Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surprise 3rd baby but only 2 bed house

127 replies

Violetroses564 · Yesterday 18:49

We live in a 2 bed shared ownership house in the south east so quite expensive area. Husband has a niche job he loves but cant rise much in pay. I work part-time but I'm also a full time carer to my parents. Both have long term conditions so unfortunately we don't have the possibility of moving any time soon or at all. We currently have a big main room that our 2 boys (15 and 8 years) used to share but we put a stud wall in to give both their own space. My husband and I are in a very small double room. There is no extra dining room, just lounge and kitchen. Being in a shared ownership makes any major extensions or loft conversions nearly impossible to get consent from the HA.
We love our house and location is spot on with schools, friends, clubs, work and parents living close. I have just found out that I'm pregnant (I'm 35). I was on the pill and I took it religiously so I really don't know what happened. But it has and we are getting our head around it. I'm very much pro-choice but I couldn't go through with an abortion.

The problem is now making use of our space. How do we make this work? The only thing I can think of is us moving downstairs on a decent sofa bed. I know baby needs to be with parents originally so I was thinking of a single bed and baby in the small double at first. We definitely can't fit baby in with us as we are. When I say small double, it's very small. The boys current rooms are just enough space for them and I would rather not interfere with their spaces.

It's such a sucky situation and not planned but I'm trying to make the most of what we have without crying all the time. I wouldn't feel so bad if I thought all of this was only for a few years but my care duties to my parents could easily be 20+ years. I feel like the biggest failure of a mum.

Has anyone been in a similar situation?

OP posts:
rottenromans · Today 13:51

YankSplaining · Today 13:18

Here we go again – another Mumsnet thread in which an emotionally vulnerable, pregnant OP asks a question that is not, “Should I have an abortion?” and people start telling her she should have an abortion. This OP’s even specifically said, “I couldn't go through with an abortion.” I’ve seen Mumsnet delete comments telling an OP who wants an abortion that she shouldn’t have one, so why does this site leave up comments telling OPs who don’t want abortions that they should have them?

OP, I think someone is going to have to move, whether it’s your parents going to different caregivers or the whole family moving into a different house. Is your husband open to the possibility of finding a different job?

Because in this situation it is the best thing for everyone involved

Babyboomtastic · Today 13:51

Check the deeds first, but could you eldest live in a caravan in your garden/driveway (if you have one). Providing he's still part of the household, it's often allowed. But sometimes the deeds or local authority rules outlaw it.

Get a cheap caravan and do it up inside. It also gives him slightly more independence as he gets older. Younger child can share with baby once he is she goes into their own room.

Ansjovis · Today 13:53

YankSplaining · Today 13:18

Here we go again – another Mumsnet thread in which an emotionally vulnerable, pregnant OP asks a question that is not, “Should I have an abortion?” and people start telling her she should have an abortion. This OP’s even specifically said, “I couldn't go through with an abortion.” I’ve seen Mumsnet delete comments telling an OP who wants an abortion that she shouldn’t have one, so why does this site leave up comments telling OPs who don’t want abortions that they should have them?

OP, I think someone is going to have to move, whether it’s your parents going to different caregivers or the whole family moving into a different house. Is your husband open to the possibility of finding a different job?

Because the OP is in an impossible situation and I think it's natural that people are reacting to that. The best possible outcome here if the pregnancy continues seems to be that OP and her husband move into the living room, meaning that the only communal space in the house would become the kitchen AND the adults would have no private space (assuming that the house layout does not allow for the living room door to be locked) and the OP has to care for a newborn and two ageing parents. Given that OP has already said she expects her eldest to remain at home for at least 10 more years, that's a long time to be living in such cramped conditions.

If moving to a bigger house is not an option within the next few years then I think it's terribly sad to say but many women do have abortions that they don't want for the benefit of their existing families.

lifeonourplanet · Today 13:53

Realistically you can't make it work unless you move. You need to work full time, your dh needs to look for a better paid job and your parents need to pay for carers.

KilkennyCats · Today 13:53

Babyboomtastic · Today 13:51

Check the deeds first, but could you eldest live in a caravan in your garden/driveway (if you have one). Providing he's still part of the household, it's often allowed. But sometimes the deeds or local authority rules outlaw it.

Get a cheap caravan and do it up inside. It also gives him slightly more independence as he gets older. Younger child can share with baby once he is she goes into their own room.

Shoving one child into a caravan to make space for another one is truly appalling.

Babyboomtastic · Today 14:00

KilkennyCats · Today 13:53

Shoving one child into a caravan to make space for another one is truly appalling.

