Judge away!!! :)

I love Rusty and Asha

Gloria will be Glo, unless you shorten to the rather lovely Lori.

Boys
Ezra - no
Grey - no
Romeo - no
Rusty - no
All dreadful

Girls
Asha - brimful of?
Effie - effin' awful
Frances (or Francis?) Frances
Gloria
Harrie - No
Noa - no
Rory - no
Rosalie - prefer Rosalind. Rosalie is too like Rosie Lee .

I like Ezra or Rory if a boy.

Your girl’s list is much harder for me...Harrie but only if Harriet. Your girl list is much harder as none are appealing to me. Half are pretty masculine sounding. Gloria is terrible. I think Harrie(t) if the t is included is ok.

With regards to Rusty, have you considered if he had red hair what the repercussions would be for the poor bairn?
My dd had brown hair at birth, ginger now.

I don't like any of your boys' names but I like Rory for a boy! I like Frances and Rosalie for girls. Definitely Frances not Francis, which is traditionally the boys' spelling.

Gilmore girls Rory was short for Lorelai! Rory as a nickname for Lorelai or Aurora is ok but not on its own for a girl

I don’t like any of your boys names, especially Grey (boring colour) and Rusty (dogs name) but Ezra is the least bad

I prefer Francesca to Frances (Francis is a boys name)

HarrieT is nice, she can be known as Harrie but should have the full name officially

Don't like any of your names, sorry.
And I know a five year old Rusty, that's what's on his bc so not a nickname. Has a brother with a similarly odd name too.

@Coffeewithmyoxyg3n

Lol I love gilmore girls! My sister begged my to name my daughter Lorelai haha! Rory is a girls name to me too. Well... Unisex at least.

How about Ezri for a girl? You won't meet many!

That was the name of the baby who shared a post labour room with me and my DD. It's similar to my babys name and there was another baby named Izal

Not keen on any of the boys' names.
Frances is by far my favourite from the girls' list. Rosalie is pretty, and there's something rather splendid about Gloria, too. None of the other names.

Ezra and Frances are lovely! Also p.p suggestion of Rosa is stunning.

From your boys list I love Ezra and like Grey as a middle name only. Romeo and Rusty! Are awful

From your girls list

Asha - not a fan
Effie - I like it but feel it needs a full name
Frances (or Francis?) - I love Francis for a bit but not keen On Frances for a girl. I find it stuffy. Love Francesca though
Gloria - pretty. I prefer Gloriana though
Harrie - is it missing a 't'?
Noa - no
Rory - cute as a nn
Rosalie - not my style. Much prefer Rosalind or Rosalin or simply Rosa

Clearly no Gilmore girls fans. Rory is definitely a girl's name to me OP!

Ezra and Rosalie are great.

Ezra and Rosalie

Boys
Ezra- I’ve never liked it but it’s quite popular now so am clearly in the minority
Grey- no
Romeo- no
Rusty- no, sounds like a dog

Girls
Asha- okay, not great
Effie- I really love this. Maybe a ‘more complete’ name, such as Elizabeth, with this as a nn?
Frances (or Francis?)- okay
Gloria- hate it
Harrie- no
Noa - no
Rory- no
Rosalie- pretty

First thread where i like any name!!!

I don't normally comment on the baby names threads but you ask for judging so that makes me think it's ok!
My now adult DCs have unusual names so I like them in general but you do have to think carefully.

Boys
Ezra - I know a boy called Ezra, he's 20 now and he's an excellent man so I like it.
Grey - grey is a drab colour but also I think of the 50 Shades books, 30 years from now your son won't want a name associated with a badly written book about a sexually coercive man. So no.
Romeo - Poor kid. Romeo in R+Juliet is a weak dreamer. Plus the Beckhams have a Romeo and it sounds like you're copying. No.
Rusty - no. Just no.

Girls
Asha - as others have said, it's an Indian name but I like it.
Effie - effing hell? No, it's silly.
Frances - it's ok, a bit plain and horsey. If you're horsey then fair enough.
Gloria - I love it, it's fabulous.
Harrie - I like it but it is very masculine.
Noa - I like it but again, it makes me think of Noah the boys name. How about Noah for a boy?
Rory - it's a boys name, firmly. I'd put it on your boys list.
Rosalie - it's nice but very 'normal' compared to your other names, do you want a normal name?

Boys
Ezra - lovely, though maybe a bit popular now
Grey - a colour, not a name
Romeo - definitely not .
Rusty - no. That's a nickname. Awful as a first name

Girls
Asha - there's a takeaway near me called Ashas, so no.
Effie - I actually like this but most people don't , maybe use it as a nn for a longer name ?
Frances - too old fashioned . Frankie is cute though
Gloria - makes me think gorilla
Harrie - t? Harriet is nice. Harrie isn't
Noa - Noah ? Boy's name.
Rory - boy's name
Rosalie - kind of cute ! Prefer Rosie

I like Ezra and Frances or Gloria

Boys
Ezra - not a fan.
Grey - love it, but for a middle name.
Romeo - great name. I think you'd get people commenting about the Beckhams though.
Rusty - no. Dogs name.

Girls
Asha - too boyish
Effie - too cutesy. Nice nickname though.
Frances (or Francis?) - too date. Frances is a girls name. Francis is a boys name.
Gloria - Awesome ñame. Don't know why it's not more popular.
Harrie - short for Harriet or Henrietta, but not on its own.
Noa - okay.
Rory - boys name.
Rosalie - nice, a bit boring.

How about Ezri for a girl? You won't meet many!