I too have a reasonably normal name (for the 80s) with an unusual spelling. Never could get anything with my name on, which was at times frustrating, so I only ever had a big blue marble with my name specially engraved on it. Now I'm kind of pleased, as all the other trinkety things you normally get your name on just wouldn't be as special as that blue marble. Still have it!
Seeker ...why not something Addams family inspired? ... Dementia? Lol.
I think a lot of the more old fashioned names are after plants, so why not choose a favourite plant or flower? It doesn't have to be an obvious one. I used to know a girl called Hebe, or there's always Hydrangea- harder to spell maybe.
Peony
Heliotrope
Violet
Dahlia
Hyacinth (hee)
Muscari
Wisteria
Honeysuckle
Magnolia
Snowdrop
Bluebell
Crocus...
next time you're in a book shop, grab one on bulbs, or flowers for the garden- I bet there's loads of ideas. I'm not saying they'll all be relevant (Hyacinth, hee) but you never know!
Or what about Shakespearean names?
Ophelia
Perdita
Portia
Cordelia
Goneril (DH accidentaly said Gonnorhea, maybe not!)
Regan
Desdemona
Titania
Hermia
Helena
Viola
Bianca
Dorcas
Francisca
Lavinia
Miranda
Nerissa
Mariana
Rosalind(e)
Adriana
Luciana
Luce
Emilia
Celia
Rosaline
(DH just suggested Lady Macbeth, I'm guessing that's a no)
or Isolde? Not Shakespearean, but still nice in a kind of antiquey way.
Someone I know named their son Otto because it was a palindrome- always thought that was kind of cool.