliana - oleaginous
Penelope - ok
Ronnie - no, but ok if short for Veronica, if a bit Eastenders

Rez & Oliana are my faves.

Ahh! Autocorrect!

No to Rez

If Rex then No = If Rex then No

Boys

Arthur - nice and quite popular
Bodhi - surfer dude or snowboarder, wears beaded bracelets, permatan, very California vibe
Elias/Eli - really cool
Fletcher - sounds like someone hacking up a loogy
Fraser - lovely, Scottish surname but very cool
James - quite nice, maybe a bit meh
Marley - Bob/reggae, and also that dog
Ozzy - don't like, it's nicknamey, Ozzy and Sharon...
Rez - not familiar with this one - is it supposed to be Rex? If Rex then No
Spencer - meh
Teddy - like but only if short for Theodore
Tommy - like but only if short for Thomas
Vinnie - like but only if short for Vincent

Girls

Cali - very insipid
Delilah - nice, strong name but also has a light sound thanks to the Ls
Elsie - name of a cow
Florence - The Magic Roundabout
Marley - Bob/reggae, and also that dog
Nancy - love this
Noa - nice
Norah - love this
Oliana - makes me think of some brand of corn oil
Penelope - love
Ronnie - love, also love Veronica, but Ronnie is lovely on its own imo

Arthur- lovely although v popular
Bodhi- not for me
Elias/Eli- nice
Fletcher- like
Fraser- meh
James- nice can’t go wrong
Marley- quite like reminds me of film about dog
Ozzy- short for Oscar/ Oswald
Rez- no. Rex is nice
Spencer- like
Teddy- short for Edward or Theodore then yes
Tommy- no
Vinnie- short for Vincent yes

Girls

Cali- yes prefer Callie
Delilah- love
Elsie- like but blends into all the Ellie, Evie, Maisie etc
Florence- love
Marley- not for girl
Nancy- like
Noa- no. A
Norah- ok
Oliana- sounds made up
Penelope- love
Ronnie- absolute no esp for girl

Arthur - nice name
Bodhi - like it
Elias/Eli - and this, you have good taste in names!
Fletcher - except for this - not keen
Fraser - OK
James - nice
Marley - like this
Ozzy - love this but it's a nickname, you need a longer name (Oscar / Oisin / Osian / Ozymandius etc)
Rez - no
Spencer - also no
Teddy - also a nickname, call him Theo NN Teddy. Theo is a lovely name
Tommy - Thomas NN Tommy is nicer. Tom is a nicer NN than Tommy IMO
Vinnie - no

Girls

Cali - love it
Delilah - not keen
Elsie - nice
Florence - great name
Marley - love it
Nancy - nice
Noa - boys name
Norah - no
Oliana - ok
Penelope - ok
Ronnie - a nickname

Fraser
James
Marley (I am a Bob fan; are you? If not, avoid it.)

Nora (no h, not necessary, looks silly)
Penelope
Florence

I don't like the others, sorry. Some are just cutesy, dated nicknames rather than proper names. Maybe consider Thomas and Vincent, and, for a girl, Veronica nn Ronnie or Caroline/Carolyn nn Cali, or consider Carly or Carla.

… favourites - Elias and Nancy

Likes -
Arthur
Elias/Eli
Fraser (well, it’s OK)
James
Teddy (if short for Edward/Theodore)
Tommy (if short for Thomas)

Cali (if short for Calista)
Delilah (it’s OK)
Florence (it’s OK)
Nancy
Penelope

Elias and Florence are both such lovely names!

Fraser
James
Nancy
Penelope