Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP has invited his ex wife for Christmas dinner and says I’m being petty

414 replies

IcyPortal · Yesterday 19:29

Me and DP are having a bit of an argument about Christmas and I’m starting to wonder if I’m being unreasonable here.

We’ve been together 3 years and live together. I have a DS13 and DD8 from my previous relationship and he has two DDs, 15 and 10, from his marriage. His girls are with us alternate weekends and some of the school holidays. They are coming to us Christmas Eve and staying until Boxing Day this year.

We’d agreed we would have everyone here for Christmas dinner. His brother and my sister were invited as well, so its already going to be quite a full house. I don’t mind that, I like having people round for Christmas and the kids all get on well enough. I am the one who does most of the organising though, sorting food, presents, making sure everyone has got what they need etc. DP will help if I ask him but he isn’t the sort to think ahead about things.

Anyway a few days ago he mentioned that his ex wife would be coming for Christmas dinner as well. I actually thought he was joking at first and said what do you mean coming for dinner? Apparently he’d invited her because she would otherwise be on her own.

For context she has recently split up with her boyfriend and doesn’t have much family nearby. I do feel sorry for her in that respect and I’m not saying she should have to sit on her own all day if there is another option. But DP had already invited her before even mentioning it to me. I had no idea he was planning this and we hadn’t discussed it at all.

He said he thought it was the right thing to do and the girls would be happy having both their parents there. Which they are, his eldest especially was really pleased when she found out. I haven’t said anything to them about it and wouldn’t want to spoil their Christmas or make them feel like they have to choose between us.

But I don’t really understand why he couldn’t have asked me first? It’s my home as well and I’m going to be doing most of the work on the day. I finish work late on Christmas Eve so there is already going to be a lot to get sorted in a short space of time. I know having one extra person isn’t the end of the world but it isn’t really about the food or having enough chairs. I just feel like he’s made a decision that affects all of us and told me afterwards as though it’s already settled.

When I said I wasn’t comfortable with it he got quite annoyed and said I was being petty and making something nice into an issue. He said it was for the children. I said that I wasn’t stopping his girls seeing their mum. They could see her earlier in the day or he could take them to see her, or she could come over for a bit. I just hadn’t agreed to having her here for the whole dinner.

He then said it would be awkward if she only came for an hour and that the girls wanted her there. I do get that. They are old enough to understand their parents aren’t together but obviously it would be nice for them to have a Christmas where everyone can be in the same room and get along. I am not trying to make things difficult for them.

I don’t think she has done anything wrong either. We are civil when we see each other but we aren’t friends and we don’t socialise together. She’s never been rude to me and I have no reason to think anything is going on between them. They were married for a long time and have children together so obviously they will always have a connection. I’m not asking him to cut her out of their lives.

It is just that he does sometimes agree to things with her or the girls and then tell me afterwards. Usually it’s small things and I let it go, but this feels different because Christmas dinner is happening in our house and I’m the one who will be getting everything ready. I feel like if I had invited my ex to spend the day with us without discussing it with him, DP would have something to say about that.

My sister thinks he should have asked me first but says now that the girls are excited I should probably just let it happen. My friend says she wouldn’t have her partner’s ex wife sitting at her Christmas table at all, but I think that’s a bit harsh when she’s recently split up and would be alone otherwise.

I haven’t told DP she can’t come. I just said I wasn’t happy that he had invited her without even asking me, and now he’s acting like I’ve got a problem with his ex when that’s not what I said.

AIBU to think he should have spoken to me before inviting her, or am I making too much of it and should just get on with Christmas?

OP posts:
dragonflygold · Today 10:04

Soulhorse · Today 09:39

“It demonstrates something very powerful to all the children involved - that it's possible to be amicable & friendly after a significant relationship ends. I think that is a great life lesson for them.“

Also demonstrates that he’s the one with all the power in the relationship and OP has to suck it up. Misogyny at it’s best.

I then went on to say that he should have consulted the OP first, not made a decision on her behalf and earlier said that he should be pulling his weight and not leaving all the domestic work to her.

What I meant by saying about it being a lesson to the children involved is that the invitation is out there now & the kids have been told so the best course of action is to let it happen and model civilised, adult relationships.

BUT that doesn't mean the DP gets away with his behaviour around this and a frank discussion is very much needed. He should do better.

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · Today 10:03

Soulhorse · Today 09:55

How’s the workload split in your house OP?

