your opinions on my longlist for a girl

Elisabeth Alice is perfect.

Valentina is much nicer, excuse typos!

Wow, that is long [grin

I love Sylvie, Rose (or Rosa), Cora, Valentina, Camille.

Josephine, Susannah and Anna are nice, classic names.

Prefer Juliet to the 'ette' ending, which is fussy.

The ones that make me shudder are:
Mirabelle
Valerie (not ready for a comeback -Valentine is far nicer)
Justine (1970s-tastic, sorry Justie MN! )
Jacqueline (terribly dated)

Danielle and Gabrielle are 'meh'. Giselle?

Prefer Stella or the Spanish Estrella to Estelle

Isabelle, Eva, Alice and Sophie are very popular names in the UK, which is slightly off putting to me, but may not be to you.

The rest are all fine names, just not to my taste.

Sylvie - no, I have images of an old barmaid aka Bet Lynch
Elise - very nice. A good name for a grown woman, but also suits a child. Pretty, yet stylish at the same time.
Corinne (KO-rinn) - nope.
Isabelle - boring
Juliane - to work I think it has to be spelt Julianne, otherwise it looks mispelt, having said that, don't like it.
Valerie - works in a bakery and is 50.
Serena - classy posh bird.
Rose - boring
Adele - nice but people might think you are naming her after Adele.
Mirabelle - no, but only because I studied a play at school with a character called Mirabell - and HE was a vain, nasty piece of work.
Jacqueline - no, she is 50.
Tabitha - cat
Elisabeth - boring
Camille - don't like the French pronunciation.
Madeleine - pretty
Sophie - boring
Juliette - nice, but Juliet is better. That said, all Juliet's live with the Romeo question.
Gemma (btw we are not in UK, this has never been popular here) - no
Alice - ok
Eva - pretty
Valentina - gorgeous gorgeous gorgeous
Estelle - ok
Calista - Flockhart
Justine - Grange Hill
Eloise - pretty, but better as a middle name
Anna - boring
Stephanie - nice
Eleanor - never liked
Gabrielle - Gabriella is WAY better. Lovely name.
Josephine - no
Danielle - no
Cora - no
Annabel - ok
Susannah - ok. Not keen on the inevitable Susie, Suze, Sue nicknames.

Sylvie - prefer Sylvia
Elise - not my cup of tea but I can see it becoming popular.
Corinne (KO-rinn) - not keen
Isabelle - nice but popular
Juliane - no
Valerie - ok
Serena - not keen
Rose - nice
Adele - like it and uncommon
Mirabelle - unusual but nice
Jacqueline -cute but only for certain people
Tabitha -not keen
Elisabeth -a nice name to have
Camille -ok
Madeleine -not keen but i like Maddie
Sophie -ok
Juliette -like it
Gemma (btw we are not in UK, this has never been popular here) -nice
Alice -nice
Eva -nice depending on how old you are
Valentina -not my cup of tea
Estelle -i can see it becoming popular

Calista -no
Justine -no
Eloise -ok
Anna no
Stephanie -average
Eleanor -nice
Gabrielle -nice and uncommon
Josephine -no
Danielle -like it
Cora -no
Annabel -ok
Susannah -no

Sylvie - not keen. Prefer Sylvia but still don't really like it
Elise - Pretty. I probably wouldn't choose it though
Corinne (KO-rinn)- not keen
Isabelle - love it
Juliane - sounds like Julian. Is is pronounced Julienne? Prefer Julia/Juliette
Valerie - dislike
Serena - not keen
Rose - it's ok. Prefer Rosa and like Rosie
Adele - quite sweet
Mirabelle - like it
Jacqueline - like it but wouldn't want Jackie
Tabitha - not keen
Elisabeth - it's ok
Camille - not keen. Like Camilla
Madeleine - love it
Sophie - like it
Juliette - love it
Gemma (btw we are not in UK, this has never been popular here) - not keen
Alice - like it
Eva - love it
Valentina - dislike
Estelle - hate
Calista - it's ok
Justine - dislike
Eloise - not keen
Anna - like it
Stephanie - like it
Eleanor - like it
Gabrielle - like it. Love Gabriella
Josephine - it's ok
Danielle - it's ok
Cora - like it
Annabel - love it, prefer spelling Annabelle
Susannah - like it

Like (very much):
Susannah
Josephine
Alice
Elisabeth
Anna

Hate:
Jaqueline
Gemma

I love Valerie, Susannah, Camilla, Juliet, Josephine - all on my list, beautiful.
Valentina is also lovely.
Alice, Rose, Gabrielle, Cora, Estelle are fine (Love Coral though)
Sophie, Sylvie, Madeleine, Eleanor, Isabelle, Anna - I find boring (although I really love Anne/Annie)
Really dislike - Jaqueline, Serena, Eva, Eloise, Stephanie, Danielle, Annabel, Justine

