Please critique our shortlist..

Samuel and Louisa are my favourites :) I also really like Lois as an alternative

Hugh (DH favourite though won't be able to use the middle name as all I can think of is 'Hugh Jackman'. DH doesn't like Hugo)- Ok a bit too "now".
Samuel Jack - Nice enough but remoinds me of Samuel Jackson
Angus Jack _ not keen on this.
Lewis Jack [my favourite (after my ultimate favourite Joseph, which DH veoted] - Like this.
Louis Jack _ Probably my favourite
Heath Jack - No doesn't sound right to me somehow.

Camille Margaret - ok
Charlotte Margaret (has always been my favourite girls name though I'm having doubts given how popular it is) - go with this classic name and your favourite.
Alice Margaret - a bit old lady.
Louisa Margaret (DH's favourite, I also am quite keen) - My second choice after Charlotte.
Brigitte Margaret - quite nice.

Samuel or Louisa

Hugh Alexander much nicer than Hugh Jack.

Might be worth considering your surname. Hugh Jack = Huge Ac...

Love Camille Margaret.

Agree some of your names are a bit punchy with Jack. What about adding an extra name if you love them?

Hugh Anthony Jack
Heath William Jack

Or something.

Samuel or Louisa.

Hugh Jack and Heath Jack don't sound right. I like Charlotte but it sounds odd with Margaret, as does Brigitte.

Love Camille. Also love Brijheet but not Brigheeta. But she would spend her whole life saying "actually it's Brijheet (or Brigheeta)".

Samuel or Louis (Loo-ee) are my favourites. Heath or other one-syllable names sound odd with Jack.

I love Camille Margaret. Louisa and Alice are both lovely, too. Charlotte is nice, but a bit plain. Not keen on Brigitte.

Hugh Jack -- is a bit like Huge Jass (Simpson's joke)
Samuel Jack -- very nice
Angus Jack -- very nice
Lewis Jack -- doesn't really flow
Louis Jack -- nice
Heath Jack -- sounds a bit clunky - like two nouns stuck together as opposed to a name.

I think you should have a third name between the first name and Jack. Jack is just a very short and sharp middle name on its own. I think as the names stand, Samuel, Angus and Louis are the best with Jack.

Camille Margaret -- lovely
Charlotte Margaret -- I would go with Charlotte Margot (French pronunciation)
Alice Margaret -- this was a name I had in mind for DD3 so a thumbs up from me. Really lovely.
Louisa Margaret LOVE yet another name I had in mind for DD3 weirdly enough.
Brigitte Margaret -- Yet again, a name I was thinking of for DD3, but I was thinking either Brigid or Bridget. Brigitte is lovely (would you pronounce it as in Brigitte Bardot? - very nice imo))

Hugh - nice
Samuel Jack - too ordinary
Angus Jack - love
Lewis Jack - nice v commonplace though
Louis Jack - only is you pronounce looey
Heath Jack - no

Camille Margaret - dont like Camille
Charlotte Margaret - beware charlotte the harlot, kids can be cruel
Alice Margaret - pretty
Louisa- bit meh
Brigitte Margaret - not for me

I will offer Megan as a variant on Margaret, Juliet and Caroline, plus Patrick and Hamish.

Lewis or Louis, Camille or Louisa. Love Hugh, maybe he could have two middle names? Is Heath really a name? Only heard of Heath Ledger, otherwise makes me think 'moor, thicket, bog, common' etc.

Hugh not sure
Samuel Jack ok
Angus Jack not sure
Lewis Jack - no, Lewises are usually naughty
Louis Jack yes
Heath Jack not sure

Camille Margaret not sure
Charlotte Margaret like but not with Margaret, too rhymy
Alice Margaret LOVE
Louisa Margaret LOVE
Brigitte Margaret ok

Samuel and Louisa.
Sorted

Angus and Louisa.

Angus or Hugh

Camille for a girl.

Louisa or Hugh. Both very lovely. Classic and underused.

Lewis (to me) a snotty nosed skin headed liitle boy, Louis much better but may get called Lewis anyway.

Don't fret about what they sound like with middle names that will be a twice in a lifetime non problem.

Choose a first name you love, use the family names as middle names, everyone happy.

Love Alice and Louisa.
Samuel (shame about Joseph!)

Louisa is gorgeous! Not so keen on the other girls names...

And I think I like Angus best from the boy list.

Alice and Louisa are really nice names, think Alice is better with the middle name. Camille is a bit fussy for me and I think that Charlotte and Margaret are a bit much together.

Boys names - like Jack as a first name and actually think that it is a little odd as a middle name with some of your choices. Hugh Jack and Heath Jack are both 1 syllable - 1 syllable and don't feel right to me.

What about Alexander Jack

or Matthew Jack.

Hugh or Samuel and Alice or Bridgitte for me.

I love all your boys names, except for Heath. I don't like this name. My favourite is Hugh.

I love all your girls names except for Camille and Brigitte, which I'm not so keen on. Louisa is my favourite.

Alice or Bridget
Samuel or Angus