Honest opinions on big list!

Ottilie is lovely.

Had I had a girl my choice would have been Camilla - Milla or Millie for nn. Just to add to your long list!!

Tabitha - Love, elegant
Alana - OK
Edith - No, prefer Edie
Nell - Alright
Martha - Love
Anastasia - No
Brooke - No
Autumn - No
Winnie - No
Sloane - No
Quinn - Boys name to me
Clemmie - No
Scarlett - No
Tatum - No
Xanthe - OK
Talia - No
Willow - No
Ottilie - OK
Savannah - No
Eden - No
Lilia - OK
Cassidy - No
Tallulah -No
Bonnie - No
Tatiana - No
Saskia -No
Jemima - OK
Sasha - No
Alicia - OK
Constance - No
Florence - OK
Annie - Like
Jasmine - No
Sadie - No
Milla - No
Cassia - Quite like this
Cordelia - OK
Arabella - No

My faves = Tabitha, Cassia and Martha

Other suggestions: Alexa, Flora

Autumn
Clemmie (Clementine)
Scarlett
Xanthe
Talia
Willow
Ottilie
Eden (boy to me, but ok)
Lilia
Jemima
Sasha
Alicia
Constance
Jasmine
Sadie
Cordelia
Arabella

These are OK Ottilie and Willow are my favourites.

I love

Tabitha
Anastasia
Jemima
Annie.

Nell or Martha

Tabitha - bit old fashioned for my liking.
Alana - pretty name.
Edith - sounds like an old lady.
Nell - not my cup of tea, but nothing wrong with it... It just seems like it's shortened from another name, instead of a name in it's own right.
Martha - It's OK.
Anastasia - Quite nice.
Brooke - Quite like.
Autumn - Not a bad name, but better for a middle name imo.
Winnie - No, makes me think of an old lady at the bingo.
Sloane - How would you pronounce it?
Quinn - Not my cuppa.
Clemmie - Either Clementine, or Clement. Clemmie isn't a name in itself, as far as I'm aware. Of course, you can make it so.
Scarlett - It's alright, but not to keen on having a double t at the end.
Tatum - No.
Xanthe - Alright.
Talia - OK.
Willow - Better for a middle name but not a bad name.
Ottilie - Don't really have an opinion on it, to be honest.
Savannah - Quite a pretty name.
Eden - Better for a middle name, but not too bad.
Lilia - Pretty, but a lot like Lily.
Cassidy - I again would favour this more as a middle name. Quite nice as a middle name, actually.
Tallulah - Not really my thing, but nothing wrong with it.
Bonnie - Makes me think of Bonnie n Clyde, so not really into it.
Tatiana - OK.
Saskia - Not really into it.
Jemima -Alright.
Sasha - Not really liking it.
Alicia - Pretty name.
Constance - Sounds more like a place name, than a name for a girl.
Florence - Same as above. Although nothing directly wrong with this one, could work as a middle name. NN would be Florry.
Annie - My grandma is named this, but nothing wrong with it pretty timeless name.
Jasmine - Pretty name.
Sadie - OK name.
Milla - Don't really like it.
Cassia - I prefer Cassie or Cassandra which are both nice names.
Cordelia - No, makes me think of Buffy.
Arabella - Pretty name, not sure I'd name my daughter it though. Lovely for a kitten though

Tabitha - quite like it
Alana = no
Edith - Prefer Edie
Nell - Like it
Martha - Like it
Anastasia - Ugly sister or posh Russian?!
Brooke - No
Autumn -Love it
Winnie - Quite like it even though it says 'witch' to me!
Sloane - no
Quinn - Quite like it, likethe character in Glee
Clemmie - no! sounds like clammy!
Scarlett - okay
Tatum - Not sure, maybe in America?
Xanthe - no
Talia - not sure
Willow - love it
Ottilie -going to get trendy like Amelia
Savannah - no
Eden - love it
Lilia - hmmm no
Cassidy - quite like it
Tallulah -No
Bonnie - not unless you are having a golden retriever
Tatiana - Russian Stripper
Saskia - No!
Jemima - Cute
Sasha - no
Alicia - sounds lvery 90's for some reason
Constance -no, reminds me of constipated
Florence - yes
Annie - ok
Jasmine - 90's name agan
Sadie - another dog name
Milla - ok
Cassia - Isn't that a watch brand or something?
Cordelia - sounds like lime cordial or something
Arabella -too twee

