Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

FOUR out of FIVE new jobs went to foreigners in the past decade, new report reveals

415 replies

OpenScroller · 14/10/2026 16:48

Four in five jobs created over the past decade have been taken by migrants.

Of the 3.7million new roles recorded under the PAYE system since 2014, just 734,000 were taken by UK nationals, a think-tank has found.

EU citizens accounted for 408,000 jobs, while the vast majority – 2.5million – went to migrants from the rest of the world, the Centre for Social Justice (CSJ) said, with most of the surge coming since the pandemic.

The think-tank warned that while employers gained 'unprecedented access to overseas labour', taxpayers have been forced to absorb the cost of millions of Britons being 'written off' and left on benefits.

As the number of migrant workers soared by 2.1million from 2020, the number of people receiving out-of-work benefits across the UK rose by 2.3million.

More than one in four (29 per cent) of the jobs that went to migrant workers from outside Europe were in health and social work.

So much for British jobs for British people!

Do we think this is due to Brits being 'too lazy to work' or because of a combination of employers wanting to pay lower wages and offer worse working conditions to migrants/preferring to employ migrants/not wanting to invest in training Brits/diversity hire tick boxes etc.

https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/CSJ-State_of_Dependency.pdf

https://www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/CSJ-State_of_Dependency.pdf

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
echt · 14/10/2026 21:39

OpenScroller · 14/10/2026 17:02

I should imagine a vast majority of those with families will be claiming top up benefits like housing benefit, universal credit, child benefit and also using services like the NHS, schools, etc while paying very little in.

We are also paying the same benefits to Brits who can't find a job.

You do the Math.

The key word here is "imagine".
Some evidence wouldn't go amiss.

Ironfloor269 · 14/10/2026 21:38

MellonFellon · 14/10/2026 17:09

Schrödinger's immigrant....

Love this. 😆

Ilovemycatalot · 14/10/2026 21:36

It’s horrible to see our young people left on benefits because they cannot find work.
My dd who finished her A level with great grades is struggling to find anything and has gone for hundreds of jobs.
She is polite, hardworking and drives yet has been rejected from retail, catering and various other roles despite being flexible and open minded about what she does.
its soul destroying and leaves the question what are employers looking for?
Unfortunately I do believe the employment market is being taken over by foreign nationals who tend to like to employ their own.
Our young people have no opportunities in their own country it’s depressing.

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 14/10/2026 21:22

OrangeSlices998 · 14/10/2026 19:18

I mean some people are universally dickheads. The point I was making was the headline is designed to dog whistle about brown immigrants when non EU can mean may other nations

Oh for sure. I’ve encountered it often enough myself - people complaining about immigrants and then, seeing my raised eyebrows, saying, “I didn’t mean you!”

And the sad thing is, they really didn’t mean me - they meant brown Muslims and expected me to agree.

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 14/10/2026 21:18

titchy · 14/10/2026 19:17

You do know people with UK citizenship can have forrin accents yes?

I did indeed! But your accent generally shows where you grew up. Mine (also) doesn’t match my nationality. I mentioned it in the context of people coming to the UK to work in relatively unskilled jobs.

I don’t think that all the people I encountered in souvenir shops were born Brits who grew up elsewhere.

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 14/10/2026 21:14

Persephonia1966 · 14/10/2026 20:10

Speaking for myself only I wouldn't look down on a South African/Australian. But I have experienced a South African in the UK sort of thinking they were better than my (English as it happened) colleague who they assumed was an immigrant. It was a bit of a "hang on a minute situation". Not that there is anything wrong with being an immigrant from South Africa or anywhere but I don't think they had more right to be in the country than someone born there just because if skin colour. I do think that person felt looked down on for being grouped in the immigrant category with brown immigrants. BUT they were an exception not the rule.

And of course I didn’t mean that all English people (or even the majority!) think they are superior - just that I’ve encountered it a number of times. I’ve not met every English person anyway 😉

Happyjoe · 14/10/2026 20:53

Wadsworthy · 14/10/2026 19:06

But a lot of UK nationals don't want to work in social care.

And we have 1 million young people who are NEETS and mostly on benefits. Apparently many of them are too "anxious" to work.