I’d also like to know this.

3luckystars · Today 09:58

Greenmouldycheese · Today 09:54

I agree with him and think you are being nasty here.

😂

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · Today 09:57

Is he generally the type of person who, if he thinks the answer is going to be 'no' presents you with a fait accompli? Because I think this is more of a 'communication in the relationship' problem than an ex wife problem. And if you are doing all the work and he's just keeping his head down and you aren't saying anything about him picking up some of the slack - I really do think the pair of you need to work on talking more, even if it's awkward. Because I worry that you're both keeping quiet about things that need to be discussed, for fear of rocking the boat.

He's wrong not to have asked you about inviting his ex, obviously. But I think this goes deeper than that.

3luckystars · Today 09:57

So, when you go to him with an issue, it feels like you caused the issue by the way he reacts ?

This here is an alarm bell going off. He is an absolute bully and a stupid, thoughtless one too.

Soulhorse · Today 09:55

How’s the workload split in your house OP?

Greenmouldycheese · Today 09:54

I agree with him and think you are being nasty here.

IcyPortal · Today 09:51

No it wasnt an affair, he’d been split from his ex for quite a few years before me and him got together. There wasnt any overlap or anything like that and I dont have hard feelings towards her because of that, theres nothing to have hard feelings about.

I honestly dont think he’s still in love with her, they have kids together and have managed to stay on civil terms which I think is a good thing. I’m not saying what he’s done is fine, I’m annoyed that he didnt ask me and then called me petty when I said something. I dont see how that means I’ve left something out of the OP or that there must be some big secret reason behind it.

OP posts:
3luckystars · Today 09:51

Also demonstrates that the OP is a servant. She has to do what she is told.

Soulhorse · Today 09:39

“It demonstrates something very powerful to all the children involved - that it's possible to be amicable & friendly after a significant relationship ends. I think that is a great life lesson for them.“

Also demonstrates that he’s the one with all the power in the relationship and OP has to suck it up. Misogyny at it’s best.

Floatlikeafeather2 · Today 09:32

What has happened the other 2 years that you've been together? Why can't she cope with being on her own this year when surely the situation must have arisen at least once before?
Most divorced people I know scrap their usual arrangements at Christmas and each have some time with the kids over the period and those that live close enough to each other, split Christmas Day itself.
Having said that, he sounds thoughtless and lazy (all year round?) and that's the bit you need to be concentrating on. Tbh, if he's pushing back at you, instead of at least saying "I'm sorry. I just didn't think. What can I do to help?", it doesn't sound like he's likely to change at all.

Wonderwall23 · Today 09:20

I agree with your sister but IMO he is blatantly unreasonable to ask anyone to Christmas Dinner, regardless of who it is, without asking you first.

I would absolutely push back on the petty label (it's not petty to expect basic manners), and if he wants to know what petty is it's that you've now asked your ex for Christmas dinner as well and he's coming. (Without actually doing that, obviously!)

Whettlettuce · Today 09:19

THisbackwithavengeance · Today 07:16

FFS. You could follow the advice on this thread, kick off, divorce, leave the house and take your DCs with you. LTB, etc etc even though most posters advocating it wouldn’t do that themselves and if they would, that’s why they’re divorced, single and bitter. Yeah, ruin your kids Christmas, get divorced, over a small issue. Such shit advice.

However back in the real world, life is often recognising that compromises have to be made and it’s not just about you.
I would see this as a good thing to do for someone who would otherwise be sat alone on Xmas day meaning that your SDCs wouldn’t be worrying about their mum. You’ve already got a full house, so really one more won’t matter? I personally wouldn’t have a problem with it.

Who would be ok with hosting their partners ex for Christmas? . I certainly wouldn't

Whettlettuce · Today 09:17

Sorry, but this is bayshit. No way would i be tolerating this and I would end things immediately

IdentifyingAsAWoollyMammoth · Today 09:14

My partner doesn't make decisions concerning us or what happens in our house without discussing it with me and vice versa. It's just basic respect and courtesy.

And if you don't have that, I'm not sure that's a healthy relationship.

Aluna · Today 09:09

The whole thing is batshit. You don’t invite your ex partner to something your current partner is hosting without asking unless you don’t give a shit about them.

Notmycircusnotmyotter · Today 08:59

He should've spoken to you but I always have my kids' dad from Christmas Eve until Boxing Day, along with my dad and a few friends. Kids love it and everyone gets along now.

