DH has gone off DS name at 40+2

we have an Isaac. It is a great name, never gets shortened (though I like Zac)

it is a family name, and we didn't have another one up our sleeve, but really when you meet your baby, they influence your choice. I met him and decided Yes he really was an Isaac.

But never tell anyone your names in advance, you get lots of odd reactions. Once it is the baby's name, people react differently.

Can Isaac be Zac?

Isn't Fyffe what the stickers on bananas say? Never heard it as a name and not that keen. Bollocks to what your DH's workmates think though.

My best friend was carrying a Dominic all the way through her pregnancy, and when I turned up to congratulate her, I asked 'what does Dominic weigh?' --Response was 7 pound exactly... but his name is Philip.

Simply, you'll just know when baby is in your arms.

Yes it was out of order of her. She screwed up her nose and said something like "oh but that's so common, we've had loads this week" .

We are glad we changed it at the last minute despite everyone's surprise when we announced the birth. It wouldn't have been right in the end. However, it wasn't the midwife's place to critique our name!

I decided to call my first child after my grandmother, it was weird when she was born because it was such a long old fashioned name, I regretted it but couldn't change it as my granny would have been gutted, but after a month I could imagine her being anything else, and 23 years later it is still fairly uncommon, she loves it, not having anyone else in her social group with the same name and since my granny died when she was 4 she loves the family connection. So do what you want and don't let anyone put you off.

Was that to me kat? Well obviously we weren't sold on the original name as I'm not usually so easy to manipulate. We do prefer the name we used as well, and so does he, when we tell him his lucky escape!

I would say stick to Isaac as you clearly like it.

However, we changed DS1 name after he had been delivered because the midwife didn't like it ,

We don't regret it one bit, but I do think midwife was naughty as she didn't know us at all and we were at an emotional and vulnerable state!

Stick with Isaac, it's a good solid classic name.

I like Seth, and Theo as nickname for Theodore.

First thought on Fyffe was the Fyffes fruit importers.

If your DH has really gone off Isaac it 's better to accept it now than after he's here maybe? I like Isaac. Fwiw I love Seth, really love it, and like Theo too. Fyffe makes me think Fife too, which isn't an awful thing, but it's not my favourite of your choices (there wouldn't be another in the class though, if that's important to you?)

Isaac was on our list for our 2nd DC. We had a girl though.
Just a quick FYI, you only have 21 days to register births in Scotland, not 6 weeks.
Congratulations on your wee man!

We were set on a name for ds and then later dd, changed our minds when we saw them as they didn't look like the name, I always wonder how people name their bumps and stick with it - I've known people to buy personalised things before the baby is born, each to their own, but what if that name doesn't suit them?

My advice, keep your choices to yourself (and dh) and wait until you meet the baby, after seeing you in labour most dh's will happily agree with your chosen name!

I quite like Isaac as long as your surname is not Hunt. Fyffe made me think of bananas too.

The randoms who are on a board or who work with DH don't live with your DCs so honestly don't be swayed OP, you know that your PILs will be thrilled you have a safe delivery and whatever name you choose, they'll accept DS with it.

I like Theo the most

DP and I chose a name for DS quite early on, then when it got closer to my due date I was a bit wobbly with the idea, but I stuck with that name and I have no regrets.. really suits him!

My first thought re: Fyffe, living in Scotland as I do, was Fife.
My second thought was bananas.

Does Isaac mean laughter, that's great .

Fyffe or Isaac, you won't care what outsiders think.

I agree that Fyffe is a great name and would go well with a long surname. I don't know any boys named this and so he will probably be easily remembered and identified! I know lots of Isaacs and Theos, on the other hand.
Go with what you love!

Dont worry about it. Just keep your mind open and keep discussing, you have plenty of time and maybe when you meet your son choosing a name might be easier.

I bet you'd get a worse reaction if you told the same people 'Fyffe'.
Isaac is a lovely name.

Well my DDs name means "lame" which is not particularly nice but it is irrelevant really.

It's also the name of a supermodel and as DD is tall, slim, with long blond hair, people ask if we called her after said supermodel. ER... No. We didn't know what she would end up looking like when she was born.

Just go with what you like. They are all lovely and your son will just become what his name is. It just seems to work like that.

Go with what you love (as long as its not too outrageous which Isaac isn't). We had a name we loved for DS3 and told my mum,MIL and BF, as well as one casual acquaintance at work. No-one liked it so we went with something safer. Still regret listening to them!