Tabitha is my fave

Elise is my fave from your list

I love:
Valentina
Calista
Josephine
Alice
Serena
Madeleine
Mirabelle (but spelled Mirabel)

Like a lot:
Jacqueline
Juliette (spelled Juliet)
Eva
Estelle
Anna
Annabel
Susanna
*Camilla (slightly prefer to Camille)
*Sylvia (slightly prefer to Sylvie)

Like:
Tabitha
Elisabeth
Justine
Gabrielle
Gemma
*Adela (slightly prefer to Adele)

Names that have a significant drawback imo:
Juliane - 70s
Valerie - 70s
Rose - old ladyish and not in a good way
Corinne - pronunciation - expect to hear a lot of Ko-RIN and Ko-REEN
Sophie - too popular; Sophia is also very popular
Stephanie - 70s
Danielle - 80s
Cora - middle aged Irish Home Econ teachers

El- names that will become Ellie (so I would avoid unless you love Ellie):
Elise
Eloise
Eleanor

(I have come across one Coren that was pronounced KO-rin.)

Nice list!

My favourites are Sylvie, Elise, Serena, Elisabeth, Madeleine, Estelle, Calista, Eloise, Eleanor, Gabrielle.

And Corinne, but I'd pronounce it Co-reen not Co-rinn.

I don't dislike any of these although find Justine, Jacqueline and Valerie a bit middle aged. Isabelle, Eva and Sophie are v popular here but that may not be an issue where you are.

You might also like (not that you need more options! ) Delphine, Selina, Marianne...

It's a very long list indeed but think my opinions are quite different from many of those you've had so far so have had a quick run through it for you.

LOVE
Tabitha - yes it has feline connotations, that's part of why it's a great name
Camille
Isabelle - prefer Isobel but as others have said it is vv popular at moment
Alice
Eleanor

OK
Elise
Corinne (KO-rinn) but with this spelling I'd read it as Cor - een
Juliane
Serena
Rose
Elisabeth
Juliette
Calista
Anna
Cora

Don't Like
Sylvie
Valerie
Adele
Mirabelle
Jacqueline
Madeleine
Sophie
Gemma
Eva
Valentina
Estelle
Justine
Eloise
Stephanie
Gabrielle
Josephine
Danielle
Annabel
Susannah

I guess I just don't like 'flouncy' names and not keen on 'ee' sounds at the end either.

Like
Alice
Elizabeth
Eleanor
Susannah
Anna
Sophie

All were on our girls list. And DD has 2 of them!

Like Rose and Eloise best from those!

Sylvie - OK but prefer Sylvia
Elise - No
Corinne (KO-rinn) - No
Isabelle - Rather popular recently
Juliane - OK
Valerie - No
Serena - No
Rose - OK
Adele - OK
Mirabelle - No
Jacqueline - No
Tabitha - Yes I like!
Elisabeth - OK
Camille - Prefer Camilla but yes quite pretty
Madeleine - No
Sophie - Love, classic and timeless.
Juliette - Like
Gemma (btw we are not in UK, this has never been popular here) - OK
Alice - Like
Eva - Rather popular
Valentina - No
Estelle - No
Calista - No
Justine - No
Eloise - No
Anna - No
Stephanie - No
Eleanor - Way too popular
Gabrielle - No
Josephine - Like
Danielle - No
Cora - Like
Annabel - OK but becoming popular. Know of 3 born in 2012 so far!
Susannah - No

I have

Eleanor
Alice
Elizabeth
Anna

on my list. My new favourite is Alice and I am seriously considering this for my dc due in May.

I also like Isabella - but this is very popular in the UK

Like:

Sylvie
Elise
Corinne
Valerie
Rose
Elisabeth
Gemma
Alice
Eloise
Anna
Stephanie
Josephine
Cora
Susannah

Dislike:

Juliane
Serena
Mirabelle
Jaqueline
Valentina
Justine
Danielle

The rest I don't mind!

