Please give your thoughts on our girls names

Claudia- love it!
Eloise- yes quite like it
Harriet- no, dreadful
Hester- terrible, but Esther is nicer. The huh and ssstt together is too much
Elizabeth- lovely but I would use either Eliza or Beth
Poppy- no. Insubstantial and ugly at the same time.

Tabitha- no, dreadful
Tamsin - ok

Claudia - nice and strong, good grown-up name
Eloise - don't like - too frilly
Harriet - good, strong woman's name
Hester - too Nathaniel Hawthorn?
Elizabeth - no, but no - not sure why I'm having this overly strong reaction
Poppy - too trivial for a grown-up
Tabitha - too north london
Tamsin - quite nice, unusual but not too out there, strong but feminine

Sorry 'tis personal preference I suppose 'round my neck of the woods a Tamzyn would be called Tammy her dad would be called a nickname of his surname all his life and smoke weed (this is going from two families I know) and the mum would swear at the kids... I also know a Tamzin who recently went to prison for murder (ex-work colleague not friend) so the name doesn't have nice connotations to me

Love Hester.

Like Claudia and Tamsin (not at all chavvy; my friend Tamsin was a university professor).

DD was nearly Tamsin

I like Claudia and Tabitha from your list.

YY to Elizabeth as a middle name.

I too know several Poppy's under the age of 5!

Claudia- nice but it sounds odd to my ears with the hard 'Cl' sound plus it doesn't sit well as a first name with any if the others as second.
Eloise- I like this but again it doesn't sit well with any of the others as a first name.
Harriet- this is lovely :) Harriet Elizabeth sounds lovely and you could call her Harri for a NN :)
Hester- uncle Hester (fester-adams family)is all that springs to mind for me so likely that will happen with a lot of people...
Elizabeth- excellent middle name :) I like it for the first name too but not with any of the others as middle names
Poppy- lovely but very over used ATM
Tabitha- I don't like this one at all... I had a baby doll that used to scare me as a child called tabitha...
Tamsin- sounds very Chav-esque to me (sorry) I would imagine her with a side pony tail and a juicy couture velour track suit on swearing loudly chewing chewing gum...(specific I know but that's the image that scream to mind...)

My favourite is Harriet Elizabeth... :) it's lovely!

Love Harriet and Eloise.

Agree Tamsin is 80s, Poppy too popular, Elizabeth dull and Tabtha a cat's name.

Can't decide on Hester.

I like Harriet and Elizabeth. Poppy too popular atm. Not too keen on your others.

I like Elizabeth and Tamsin.

I like most of your list.

My very very favourite is Tabitha, it's a fabulous name don't listen to people who say it's catty, the feline connotations are part of what makes it such a lovely name!

Followed by Hester (Esther is lovely too) and Harriet. Eloise is pretty, makes me think of the 80's song by - was it The Damned? Quite like Claudia.

Elizabeth is Ok but a bit ordinary compared to the names above.

Poppy is just far too cutesy and stands out as being quite different to your other ideas.

Tamsin sounds like the name of a character from a Blue Jeans photo story (showing my age....), very 1980's as someone has already said.

From your names I'd go with Tabitha Harriet.

You might also like; Eliza, Esme, Ursula, Anita, Lydia, Anya, Meredith, Verity.

i really like Tamsin.

also like Elizabeth.

I love Eloise, Harriet, Tabitha and Hester (although I think Esther is even nicer than Hester).

Elizabeth is classic and I love Beth and Eliza but its just a bit plain.

I personally dislike the sound of the name Claudia. I also think it sounds pretentious. I also really dislike Tamsin which has a very 80s ring to my ears.

Poppy is OK, a bit meh but OK.

Hester Elizabeth is my favourite.

Hester Eloise

Claudia Poppy. Lovely!

Hester and Eloise are my favourites.

Elizabeth is great with heaps of possible nicknames declares bias as mum of Bess

Love love love Tabitha.

Really like Hester, Claudia and Tamsin, too.

Knowmheapsmof little Harriets all of a sudden, and Poppys too.

Claudia - I have an irrational hatred of this one, think it's really awful
Eloise - fine, bit bland
Harriet - like
Hester - It makes me think of witches
Elizabeth - love
Poppy - ok
Tabitha - this also makes me think of witches
Tamsin - not keen

I think I'd choose Harriet Elizabeth or Harriet Eloise

Like Hester Eloise or Hester Elizabeth best so far.

What about Henrietta (Hetty) with Poppy as a middle name?

Claudia Elizabeth. Fosho.

Elizabeth, Harriet and Eloise but not the rest.

Clara
Juliet
Elodie
Holly
Coralie
Vivienne
Violet
Charlotte
Meredith
Georgia
Francesca
Indira
Jessica
Anthea
Martha
Scarlett
Jasmine
Madeleline
Miranda
Larissa/Lara
Iona
Philippa/Pippa
Seren/a

Claudia, Harriet and Elizabeth are my favourites from your list.

Claudia - quite like it. Very timeless and elegant
Eloise - not keen, it sounds a bit nasal to my ears
Harriet - quite like it but not very exciting
Hester - like it and only know of teenagers with the name, no little ones
Elizabeth - bit meh. It's ok and the ultimate timeless name but not a name I'd ever choose
Poppy - It's ok. Pretty but lacking substance
Tabitha - not keen. too catty
Tamsin - quite like this

I would choose:
Hesther Eloise
Harriet Elizabeth
Claudia Tamsin