Come on, most teenagers would love it. More space (certainly than sharing with an 8yo), and can come home late without waking the household, of and easier to sneak a girlfriend home. If it's sufficiently warm and cozy it's surely every teenagers dream.

flumpkeu · Today 14:02

Babyboomtastic · Today 14:00

Come on, most teenagers would love it. More space (certainly than sharing with an 8yo), and can come home late without waking the household, of and easier to sneak a girlfriend home. If it's sufficiently warm and cozy it's surely every teenagers dream.

Edited

I can honestly say no teenager I know would love this. For goodness sake abortions are here for a reason, it’s cells, the pre existing children are people in the here and now that need and deserve to be prioritised. My mind boggles are how people covet unconscious cells over actual people. The mental gymnastics people are doing to try and justify this situation.

ratatouillemousesqueak · Today 14:10

I think others have suggested some good ideas for how but long term I don’t think you can have three kids and be FT carer. You can ask social services for support for parents? Then after mat leave you can work more. Can partner take on any extra work. Long term you need to move.

is there any outdoor space?

Babyboomtastic · Today 14:10

flumpkeu · Today 14:02

I can honestly say no teenager I know would love this. For goodness sake abortions are here for a reason, it’s cells, the pre existing children are people in the here and now that need and deserve to be prioritised. My mind boggles are how people covet unconscious cells over actual people. The mental gymnastics people are doing to try and justify this situation.

We are all cells.

You are cells just as much as a fetus is. There are many valid prob life arguments, but being made of cells isn't one of them 😂.

If there caravan idea isn't popular, then there will be other ideas. Terminating the life of a wanted baby isn't over of them. For a start, the OP has said she doesn't want that, and therefore we should respect her choice surely.

ratatouillemousesqueak · Today 14:11

OP sorry I do want to ask as well. Is this baby worth the risk to your own mental health and your boys? You already do a lot.

Babyboomtastic · Today 14:14

Other options:

  • multi purpose lounge
  • get a double high sleeper in your room which will give you room for a bit/toddler bed underneath.
  • garden room to be used as bedroom.
  • move house

It doesn't have to be a solution that works for the next 10 years, just look from birth to say 2 and re-evaluate then.

ratatouillemousesqueak · Today 14:15

YankSplaining · Today 13:18

Here we go again – another Mumsnet thread in which an emotionally vulnerable, pregnant OP asks a question that is not, “Should I have an abortion?” and people start telling her she should have an abortion. This OP’s even specifically said, “I couldn't go through with an abortion.” I’ve seen Mumsnet delete comments telling an OP who wants an abortion that she shouldn’t have one, so why does this site leave up comments telling OPs who don’t want abortions that they should have them?

OP, I think someone is going to have to move, whether it’s your parents going to different caregivers or the whole family moving into a different house. Is your husband open to the possibility of finding a different job?

Because it’s not just the baby but the impact on her own quality and life and mental health. She’s doing a lot and doesn’t sound like she’ll give up the care of her parents. With little money and another child to look after and feed, any extra income will be quickly spent.

I agree that nobody should be encouraged to have an abortion if that’s what they are choosing. But this is a discussion forum and there are wider things to consider.

Wopple · Today 14:20

Babyboomtastic · Today 14:00

Come on, most teenagers would love it. More space (certainly than sharing with an 8yo), and can come home late without waking the household, of and easier to sneak a girlfriend home. If it's sufficiently warm and cozy it's surely every teenagers dream.

Edited

For me at 15 i would have been terrified sleeping outside the main house all night. I was scared being in the house by myself even past 18 in case someone broke in or something. (Being honest I still don’t like it at 45!!) I also wouldn’t have felt part of the family anymore. It may work for a 20+ year old who really wants to move out but can’t, but I do feel a 15 year old may feel more pushed out and isolated.

flumpkeu · Today 14:20

Babyboomtastic · Today 14:10

We are all cells.

You are cells just as much as a fetus is. There are many valid prob life arguments, but being made of cells isn't one of them 😂.

If there caravan idea isn't popular, then there will be other ideas. Terminating the life of a wanted baby isn't over of them. For a start, the OP has said she doesn't want that, and therefore we should respect her choice surely.

How much is that thinking from societal pressure as opposed to a genuine emotional inability to go through a minimally invasive procedure for the benefit of her children, how often do we see “oh I just couldn’t go through with it” on here, I think women are just trained to feel this way, women are pressured into viewing pregnancy romantically. But I think it’s actually really bloody harmful, to them and to their families. Why on earth are people so pious about this? I bet no one here is even religious, it’s simply a hang over from that.

So I jsut don’t buy the pleading vulnerability argumemt, it’s not just her that’s vulnerable here, it’s her children, who have no say in any of this and are probably mostly impacted. Take the emotion out of it.

flumpkeu · Today 14:22

Just to add I’m not saying she should have an abortion, just that I think it should be seriously considered pragmatically, not emotionally ruled out immediately because that could be misplaced misogyny and societal pressure as opposed to genuine emotional vulnerability.

