When I first heard of Edith Bowman (donkey's years ago) I thought it was really ugly. It was my grandma's name, and it just didn't feel right on someone 10 years or so older than me.
Now that I'm older, I can imagine it being cute on a little girl - but as it fits with the granny chic trend, it may go out of fashion again and be 'of a time' rather than a timeless age iykwim.