Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Baby names

Find baby name inspiration and advice on the Mumsnet Baby Names forum.

Asian or English names?

40 replies

ScottyDog7 · 28/11/2021 21:46

So DP is Pakistani by birth, raised Muslim but has identified as atheist for all adult life. Has 2 DSs from previous relationship (ex wife also Pakistani Muslim) and DSs has his surname, and "Muslim" names although more Turkish (I think).
I'm pregnant. I'm white British. I've always been a bit spiritual but raised and identify as agnostic.
There's a Muslim version of an angelic name which I LOVE. But my family are a bit Hmm at it, as are most of my friends. We are not married, but plan to be in a few years so DC will have DPs surname, which is obviously Asian.
I hate to think it but I worry about racism for my children, and how it may effect their future with an obviously none white British name.
It's making me question not just the first name but also the surname. If the baby is born looking more like one ethnicity than the other, that may have more influence. But then pigment can darken as the baby gets older...
DP is quite light skinned. And I'm pasty white. So we think baby is likely to be on the lighter side.

Also I'm totally blaming pregnancy hormones and lack of sleep for this sudden chain of though/ possibly irration fear. I just want my child/children to have the best and easiest life possible.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SirVixofVixHall · 02/12/2021 16:41

@ScottyDog7

As much as I'd love to get married before the birth thats just not financially possible. Unless we just have a quick sign the paper wedding at the local registry office. Which is not my ideal situation.

I'm not personally a fan of double barreled surnames. But maybe it's an option and can be changed once we're married... DP is pretty laid back about all of it, so it feels like a big responsibility to me at the moment.

Have a registry office wedding now. Do the big wedding, if you still want it, when you have the cash.
Jossbow · 02/12/2021 16:36

Malik / Malika

Scirocco · 02/12/2021 15:53

If you're keen to include a nod to your partner's heritage, maybe you could look for a middle name that has a connection with his place of birth, or an aspect of the culture in which he was raised? There are a lot of beautiful names with connections to Pakistani culture without being overtly associated with one faith or another.

If neither of you are practising Muslims then it probably wouldn't make that much sense to give your child an overtly Islamic name, although if you wanted that association there are lots of names which have English versions, eg. Michael, Noah, Mary.

In terms of UK legal issues around names, if you aren't married (with a legally valid UK marriage), I'd suggest using your last name for your baby. It makes a lot of things easier if you and your baby have the same last name, and gives some additional protection in case of a relationship breakdown. You could then change both your last names after marriage if you wanted?

In Islam, the main piece of guidance about naming a child is to choose a name with a good meaning which will set them up for a life in which they can find success and happiness and be a good and kind person. Pick a name that you and your partner love, that has a nice meaning and makes you both happy.

(But I'd really recommend not going with Azrael...)

ReadtheFT · 02/12/2021 12:50

Give any british name you like, but if child looks anything other than white british he will still be victim of racism.

silentpool · 02/12/2021 02:44

I would do English first name, Asian middle name, if you will be living in an English speaking country. I have a name which does not match my cultural background and I have spent my entire life spelling it.... I am very careful to spell and pronounce other peoples' names right though!

Elspethelf · 02/12/2021 01:57

I know of someone who named her child Gabriel to fit in with the Western Culture he was raised in, but the Middle Eastern side called him Jibreel and that worked for her family. I wouldn’t worry about ‘Gay’, gay isn’t an insult

Snickers94 · 01/12/2021 20:32

Oh my gosh, please don't name your baby Izra'il or Azrael, that's the angel of death. I think your DPs family would also really not like that name!

Aliyah and Leila/Laila are Arab/Muslim names too, I think it's only now becoming more common for white people to use these names.

Honestly, it doesn't matter what your baby's name is. There are so many weird and wonderful names these days that nobody will probably notice, as well as mixed cultural names. Pick something you and him both like - the fact that baby's surname will be Pakistani will probably give away their race anyway!

bonfireheart · 01/12/2021 15:54

Agree with @takeme2insanity

Footle · 01/12/2021 15:29

Micheal is the spelling often used in Ireland.

Change123today · 01/12/2021 15:24

My friend is Scottish and her two have Celtic first names and their Dads Asian surname.

TakeMe2Insanity · 01/12/2021 15:07

Pakistani origin here, mixed couple but both Muslim. So dc have dh’s western last name but have muslim first and middles muslim name because we are muslims.

So what stands out to me is that neither of you are muslim and it really makes no sense to have muslim first names when you aren’t. Given your situation I’d choose an English name that you like rather than muslim name that you are going to anglicise that looses the sense of the name, a lot of people of mumsnet suggest that as an obvious solution but it’s not great.

Pakistani-German friends whose parents weren’t married were given German 1st name then Pakistani (muslim midddle names) and then German last name to be changed on marriage but never did. They’ve always said the middle name gave them an actual cultural link but not everyone’s business.

In terms of a last name, as you aren’t married I wouldn’t give my dc my dp name unless we were married.

I really don’t think you should go down the rabbit hole of what your child’s skin colour or tone will be. What ever it will be it will be perfect and you will do the best for him or her regardless.

sashh · 01/12/2021 05:30

OP if you are choosing a name familiar in English please use the most common spelling eg Michael not Micheal. You cannot imagine how infuriating it is to have a normal name with a not normal spelling, you spend your life correcting people, altering forms etc.

