Active discussions

Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Talk
Baby names

Find baby name inspiration and advice on the Mumsnet Baby Names forum.

Original poster

Arthur... in Scotland

21 replies

Whatsinaname2011 · 20/11/2015 22:23

We have 2 sons, Henry and James

Expecting 3rd son shortly and our favourite names are George and Arthur.

Arthur is 41 in England so relatively common, not too "out there" but worried that in Scotland it's 133 so not sure it's made enough of a "come back"

Will Arthur be teases mercilessly by his Scottish peers? (private school, nice area does this matter??)

It's so hard naming a human!! Such a responsibility...

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Set a reminder
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
magpie17 · 30/11/2015 17:18

George, Henry and James together is FAR too Thomas the tank engine!! Arthur is much nicer.

magpie17 · 30/11/2015 17:16

I'm in Scotland and know a baby Arthur (about six months old), I love the name! My DS has a bit of a love/hate name so you have to be confident in your choice because people might not like it.

serin · 30/11/2015 16:29

Arthur ? Mac (Something).

Wow, Yes that sounds great.

Original poster
Whatsinaname2011 · 29/11/2015 12:44

It will won't it! The lovely rolling r!

OP posts:
villainousbroodmare · 29/11/2015 07:19

I much prefer Arthur.
It will sound gorrrrrgeous in a Scottish accent.

Original poster
Whatsinaname2011 · 29/11/2015 07:04

I agree totally with PP who said George is a nicer name but Henry James and George sounds a bit...of a set of royals/trains.

It's hard. We are moving soon so area will be around dollar school or ardvreck for juniors and then dollar or glenalmomd or Strathallan for senior.

We are now wondering about Edward. But I think I prefer Arthur. Goodness it's hard to name a baby!! It's so....permenant!

OP posts:
AngelsWithFilthySouls · 24/11/2015 16:53

Hmm, I think it would be area dependent. I don't know of any but then despite being professionals I'd struggle to class myself or any friends as posh and I would definitely see that as a 'posh' sib-set Grin

It's mainly Jacks and Noahs at groups/nursery

marmiteontoast76 · 24/11/2015 16:25

....anyway, George is a steam roller and I think there is a train called Arthur!?!

marmiteontoast76 · 24/11/2015 16:22

I think Arthur flows better with your other ds names, however I think George is a nicer name. I can see why this is hard for you.

Henry, James and George is fine though. Wouldn't worry about sounding like a set of trains, most of the young boys in our family have Thomas type names - Edward, Thomas, James, Henry etc, and no-one ever comments when they are all together.

LetsSplashMummy · 24/11/2015 15:33

I know a couple of Arthur's in Scotland, it isn't a name that draws comment and not too different in popularity from Henry, is it? Perhaps there are different spellings in Scotland - Artair is the Gaelic - so you would need to group them in to see real popularity. I think Arthur is much better than George with the siblings, George is too much a "set," Royals or Tank Engines!

squoosh · 21/11/2015 22:46

I can't see it raising too many eyebrows. There are lots of young Gordons and Hectors here, Arthur doesn't seem too far removed from that.

twinjocks · 21/11/2015 22:08

Lovely name, and will sound fab in a Scottish accent with all those rolling Rs!!!

Original poster
Whatsinaname2011 · 21/11/2015 20:56

Out of interest would you vote George or Arthur to go with that sibling set?

I prefer George but worry it's then a bit too "Thomas the tank engine" sounding.

OP posts:
Sleepybunny · 21/11/2015 04:39

I love it, and I'm in scotland. Yes plenty of Archie's etc around, so I don't think it's too 'out there'or posh.

Original poster
Whatsinaname2011 · 21/11/2015 04:31

Thank you for all your insightful comments

OP posts:
Ipushedmygrannyaffabus · 21/11/2015 01:18

Hunger? I meant younger!!

Ipushedmygrannyaffabus · 21/11/2015 01:18

I,ve known a few Arthur's in scotland - all of which were named after their fathers. I don't think they'd get teased, as there are plenty of Alfie and Archie's, which would also have been "old man" names when we were hunger.

I think it's always going to be 'posh' rather than 'cool' mind you.

irishe · 20/11/2015 22:46

I know a 4 year old Arthur in Edinburgh. Never thought anything of it and have never heard any negative comments made about it. If you like it, go for it!

MrsBalustradeLanyard · 20/11/2015 22:39

I've never met a baby Arthur in Scotland! Not that I'm saying that's a bad thing. Prefer Atholl, myself though. Or Alban.

HarrysMummy17 · 20/11/2015 22:35

There are 2 Arthur's in the Scottish village I live in. Both under 3

SymbollocksInteractionism · 20/11/2015 22:26

I like it, might get shortened to Art though which is cute I think.

Swipe left for the next trending thread