MrsBananaman · Today 14:24

Violetroses564 · Yesterday 18:59

No we literally have a bed and our wardrobes. It's very small. One or both of us would have to go downstairs at some point. Oldest isn't going to uni either. He is looking at an apprenticeship post college but I can't imagine him being able to move out before 25

Can you move the wardrobes into another room?

CherryKerry · Today 14:24

Bunk beds for the 2 younger ones once baby is in a 'big bed', until then keep the cot in your room. Then wait until older one moves out.

Plenty kids have to share and it won't be forever as oldest will probably want their own place in 5 years.

Summer26woohoo · Today 14:43

Agree with a pp...you're talking about a lot of fixed things that 'can't' change but you need to be realistic. You have to make changes.

  • Stop caring for your parents. No one has 'caring duties' for parents, they make choices to. You can no longer afford, in time or money, to do that and looking after your kids properly is more important. Speak to them, speak to social services or whoever deals with such things and step back.
  • Fit the baby in with you for the first few years. Yes, you CAN fit them in you room. Get a smaller bed for you two (small double or double depending on what you have now). Push it up against a wall. Get rid of your wardrobes, replace with a cot/toddler bed. Find somewhere else to store clothes - convert an airing cupboard, put a wardrobe on the landing, use under the stairs as a walk in, buy an ottoman bed. There will be something.
  • Time to level up financially. You need to get a full time job. Your dh needs to try and get a part time job, promotion, side hustle, whatever. If there's a better paying job not so niche or enjoyable, tough tits. He just helped create another human you can't afford to properly house yet so he needs to suck it up.
  • Save every single penny to move. Make that your only aim, you have several years before the bedroom situation becomes actually impossible.
villadicance · Today 14:50

I think the biggest issue isn't the house but your mental health

Two children, plus a baby, plus a job, plus two elderly parents, it is just too much and you will burn out.

You are not the only option to care for your parents even if they have made you feel that way. But if you want to continue caring for them, don't have the baby

PinkViola · Today 14:50

Tryingtothinkofausername · Yesterday 21:45

The loft bed to replace the double bed seems to be the best solution for at least the next three years, possibly a little longer. The baby's cot/toddler bed will fit underneath with some small storage space.

I agree. If you can't spread outwards you have to spread upwards.

Stressedandgrey · Today 15:59

Snoken · Today 09:44

Whereas that's true, OP does have two existing children who are considerably older than a baby. Would it be fair to expect them to live as if it's 1932 in an overcrowded house just so that OP and her husband can have another baby that neither of them actively tried to create and they can't afford?

I don't think two kids in bunks in one room, And the other on their own in a second is exactly going back to slum housing standards 🙄

KilkennyCats · Today 16:04

Stressedandgrey · Today 15:59

I don't think two kids in bunks in one room, And the other on their own in a second is exactly going back to slum housing standards 🙄

It’s not two rooms, though? The existing kids share one room which was divided in two, so I imagine the individual spaces are not overly large.
Stuffing two kids into half a room is pushing it.

Gengha · Today 16:08

flumpkeu · Today 14:20

How much is that thinking from societal pressure as opposed to a genuine emotional inability to go through a minimally invasive procedure for the benefit of her children, how often do we see “oh I just couldn’t go through with it” on here, I think women are just trained to feel this way, women are pressured into viewing pregnancy romantically. But I think it’s actually really bloody harmful, to them and to their families. Why on earth are people so pious about this? I bet no one here is even religious, it’s simply a hang over from that.

So I jsut don’t buy the pleading vulnerability argumemt, it’s not just her that’s vulnerable here, it’s her children, who have no say in any of this and are probably mostly impacted. Take the emotion out of it.

I agree with you. She didn’t want the baby in the first place and now she’s going to upend the lives of her kids and parents to accommodate it? Madness.

Snoken · Today 16:21

Stressedandgrey · Today 15:59

I don't think two kids in bunks in one room, And the other on their own in a second is exactly going back to slum housing standards 🙄

But they are at very different stages too. It could have worked if they were 1, 4 and 6 for example, but cramming 3 kids that are 1, 9 and 16 into what is effectively one room would not be enjoyable for anyone. They will have completely different sleep patterns, needs for quiet time, needs for play time etc. This would also be for upwards of 10 years, at that point there will be 4 adults and one 10 year old sharing 2 bedrooms. I just cannot see what is in it for the older two.

ChildrenOfTheQuorn · Today 17:36

YankSplaining · Today 13:26

So is two children – is that a “large family” too?

No, because whereas 1.4 might be the mean average, pretty sure 2 would be the median average.

ETA: I knew I'd get some wannabe "gotcha" post in response.

Swipe left for the next trending thread