We have too many people in the UK who don't want to work full stop! My next door neighbour, 4 year old daughter (now goes to school), she and her new fella don't work, father of the child doesn't work. Live in a council supplied home, doing nothing other than taxi's to the shops, uber eat deliveries and going on the tiles every weekend.
Apart from the amount of money they're costing taxpayers, I find it utterly depressing that this is all their life is at aged about 25ish. Why does nobody want to live a bit anymore?

ClaudettedeBeauvoir · 14/10/2026 20:48

Birdcatdog · 14/10/2026 18:09

I was just about to type this, they are right wing and will present data to support the right wing agenda

Exactly. And when you check their sources they are quoting their own "math". Interesting.

Happyjoe · 14/10/2026 20:45

Monty36 · 14/10/2026 18:01

Two years if you are here under a marriage visa.

Is that true? I thought that was 5 years, after allowed to apply to remain? Plus spousal visa means that the spouse must earn a set amount of money to pay for their spouse. That's what happened with someone I knew who is English but brought her partner from overseas.

FlyingCatGirl · 14/10/2026 20:31

The reality is that we have an absolutely screwed jobs market in this country! We have low or unskilled vacancy gaps that have no career potential so they don't get filled. We have a ton of jobs that expect a ridiculous assortment of experience of skills,qualifications and experience that few people can live up to and for not that much more money than minimum wage.

People can't afford to retire until the state pension kicks in at 67, nobody wants to train or develop anybody and it leaves so many people in limbo! And if or when you do get that job you live, you get made redundant as businesses are closing hand over fist in this country!

And for anybody that's disabled or develops a chronic condition, it's frequently hell to get an employer to agree to even minor adjustments to a role.

I'm H&S by trade, I saw a Junior HSE position being advertised recently, working pattern is ten days on and 4 off and working hours 12 noon to 10pm! Who wants to live that life? And the amount of experience you were required to have that role did not match up with it being junior! And forget seeing anyone you live with or having a social life! This is what people are up against plus the fact that many jobs are 6 & 12 month temp contracts now!

workinghardhardlyworking · 14/10/2026 20:11

I thought quite a few EU migrants had left the UK since Brexit. Those figures would include people like me, who haven't lived in the UK for the better part of a decade.

Persephonia1966 · 14/10/2026 20:10

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 14/10/2026 19:05

I don’t know about Americans but I’ve experienced for myself how some/many English people in particular look down on Australians and South Africans.

Speaking for myself only I wouldn't look down on a South African/Australian. But I have experienced a South African in the UK sort of thinking they were better than my (English as it happened) colleague who they assumed was an immigrant. It was a bit of a "hang on a minute situation". Not that there is anything wrong with being an immigrant from South Africa or anywhere but I don't think they had more right to be in the country than someone born there just because if skin colour. I do think that person felt looked down on for being grouped in the immigrant category with brown immigrants. BUT they were an exception not the rule.

OrangeSlices998 · 14/10/2026 19:18

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 14/10/2026 19:05

I don’t know about Americans but I’ve experienced for myself how some/many English people in particular look down on Australians and South Africans.

I mean some people are universally dickheads. The point I was making was the headline is designed to dog whistle about brown immigrants when non EU can mean may other nations

titchy · 14/10/2026 19:17

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 14/10/2026 18:56

I was surprised when in the UK recently that there were quite a few people who were clearly from India/Pakistan (I mean based on their accents, not just assuming based on appearance) working in souvenir shops. No judgement either way, but it did make me wonder!

You do know people with UK citizenship can have forrin accents yes?

Wadsworthy · 14/10/2026 19:06

But a lot of UK nationals don't want to work in social care.

And we have 1 million young people who are NEETS and mostly on benefits. Apparently many of them are too "anxious" to work.

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 14/10/2026 19:05

OrangeSlices998 · 14/10/2026 18:59

So hang on immigrants are a scourge in society draining our benefits and they’re also stealing all our jobs? Which is it?

Most people on UC are in work, whether white or brown, we should look at why working full time at Sainsbury’s or Starbucks or as a care worker or a cleaner is not paid well enough that a top up is needed.