Looks like the only ones I really like are:

Willow
Autumn
Eden

I'm a hippie! lol

Talia
Willow
Ottilie
Eden
Annie
Jasmine
Sadie
Cassia

I like these from your list.

Saskia is lovely, I think it works at all ages too. I know a teenage one who is Sassy to her friends- could be nn when tiny? The stand out name for me from your list and many of the others could work as a middle.

Bloody hell: that's a long list!

Tabitha - no
Alana = no
Edith - yes
Nell - yes as nn
Martha - yes
Anastasia - I like it but no
Brooke - noooooooo
Autumn -no
Winnie - no
Sloane - please god, no
Quinn - guy in Jaws
Clemmie - no
Scarlett - okay
Tatum - hideous
Xanthe - no
Talia - no
Willow - no but not hideous
Ottilie -ok
Savannah - no
Eden - ok
Lilia - sounds like sanitary towels
Cassidy - no but love Cassie
Tallulah - nooooooo
Bonnie - noooooooooo
Tatiana - try hard
Saskia - no
Jemima - no
Sasha - no
Alicia - no but I like Alice
Constance -yes
Florence - yes
Annie - fine
Jasmine ok
Sadie - hate this
Milla - no
Cassia - no
Cordelia - try hard
Arabella -ok

Edith with nn Edie prob my favourite

My favourite is Martha.
Also like Cordelia, Lilia, and Scarlett.
I surprise myself in quite liking Sloane - know there is a US tennis player called this and that's the only one I know of. It's quite masculine and strong sounding though.
My least favourites from your list are Bonnie, Winnie, Nell and Constance.

Tatty could be short for Natalia, which is a pretty name.

Saskia was one of my fave names when DD was born (after a doctor who, imo, saved her life during my pregnancy). I had never heard the name before. My sister asked if I had any names planned, and when I said Saskia she cracked up laughing, and had obviously thought I was joking. It sort of put me off! Shortly after DD was born, a Saskia shot Martin Kemp's character in Eastenders, so I was glad I hadn't chosen it. Still like it though!

Tabitha - cat
Alana - don't like the sound much
Edith -no
Nell -not my favorite
Martha -quite like it
Anastasia - no
Brooke - no
Autumn - no
Winnie - as a nn
Sloane - no
Quinn - no
Clemmie - as a nn
Scarlett - not my favourite
Tatum - like this!
Xanthe - love this. I knew one as a child.
Talia - no
Willow - no
Ottilie - not my fav
Savannah - no
Eden - no
Lilia - no
Cassidy - no
Tallulah - no
Bonnie - quite like it
Tatiana - no
Saskia - quite like it
Jemima - a bit too girly for me
Sasha - I like this
Alicia - quite like this
Constance - I quite like this, with connie as a nickname
Florence - no
Annie - I do rather like Anne (then you could use Annie as a nn). It has a classic quality, and isn't at all common at the moment. But it may be because it is my Mums name!
Jasmine - no
Sadie - no
Milla - knew one as a child but not my favourite name
Cassia - not so keen
Cordelia - no
Arabella - no

So, in sum, my favourites are:
Xanthe
Sasha
Anne (Annie)
Tatum

I like Anastasia, Scarlett, Willow, Savannah, Jasmine and Cordelia best off this list

Stand out name for me from your list is Scarlett

Tatty is bad, sorry.

Very eclectic mix (I applaud you).
But SLOANE? Are you serious? Sloane???

