Your honest thoughts on these?

Roman and Octavia lovely, suspect you would need an italian connection tho. :)

Clementine - a joke surely.
Octavia - see above.
Ivy - OK.
Athena - ridiculous.
Pearl - OK.
Blossom - stupid.
Tabitha - a cat.
Skye - a dog.
India - too middle class.
Savannah - too American.

Chester - a monkey.
Balthazar - stupid.
Roman - stupider.
Thaddeus - worst name yet.
Seth - OK.
Saxon - awful.
Jasper - a cat.

There's no names here I can give two thumbs up to. Really really bad selection. Especially the boys.

Honestly I think people are reading into these choices too much, if your son is called Saxon it doesn't necessarily mean he will be a tattoo'ed heavy metal listener (not that there is anything wrong with that anyway!)

Any of them would be a lovely name, I don't find any, apart from Balthazar and Thaddeus which just seem "different for different's sake" to me, and Savannah which I find too American, all of them are lovely

India Pearl or India Skye
Athena Skye
Ivy Clementine

are my fave girls ones

Seth Roman would be my fave boy combo

I like Seth and Ivy.

The only name I like out of all these is Skye, though I would spell it Sky.
Don't like any of the others.

I like Seth, a lot.
Ivy and Pearl are ok.
Not keen on the others.

Clementine - an orange
Octavia - a ship
Ivy - traditional and querky...like it
Athena = not for me
Pearl - fortune teller
Blossom - a nick name
Tabitha - ok
Skye = a dog's name
India - yes like it
Savannah = not for me

Chester = a cat
Balthazar - a restaurant in New York
Roman - Chelsea
Thaddeus = a Greek god, yuck
Seth - star wars
Saxon - horrible
Jasper - a dog

I think there is a slight danger of trying too hard with these but a lot depends on your surname. If it's a really straightforward name, maybe do the "facebook test" checking you don't get 1000s of hits [confessionsmiley] but if you've got an unusual surname I would probably go for something more like an Emily or a James so that they won't need to spell two names. Others have mentioned the CV test (which I agree with) but I think the introducing-yourself-on-the-phone test is a good one too.

I like Pearl and Tabitha, Seth & Chester.

Clementine - love it, on my current list
Octavia - nice
Ivy - old lady
Athena - poster shop from the 80's
Pearl - old lady
Blossom - TV show I used to love
Tabitha - love it
Skye - nice
India - like this too
Savannah - not sure

Chester - great
Balthazar - love
Roman - abramovich
Thaddeus - love
Seth - love
Saxon - quite like this
Jasper - love

Clementine - like :)
Octavia - like :)
Ivy - like :)
Athena - poster shop
Pearl - quite like
Blossom - pet's name
Tabitha - ugly sound, cat's name
Skye - quite like
India - name of a country, not "original" these days
Savannah - again, name of a country, not "original" these days

Chester - dog's name
Balthazar - unusual but actually I like this! :)
Roman - not keen, Empire jokes etc.
Thaddeus - like :)
Seth - quite like :)
Saxon - surname or historical group of people
Jasper - OK

Clementine - much prefer Clemency
Octavia - ostrich, but nice
Ivy - want to like it, but don't
Athena - prefer Athene
Pearl - old lady at bingo
Blossom - her mate
Tabitha - nice, if a little feline
Skye - ok
India - nice
Savannah - like it

Chester - dog
Balthazar - heir who used to date Sienna
Roman - ok
Thaddeus - earnest RE teacher
Seth - lisps
Saxon - likes heavy metal, has tattoos
Jasper - cat, or small wet posh boy

Clementine & Roman are completely gorgeous.

I like Ivy, Tabitha and India.

Not keen on the boys names sorry.

For a change I'm going to give them scores out of ten.

Clementine 9.5
Octavia 9.0
Ivy 9.4
Athena 9.3
Pearl 8.5
Blossom 4.0
Tabitha 3.5
Skye 3.5
India 7.5
Savannah 3.5

Chester 1.5
Balthazar 0.0
Roman 4.0
Thaddeus 1.5
Seth 7.0
Saxon 4.0
Jasper 4.0

Clementine - pretentious
Octavia - posh
Ivy - old lady
Athena - don't like
Pearl - nice unless you are Scottish as it gets pronounced Peril
Blossom - the name for a pet
Tabitha - cat or witch
Skye - nice
India - nice but hippyish
Savannah - nice

Chester - not bad
Balthazar - god no!
Roman - nice
Thaddeus - god no!
Seth - 87 year old yorkshire man
Saxon - No!!!!
Jasper - ok but was my dog's name so would never give it to a child

Clementine - lovely
Octavia - not unless you are POSH
Ivy - dreadful even for a guineapig
Athena - no
Pearl - lowe - dreadful woman need i say more
Blossom - too girly
Tabitha - cats's name
Skye - hippy
India - isn't this a bit common now
Savannah - no no

Chester - cat's name
Balthazar - oh no not unless you can really pull this off
Roman - lovely name
Thaddeus - I do know a grown up with this name - he uses Joe
Seth - lovely
Saxon - bad hair metal band
Jasper - lovely

Savannah and Roman.

Clementine - lovely
Octavia - ok
Ivy - marvellous
Athena - nice
Pearl - YUK
Blossom - for a pony?
Tabitha - quite nice
Skye - no
India - no
Savannah - no

Chester - Could work
Balthazar - bit mean
Roman - Chav
Thaddeus - Posh
Seth - idiot
Saxon - NO
Jasper - Fab

If either of our DDs were DSs then DP wanted Thaddeus. Don't really like your girls' names though

I love Athena and Tabitha, also Octavia (but only if you have an "8" reason for using). Skye, India and Savannah are OK. I don't like Pearl or Blossom as they make me think of old lady's bath salts, nor Ivy which to me is dull.

I love Jasper, and like Roman if you're Slav or Thaddeus if you're erudite. Not so keen on Saxon or Balthazar, and don't like Seth.

I do like Seth a lot.

Not keen on the rest though sorry .

Clementine - nice but citrus
Octavia - ostrich from Pipkins
Ivy - old lady
Athena - poster shop
Pearl - 's a singer
Blossom - kids tv prog
Tabitha - our cat
Skye - ok
India - ok
Savannah - hmmm

Chester - drawers
Balthazar - biblical
Roman - ok but only if you've got a matching surname
Thaddeus - ?
Seth - makes me think of village idiot
Saxon - ?
Jasper - carrott

Clementine-like
Octavia-realy like
Ivy-boring
Athena-know a toddler one,quite nice with Phenie as nn
Pearl-quite like
Blossom-too my little pony
Tabitha-like
Skye-too common
India-name of an overpopulated country
Savannah-no

Chester-sounds like trouble
Balthazar-why would you do this to a child?
Roman-Polanski
Thaddeus-not sure,could grow on me
Seth-too Cold comfort farm
Saxon-know a young girl called this
Jasper-like but growing in popularity

Clementine - like
Octavia - old lady
Ivy -love this
Athena - not sure.
Pearl - love this. Wish I'd thought of it!

Blossom - no
Tabitha - cat's name
Skye - a little YKW (C word)
India - country in Asia
Savannah - No

Chester - No
Balthazar - No
Roman - This is a good one
Thaddeus - I love biblical names
Seth - ditto
Saxon - only heard of this as girl's name
Jasper - okay