Hazel -pretty and never met one much younger than me
Zoe - like it
Amy - love it
Beth - not keen
Elizabeth - It's ok but I don't like the nicknames and it always gets them
Libby - not keen
Meg(an) - Megan is nice. Don't like Meg
Lucy - like it
Beatrice -not keen
Carys - love it
I would have Amy or Carys from your list.
Similar:
Anya, Amber, Annie, Asha, Ayla, Alice, Astrid, Asia, Brooke, Bryony, Bethan, Cerys, Ciara, Cara, Chloe, Claire, Callie, Darcey, Dana, Eilidh, Ellen, Eden, Faith, Farrah, Freya, Grace, Hannah, Hayley, Halle, Iris, Imogen, Juliet, Jade, Katie, Lottie, Leah, Layla, Lauren, Lara, Morgan, Macey, Naomi, Orla, Paige, Rosie, Ria, Sara, Seren, Sophie, Tegan, Tanya, Verity, Zara, Zia