Tabitha - not keen, makes me think of cat
Alana - like the sound of it but just makes me think of Alan, which I don't like
Edith - nice, LOVE Edie as nickname
Nell - like
Martha - like
Anastasia - ok
Brooke - no
Autumn - no (maybe as middle name would be nice)
Winnie - the witch
Sloane - !!!!!!!!!
Quinn - sounds like a boy's name to me
Clemmie - no
Scarlett - nice
Tatum - no
Xanthe - no
Talia - no
Willow - not bad
Ottilie - cute
Savannah - no
Eden - ok
Lilia - nice
Cassidy - nice
Tallulah - ok
Bonnie - blue peter dog (showing my age)
Tatiana - no
Saskia - nice
Jemima - no
Sasha - ok
Alicia - ok
Constance - no
Florence - lots of them about
Annie - nice
Jasmine - ok
Sadie - ok
Milla - no
Cassia - like
Cordelia - no
Arabella - no

My favourites are Tabitha, Scarlett, Ottilie, Saskia, Jemima and Jasmine.

Tabitha - nice, but wouldn't like it shortened to Tabby
Alana - quite nice, Nordic sounding, am thinking cool tall Swede
Edith - not sure, first thought was little old lady
Nell - Too short am thinking Little Nell
Martha - Servant girl in days of old
Anastasia - like full name, but that wouldn't happen and would be Annie
Brooke - American beauty pageant contestant
Autumn - Quite like this and difficult to shorten.
Winnie - The Pooh
Sloane - Yuck - sorry
Quinn - Wrestler
Clemmie - lovely if short for Clementine, not on its own
Scarlett - angry toddler, red in face
Tatum - American and spoilt
Xanthe - No
Talia - Looks made up
Willow - Ethereal, willowy with slightly hippyish parents
Ottilie - Def. no
Savannah - Trailer trash
Eden - Quite nice, potential for teasing though
Lilia - Prefer Lilly, sounds made up
Cassidy - The Partridge family
Tallulah - Difficult to shorten nicely
Bonnie - lovely for young child, not sure about an adult
Tatiana - Do you want your child called Tatty?
Saskia - Ok
Jemima - lovely
Sasha - Ok
Alicia - Nice
Constance - Very nice and like Connie as nn
Florence - Would get shorted to Flo and would make me think of

sanitary ware
Annie - Little old last, very serious, quite child
Jasmine - Love this and would love Jas or J as nn
Sadie - Sad
Milla - Vacuum cleaner
Cassia - Sounds like a boys name
Cordelia - Aged aunt
Arabella - Sorry, no

1. Jasmine
2. Constance
3. Jemima

Tabitha - cat
Alana - honey boo boo (but actually quite a nice name imo)
Edith - truly awful.
Nell - nice as a nn for something else, maybe Helena
Martha - ok
Anastasia- Disney princess
Brooke - ok
Autumn - ok
Winnie - the witch or the pooh
Sloane - square (and surely a boys name anyway?)
Quinn - okish
Clemmie - clammy clemmie
Scarlett - ok
Tatum - no
Xanthe - not for me, but it is a proper name
Talia - nice
Willow - ok
Ottilie - fine
Savannah - nice
Eden - no
Lilia - nice
Cassidy - no, although I really like Cassie
Tallulah - no
Bonnie - ok
Tatiana - Russian hooker
Saskia - ok
Jemima - puddleduck
Sasha - nice
Alicia - nice
Constance - I like Connie as a nn
Florence - nice
Annie - nice
Jasmine - Disney princess
Sadie - ok
Milla - ok
Cassia - not for me
Cordelia - not for me

Arabella - not for me

Love Anastasia and Cordelia.

Quinn is a boys name, sometimes short for Quentin.

I really like Sasha & Sadie from the list. I much prefer Mila to Milla.

Is Francesca any good?

Talia, Eden or Autumn are my favourites on your list.

Talia and Eden were on my list 8 years ago for dc2 but had ds and I still love them.

My niece is an Autumn So I'm biased