MeridianB · Today 08:45

Also, no relationship is perfect, but in a world where you and your DP are role modelling a relationship to four children, is there behaviour that you wouldn’t want them to accept in their own future relationships?

dragonflygold · Today 08:45

TotaleclipseinFrance · Today 08:34

Strongly disagree.

Though it is possible to be amicable and attend events where your ex is going to be, it's one step too far to expect your new dp to host them.

What is the thing about being the host?

Personally I would prefer to be the host in this situation than the person attending.

MeridianB · Today 08:40

”I wouldnt say we have massive rows all the time but he can be quite dismissive when I disagree with something he’s already decided.”

With this and you doing everything to host at Christmas despite working, his behaviour is giving Handmaid’s Tale vibes. And it sounds more than dismissive- Darvo and name-calling.

What do you children really think of him? Is he consistently kind and fair to them?

Nopersbro · Today 08:39

He should have checked with you before inviting her; I'm sure she assumed he did. Disinviting her would be a problem since the girls are excited about her being there, but the tricky part is that if you don't, you need another way to impress upon your husband that what he has done is not OK, and get him to commit to checking with you in future and actually consistently doing so. it's made much harder when sneaking has resulted in his getting his way, but if he's a decent guy you can still make the point and treat this as an exception. What worries me is that now that you've told him it's unacceptable he isn't apologising and reassuring you he'll treat you as a partner and equal in the future, he's trying to blame you rather than to see your point of view and compromise.

If you can manage having her this once, then I'd try again to speak with him when you both have time and privacy and explain what the issue is and that she comes on condition that he agrees that his unilaterally making decisions like this stops now. If he's still an arse during that discussion, then you have a much bigger issue. (Oh, and given that you have to work and he's invited an extra person, perhaps he takes on a little more than his half of the prep work and holiday celebration grunt work this year!)

TotaleclipseinFrance · Today 08:34

dragonflygold · Today 08:24

I don't think she's being made a fool of at all.
She says she gets on with the ex wife and it doesn't seem to be her presence that is the problem here, more the DP not asking her opinion on it first.

It demonstrates something very powerful to all the children involved - that it's possible to be amicable & friendly after a significant relationship ends. I think that is a great life lesson for them.

But the OP needs to have a frank discussion with her DP about his lack of consideration and communication. That's the issue here, not whether the ex wife comes to Xmas dinner or not.

Strongly disagree.

Though it is possible to be amicable and attend events where your ex is going to be, it's one step too far to expect your new dp to host them.

SwirlingAroundSleep · Today 08:25

If my DP did this he would swiftly find he was no longer my DP and organising Christmas himself. Maybe that’s coloured by the fact that his ex has literally been harassing me to the point she’s been banned from my workplace, but it’s also because Christmas and my home are my places to relax and nobody wants to host an ex-wife unless they’re actually friends with them.

honestly I’d book a getaway (or a meal out) and take your daughters OR tell him to do the same with his ex-wife and daughters.

he certainly wouldn’t continue to be my partner after making it clear his first priority is his newly single ex.

dragonflygold · Today 08:24

TotaleclipseinFrance · Today 08:15

She's agreed to it when it would be very easy to get out of it. Very easy.

The OP is being made an absolute fool out of here. It's obvious.

I'd say the same if all genders were reversed.

I don't think she's being made a fool of at all.
She says she gets on with the ex wife and it doesn't seem to be her presence that is the problem here, more the DP not asking her opinion on it first.

It demonstrates something very powerful to all the children involved - that it's possible to be amicable & friendly after a significant relationship ends. I think that is a great life lesson for them.

But the OP needs to have a frank discussion with her DP about his lack of consideration and communication. That's the issue here, not whether the ex wife comes to Xmas dinner or not.

Firefly100 · Today 08:23

Personally I wouldn’t accept it. It has been done in such a way you have no say as you would be disappointing his kids and ruining Xmas. I would not try to recind the invitation for this reason. I would ask my sister if there were any way I and my kids could come to her house instead and beg her help. If not, I’d even go as far as offering to pay for all of us (my and sister family) to have Xmas lunch in a restaurant instead (I appreciate not everyone could afford this option). He can cook for his family and guests. He has presented a nice fait accomplis where the workload and sacrifice all falls on you. No. On principle. Next time he’ll ask! I suspect though, faced with this, he will likely recind the invitation himself.