I have come across people using names that can easily be anglicized eg Karenjit and Sharonjit (yes I know they are Sikh names).

user97533676 is not unusual in having a nickname, it's quite common with people from Hong Kong and works well.

Anyway congratulations on your pregnancy, you may find you take a look at your child and they look like a particular name.

RedWingBoots · 01/12/2021 04:40

OP if you look on baby name lists of Muslim names there are plenty of names which are instantly recognisable and even if they have different spellings you can recognise them by their pronunciation. While some of them aren't English they won't stand out as being Muslim as they are common in other European countries e.g. Ireland, Greece, Russia.

I know plenty of people who have such names which they don't realise. And when I was looking for names for my DD I deliberately choose a middle name that fitted within those parameters due to my wider family culture.

You basically Google for a list of Muslim names. Check any names you like have variations in other cultures, look at the spelling variations for that name and choose an Anglicized spelling.

For example just did a Google now for Muslim girls names and it threw up the well-known names Anita, Alisha, Ariana, Amelia, Amber.....

user97533676 · 01/12/2021 03:10

Also wanted to say, OP, I was in a similar situation, dad was Muslim, mum wasn't.
Different races but not the ones you mentioned.
I was given an Islamic name with an English nickname.
Everyone used the English nickname.
In the end I changed my name legally to the English nickname but that wasn't entirely because of the name.
Something like that may work for you.

Newmum29 · 01/12/2021 02:52

I’m going to be really blunt. I live in Aus and it’s quite a racist place (moved from London). I find it’s extremely white and segregated in general- most non white people tend to be Chinese, Indian or south east Asian and live in their own ethnicity areas. I would give them a western name.

user97533676 · 01/12/2021 02:47

User, I just thought it was somewhat relevant since my DP was raised but not practising Muslim, and I am picking Islamic angle names. I supposed I wanted peoples views on us using them as much as anything else.

Sorry I meant it was interesting you used "identify."
I've never heard as someone identifying as a Muslim.

ScottyDog7 · 30/11/2021 20:39

Rafail is lovely. Not heard of that as an angel but I like the name. I shall look into that one more. Thank you. And thank you for the lists.
Yes, we don't yet know what we are having.
I prefer the girl names which will work better in both, so boy names are more of a challenge. I want DC to be comfortable and proud of their heritage so it would be nice if we could have a name that works in both. And that both families can easily pronounce Grin

User, I just thought it was somewhat relevant since my DP was raised but not practising Muslim, and I am picking Islamic angle names. I supposed I wanted peoples views on us using them as much as anything else.

I think I will go with my surname, and look at changing once we are married. We have a date set but it's not for 2 1/2 years. So the child will likely not really know their own surname, or even if they do should quickly adapt without it being a problem.

OP posts:
user97533676 · 30/11/2021 18:47

Completely off topic I was just interested that you described you both as identifying as a follower of something.

StColumbofNavron · 30/11/2021 18:44

I've just realised you didn't actually say a boy. Girls we know.

Jenna(h)
Sara (in various Zara, Zarah, Zahra, Saara, Saraah forms)
Selina
Aliyah/Alia (I also know two girls with English parents with this name)
Leila
Tania
Isla/Aiyla/Ayla
Maria
Diana
Dinah
Aida

StColumbofNavron · 30/11/2021 18:39

Rafail is also an angel I think (Raphael) and Rafa or Rafi for short which is fab. Mikhail/Michael is nice as Mika. Gabriel is lovely.

Mixed couples we know (and we are mixed Asian and English/Middle Eastern) have gone for things like

Noah (not Nuh)
Elias
Zak (in various long forms but all known as Zak)
Adam
Sami
Ryan/Rayan
Aaron/Arun
Ari (a Jewish Asian couple)
Daniel/Daniyal

Re: surnames, I think that is personal choice really. I let ours have DH's because his was easier to spell (we are also married). I gave my surname as a second middle name (due to aforementioned spelling ballache).

WhereYouLeftIt · 30/11/2021 18:39

@ScottyDog7

Sorry for some reason my phone is autocorrecting Michael to ea instead...

I've also thought about giving DC my surname, with a view of changing it to his once we are married. Of course I'm hoping and expecting everything to work out with us, but yes, it could be safer and less of a PITA for me if things don't. My DSis is currently going through similar with her DC with their bio-fathers surname, which the kids hate.

I would give them my surname if unmarried. No question.
KirstenBlest · 30/11/2021 18:27

that should have said
easier all round if DC has the same surname as their mother

BiscuitLover3679 · 30/11/2021 18:26

@Palavah

This isn't about the names, but financially you could be heading into a bigger problem by not getting married before you have the baby. Are you only taking mat leave on full pay and not expecting to make any compromises at work for childcare or similar?
Really irrelevant to the post.
KirstenBlest · 30/11/2021 18:23

Sorry to be negative, but it's easier all round if DC has the same surname, and of course, it can be changed when you get married

Friend of her friend had her fingers burnt by a DH who had dual nationality. She was married but he buggered off back home

KirstenBlest · 30/11/2021 18:21

Micheal (fada on the i and a) is an irish name, approx. pron., Mee-hahl.
It was probably a typo upthread