I don’t know why this pisses people off, we need doctors, bus drivers, shop assistants, care workers, baristas, waitresses - it’s surely good people are working regardless of skin colour or ethnicity. People are just annoyed because they don’t want to believe a foreigner could do their job or compete with them. FYI non EU also included Australians, Americans, South Africans - or is it okay if they’re white?

I don’t know about Americans but I’ve experienced for myself how some/many English people in particular look down on Australians and South Africans.

EmBear91 · 14/10/2026 19:04

OpenScroller · 14/10/2026 17:05

Well a lot of low paid social and health care employees will be claiming top up benefits, ditto those in other low paid roles if they bring families with them.

Cost of living in the UK is hardly cheap is it now.

You do realise that immigrants aren’t entitled to benefits right? My wife is an immigrant & was on a work visa with her school (she’s a teacher) for 10 years before she could apply for leave to remain. She was not entitled to any benefits then & she still isn’t now! You’re not entitled to any public funds until you become an actual British citizen, which is expensive & takes years to achieve.

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 14/10/2026 19:04

Nottodaybob · 14/10/2026 19:00

When I went to New York last, the vast majority of souvenir shops were being run by south Asian people (with accents).

I was more wondering from the UK visa point of view IYSWIM 😊

Nottodaybob · 14/10/2026 19:00

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 14/10/2026 18:56

I was surprised when in the UK recently that there were quite a few people who were clearly from India/Pakistan (I mean based on their accents, not just assuming based on appearance) working in souvenir shops. No judgement either way, but it did make me wonder!

When I went to New York last, the vast majority of souvenir shops were being run by south Asian people (with accents).

Minasama · 14/10/2026 18:59

Monty36 · 14/10/2026 17:23

No. The employer ‘sponsors’ them to come here.
The employer does not have to prove that they could not find someone to do the job already resident in the UK before doing so.

My experience when hiring for a couple of large companies was that no one wanted the faff of hiring someone without the right to work. This may of course be different in technical/specialist roles.

OrangeSlices998 · 14/10/2026 18:59

So hang on immigrants are a scourge in society draining our benefits and they’re also stealing all our jobs? Which is it?

Most people on UC are in work, whether white or brown, we should look at why working full time at Sainsbury’s or Starbucks or as a care worker or a cleaner is not paid well enough that a top up is needed.

I don’t know why this pisses people off, we need doctors, bus drivers, shop assistants, care workers, baristas, waitresses - it’s surely good people are working regardless of skin colour or ethnicity. People are just annoyed because they don’t want to believe a foreigner could do their job or compete with them. FYI non EU also included Australians, Americans, South Africans - or is it okay if they’re white?

Nottodaybob · 14/10/2026 18:58

Anyahyacinth · 14/10/2026 18:56

So these are skilled jobs ..so why can’t UK nationals train for them?

Because entry level jobs in those sectors which provide such training are like hens teeth. It's easier to get a job when you already have experience.

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 14/10/2026 18:56

Campanulaceae · 14/10/2026 18:51

There have recently been £5000 incentives for businesses to hire someone from India, which costs businesses less overall because they can pay them less. From a purely business decision, it makes sense. It's not right, but it makes sense.

And don't get me started on employees on "skilled worker" visas working at kebab shops.

I was surprised when in the UK recently that there were quite a few people who were clearly from India/Pakistan (I mean based on their accents, not just assuming based on appearance) working in souvenir shops. No judgement either way, but it did make me wonder!

Anyahyacinth · 14/10/2026 18:56

Douglasmummy · 14/10/2026 17:57

Because they are already trained so employers don't have to bother spending time training up 18 year olds, because someone else in another country has done that. And all the reasons the person I quoted stated. That if your visa is dependent on your job employers can get you to do what they like. There are also places who basically applied to be sponsors as part of visa scams. We have a hugely inefficient system for work ( and student) visas where people know full well they can just do what they like and the chances of them being caught are minimal.

So these are skilled jobs ..so why can’t UK nationals train for them?

JenniferBooth · 14/10/2026 18:51

willingtolearn · 14/10/2026 17:15

I'm fed up of the 'Brits don't want these roles' - they do.

They just don't get a look in or aren't prepared to live in an HMO, working double shifts to eke out a basic existence.

Why don't we want more than this for our children?

people who have a social housing place are also expected to actually live there.