Sylvie - think I prefer Sylvia, perhaps Sylvie as a nickname
Elise - lovely
Corinne (KO-rinn) - lovely
Isabelle - lovely
Juliane - quite unusual, I like it
Valerie - reminds me of the song, I'm afraid. Not keen.
Serena - love it
Rose - favourite
Adele - people will/may think you named her after the singer
Mirabelle - a little bit flouncy
Jacqueline - bit old-fashioned
Tabitha - sorry, always a cat association
Elisabeth - think she'd probably be spelling it every time 's not a z'
Camille - that's nice
Madeleine - lovely
Sophie - one of my favourites
Juliette - think I prefer as Juliet
Gemma - lovely
Alice - lovely
Eva - lovely
Valentina - not keen
Estelle - not keen
Calista - not keen
Justine - not keen
Eloise - nice
Anna - nice
Stephanie - not keen
Eleanor - lovely
Gabrielle - lovely
Josephine - not keen
Danielle - not keen
Cora - lovely
Annabel - lovely
Susannah - lovely

my fave is Valentina

Sylvie- don't understand its appeal
Elise- lovely
Corinne- really nice
Isabelle- can't understand the popularity of this
Juliane- pretty
Valerie- sounds middle-aged to me
Serena- nice
Rose- classic
Adele- ok
Mirabelle- hate it
Jacqueline- indifferent
Tabitha- cat name
Elisabeth- classic
Camille- lovely, elegant
Madeleine- not a fan
Sophie- nice, very popular
Juliette- beautiful
Gemma- blah
Alice- pretty
Eva- gorgeous
Valentina- nice but long
Estelle- bad images in my head, not sure why though
Calista- very nice
Justine- meh
Eloise- pretty
Anna- ok
Stephanie- ok
Eleanor- don't like it
Gabrielle- gorgeous
Josephine- not a fan
Danielle- ok
Cora- really nice
Annabel- hate it
Susannah- ok

Top 5:
Corinne
Serena
Eva
Gabrielle
Cora

Valentina is my hands down favourite from that list. I may be slightly biased though

I also like Isabelle and Cora. Gemma is my least favourite.

Love Tabitha, Elisabeth (and Elise which could be a nn), Madeleine (my favourite!), Eleanor, and Eva. Of the others, they are also beautiful. I don't think you can go wrong with any of them.

Sylvie - I understand that lots of people like this name but I just don't get the appeal.
Elise - A bit of a non-entity, in my opinion.
Corinne (KO-rinn) - Fine.
Isabelle - Too popular for my own tastes but I can see why so many people like it.
Juliane - Indifferent.
Valerie - Not ready for a come back.
Serena - Pretty. Will remind young'uns of Justin Bieber's girlfriend.
Rose - Pretty.
Adele - Inextricably bound up with the singer in my mind.
Mirabelle - Bit too frilly.
Jacqueline - Could be ready for a comeback.
Tabitha - Like it for someone else's child but not for me.
Elisabeth - Like this spelling but would only use it if it were the common spelling where I lived.
Camille - Don't like the 'mille' ending; much prefer Camilla.
Madeleine - Can't disassociate it from the unfortunate Madeleine McCann. That said, it's a nice name. Too many ways of pronouncing it for it to be one I used.
Sophie - Fine. Know quite a lot of Sophies so it doesn't wow me but it's a lovely, sensible choice.
Juliette - Like it a lot.
Gemma - Fine. Gem is a cute nickname. I also like Emma.
Alice - Like it a lot.
Eva - Like it.
Valentina - Not very wearable but sounds pretty.
Estelle - Another singer. Prefer Stella or maybe Estella but the latter might be a bit Great Expectations-y.
Calista - Flockhart. Not one for me. Reminds me of Calypso ice-lollies.
Justine - David Milliband's wife.
Eloise - Nice. But prefer Louisa or Elodie.
Anna - Like it a lot.
Stephanie - Fine.
Eleanor - Fine.
Gabrielle - Prefer Gabriel for a boy but this is pretty.
Josephine - Like it.
Danielle - Bit 80s?
Cora - Fine.
Annabel - Too frilly.
Susannah - Love it.

Sylvie - ok, pretty
Elise - no
Corinne (KO-rinn) - no
Isabelle - like
Juliane - prefer Julianna
Valerie - no
Serena - ok
Rose - a bit dull
Adele - nice
Mirabelle - no
Jacqueline - no
Tabitha - not unless she's a cat or a witch
Elisabeth - lovely, classic, lots of nice nn
Camille - nice and not too popular
Madeleine - like
Sophie - a bit dull
Juliette - no
Gemma (btw we are not in UK, this has never been popular here) - a bit dull
Alice - like
Eva - prefer Ava
Valentina - ok
Estelle - no
Calista - like nn Callie
Justine - no
Eloise -no
Anna - like
Stephanie - a bit dull
Eleanor - ok
Gabrielle -ok
Josephine - no
Danielle- no
Cora - really like this one
Annabel - like
Susannah - ok

My top 5 are;

Elisabeth
Alice
Camille
Isabelle
Cora