Thanks for all your input. Part of the problem is probably that I'm American and Dh is English so different names have different connotations to us.
For example Elise is considered quite 'chavy' in the USA although we don't really have that term. Katrina only brings to mind Hurricane Katrina. And I love Paige, but that looks to be really unpopular here in the UK from all of your suggestions.
We have a very English surname and live in England so I sort of feel like I should get to have more input into the first name and for it to be more 'American' but dh doesn't agree.
I definitely don't want any top 10 names that are really vowel-y (Eva, Ava, Evie, Isla, Olivia, Ada, etc.) They just aren't for me and I have a name that was common in school and hated it. Plus we have loads of goods friends with babies with these sort of names so even if I like one it's already used and I don't want to duplicate.
I also like Sadie, Scarlett, Violet, Betsy, Kiera, Leah, Ruby, Cora, Beatrice, Summer but DH has said no to them all.
I did think maybe Susannah but when I mentioned it at work the entire table of 6 ladies pulled a face and thought it was terrible which has now put me off.
The one we both thought was ok was Abby but I guess I'm just disappointed it might come down to a name we both think is just ok rather than one I love when there are probably 20-30 that I do love.
If it's a boy we will probably name it Henry. We both have always said we liked it, it's a family name for DH and I don't have the energy to find an alternative bc dh has said no to every other suggestion I've made.