Sensible names?

Joshua definitely the best boys name on your list.

I quite like Juno.

I love Loki and I would also consider Zeke (sounds the same as the other spelling but more traditional)

I'd go for Joshua. It maybe very common but it still comes very meaningful because of its biblical character.

I like Barnaby and Felicity out of your sensible names. I do think Toby/Emily/Lucy are a bit dull and perhaps a bit abrupt-sounding with your surname. Joshua is OK, but is it dated? I know a few who are in their mid-20s. I like both Juno and particularly Zelda out of the fancy names, but none of the boys'. Asterix is a piece of punctuation to me.

Love all the sensible ones, especially barnaby and felicity.

I like your sensibles and given the way you feel about your own name, do you really want to give your baby an out there name?

Toby and Luna get my vote :)
If I cud b so rude :-s I think the three 'different' boys names are horrific ! Don't do it !

I Like all the names on your sensible list.

I actually really like your name, too (it's my Hebrew name) and it meets all same criteria I would apply when choosing a baby name - not overly popular, but recognisable, easy to pronounce and spell and not too specific to any particular social class!

Toby and Felicity would be my favourite choices from your list.

These lists are a bit polarised. There is a middle ground (I think Barnaby and Felicity are these types of names - that are neither boring or wacky).

If it influences your decision at all Luna is not unusual at all where I live, I know several 1 and under! Juno is beautiful and although a little unusual not that ‘out there’ also, you could call her June which I think is gorgeous😍 I like Barnaby, Zeke and Loki but would potentially go for Ezekiel and Lochlan and shorten them to Zeke and Loki myself.

Female Asterix characters I like are

Panacea
Bicarbonatofsoda

and

Ulna

If you want to go all Gosginny and Uderzo you could go with

Geriatrix
Getafix
Fulliautomatix

Toby or Lucy. I love the name Toby so much. My DD would have been a Toby had she been a boy

Barnaby - a bit wet
Joshua - nice
Toby - a bit wet
Asterix - no way. It's not really a name; it's a pun on asterisk
Loki - no
Zeik - OK
Felicity - nice
Emily - quite popular. OK
Lucy - nice. Not commonplace
Luna - nice
Juno- lovely
Zelda - another one that sounds like you are joking.

Barnaby - love this
Joshua - ok, but maybe a little dull
Toby - I like this but if it was me I'd probably go with Tobias which could then be shortened to Tobi/Toby but is a bit more unusual as a full name.

Asterix - just no - he's not a French cartoon!
Loki - also no!
Zeik - love this but would spell it Zeke and would also use Ezekiel as the full name. (Disclaimer: this was the name we had chosen for DD2 if she had been a boy and I am still a little sad that I never got to use it)

Felicity - love this
Emily - like but perhaps a little dull
Lucy - like this also - very pretty and less common than Emily where I live anyway.

Luna - ok
Juno - like, but prefer Junia as a name with a similar sound.
Zelda - no - she's unlikely to be a warrior princess!

From your lists:

Boys:
Barnaby - love
Joshua - like
Toby (maybe) - no real feeling either way

Asterix - not for me
Loki - not for me (and wasn't he a particularly naughty God?)
Zeik - not for me

How about:

Sebastian - as a nice sensible name, or Spike for a fun one?

Girls:
Felicity - a bit wishy washy
Emily - like
Lucy - like

Luna - like
Juno - like
Zelda - not nice to my ear

ps I like your name, though admit, I probably like the shortening more

Joshua or Felicity

Loki or Barnaby, Juno or Lucy.

I like your sensible boys names. Not the weird ones and definitely not Zeik - reminds me of Zika virus.

Love all the girls names.

❤️ Zeik and Zelda, go on OP, be brave ! 👍🏻

I like Felicity and Joshua

I am a big fan of 'different' names.

Hate all your 'traditional' boys' names (sorry). Barnaby is the best of the three.

Love Zeik the most out of the other three.

Hate your 'traditional' girls' names. Emily and Lucy are boring and outdated. Felicity is very bland.

Love Luna, Juno and Zelda.

I like Barnaby, Zeik, Felicity, Luna and Juno. I love Asterix books though!

I think there might be other not "sensible" but not too "out there" names too - a middle option if you like (although you may have already been through every name!). Maybe keep trawling?

Fwiw, my DS has an unusual name and he loves it and loves that he doesn't know anyone with his name (he is 5). It is the surname of a famous US president who was shot, beginning with L. If left to me, I'd have gone for a very straight laced name but his Dad wanted something unusual and I went with it. I don't regret it at all even though it isn't what everyone would go for. The name is totally DS now and really suits him. I can't imagine him as an Oliver or Alexander (I think those were my favourites).

I'd go for what you love over what you think is sensible (and that is totally NOT what I would have said before having an unusually named DS!).

I like Joshua, Toby, Emily, Lucy, Luna

Sensible list, it's not boring.