Please judge my list!

Surnames for first names? No, no, no. Just wrong.

Carmichael
Fox
Enderby
Crawford
Fletcher

Simon is awful! I find it really odd that you like such a boring name after the long list of "out of this world names".
I would go with Nathan

Knox - like it a lot
Diggory - don't like this one, pompous red faced buffoon
Neville - not attractive no matter at what age
Axel - love it but without Scandinavian roots I think it would be weird

Gannon - too much like gammon
Brody - I like it
Brennon - too much like Brendan
Nathan - OK, rather boring
Simon - I like it

May I offer you Lev, Dashiell and Toby?

Hades?
Thank fuck that was vetoed!
Nathan and Simon I sippose, though struggling to see how you came up with those names as well as the others.

Simon is the only possible one and I don't like that much
Sorry to be blunt

Knox - Love this. Knox was in the punk band The Vibrators.
Diggory - No way, reminds me of Dirk Diggler.
Neville - Horrible, please no.
Axel - Ok.
Gannon - Surname and unpleasant.
Brody - Ok.
Brennon - No.
Nathan - Meh.
Simon - Very dated 70's name.

Oh no. No to all of them. Please don't. Please.

I'm sorry, I know names are hugely important, personal things to choose and people's negative opinions on names that you love is awful, but you have to seriously consider the fact that this is a life choice you are making for somebody else. Giving a child a ridiculous, really 'out there' name is borderline bloody cruel lol. Your child will have to grow up with this name for the rest of their life.

Lots of folks don't want something as Top 10 popular as Harry or Oliver or Jack. But Axel, Gannon and Diggory? Come on, give the kid a fighting chance!

From your list, I'd say Nathan or Simon at a big push. They at least sound like real names.

Nathan and Simon are ok.
The others are shocking. Sorry.

What bakingtins said!

Brody is OK. I know someone with baby Brody (or Brodie, not sure).

If you like American-sounding names, how about:
Curtis
Spencer
Oren
Wyatt
Cody

Hmmm. Your names arent to my taste.

I quite like Nathan from your husband's list, although prefer Nathaniel.

Knox, Diggory and Gannon are vile.

Nathan, Simon and Brodie are ok.
The rest are an improvement on Hades.

To be fair!!!!! FFS!

I like Axel and Brodie

Just wanted to fair!

Knox. Like the slebs kid . No, I don't like it
Diggory. Awful name, sorry
Neville. Not great, sounds silly
Axel. Ok
Gannon. Nope Not sure how it's pronounced either. Is it Gan yon?
Brody. Ok
Brennon. Ok
Nathan. Really nice
Simon. Really nice

Gannon is Irish or Gaelic I think - I know one but he's a PITA.

Brodie is a good name, but a bit surname like - depends if your surname is like a first name (eg James) as that would get confusing.

All are better than Hades though

How about Dickon (rather than Diggory, which I would associate with a dog)?

The only one I like is Nathan.

Nathan is a great name, love it!
Simon is good too.
Brody and Axel are ok.... at a push.
The rest, no.

Erm. Erm. Erm. Nathan. Simon and Brodie maybe. The others are beyond horrendous.

My first opinions/reactions -

My favourites:
Knox - Fort Knox, also I think it's the name of a medication to get you to sleep, not too sure of the spelling though.
Diggory - Cedrick Diggory, Harry Potter. I don't MIND it too much, but it just doesn't sound like an actual name. Cederick is nice, though.
Neville - It's a bit old many re Chamberlain and also reminds me of Harry Potter, but the best of the bunch.
Axel - Axl Rose is the first thing that comes to my mind.

Other half's favourites:
Gannon - I just think of Gammon, sorry! Is it an actual name? I don't say that lightly either, I'm pretty liberal with names.
Brody - I don't mind this name.
Brennon - It sounds like a surname.
Nathan - Reminds me of a bloke I knew from East London who was a womaniser. Not a terrible name, but does remind me of a seedy kind of bloke.
Simon - Reminds me of a man in his 40s/50s not a baby but he'll grow up eventually, obviously. :)

Interesting names and not necessarily horrible, I just want you to be aware of connotations people may have.

Good luck naming your baby.

*Brodie the only half decent one, and Simon.

Nathan is a horrible name. I can't believe so many people like it*

But you think Simon is OK???

Just shows how we are all different.

Quite a terrible list, imo.

Brodie the only half decent one, and Simon.

Nathan is a horrible name. I can't believe so many people like it.

Fox Knew I had heard something similar to that before and couldn't place it! No need to google it now!

Brodie, Brennon (although I would spell as Brennan) Nathan and Simon are all reasonably nice but I have to agree with a lot of the posters above that the other's are fodder for judgey-pants parents. Like we've just judged. Imagine the above thoughts but not spoken aloud just subconsciously in the back of peoples minds when heard. I tried to go for names which weren't of famous people or had class connotations for the same reasons. Don't worry what kids will think, DS has a very traditional Welsh name that some children chose to tease him about. One of the children instigating it was called Tallulah which of course sounds very classy in the local accent
DS and I had a little light hearted chuckle about it at home!
See what I mean about judgey parents!!?

Different spelling but Ganon was the name of the baddy in the Zelda games.