Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel stuck managing conflict between my two daughters with one really pushing buttons

170 replies

Krispycrem · 25/09/2026 08:20

To really be stuck as to what to do with my two DDs

I have 2 DDs , one neurodivergent 18, one not,16.

DD18 was a dream up to puberty but we’ve had a hard 5 years. We’ve got her assessments, help, moved schools etc

Since aged 11, she’s basically ignored DD2 and they don’t have a relationship. DD2 has long given up trying and as DD1 is highly argumentative , she’s not too keen on doing things with her. Sharing a room on holidays is fraught. DD1 is prone to meltdowns and twice DD2 has borne the brunt of her sister saying she wants to die etc and she is just wary of her now.

DD1 can be quite vicious to me, particularly around any perceived slight and I mostly try and ignore but sometimes I have to draw the line.

What’s become clear is that she has developed this narrative in her mind that DD2 is the golden child and we all judge DD1 etc etc

Thats not the case, DD2 is easier going so there are less arguments but DD1 gets days out, trips away, time etc all with both myself and DH. She just argues non stop and DD2 doesn’t. We ignore as much of the arguments as we can but it’s just been non stop difficult for many years with glimmers of the child she used to be. I think she is improving but it’s a slow process

Im not sure I can do much to address this , I’ve tried reasoning, examples etc but nothing works.

For example- Last night there was a total screaming meltdown because she had lost about 6 sets of airpods (all somewhere in the house , just not bothered to actually match them) and when I pointed out she might try and actually find them and still gave her a pair of my wired ones, she then continued to tell me how awful I was etc, even after I went and found her a pair.

I took the wired ones off her and said fine if you can’t be civil you can’t have them but I was called abusive because I took her earphones she needs to wind down ( they are mine)

She then came into my bedroom, stood there shouting, woke the house up and called her sister names (in DD1s defence her sister did say she didn’t want her at something earlier in the day so she was hurt)

DD1s behaviour is bad, DD2 just doesn’t want anything to do with her sister and I am worn out and sad that it’s come to this. I worry that I am playing a part in this chasm between them but I can see why DD2 is now wary. DD1 can turn, ignore etc at any time

What can I do ?

OP posts:
HunterBidensTanktop · 25/09/2026 12:14

Krispycrem · 25/09/2026 12:10

Sorry I don’t understand what this means ?

TLDR = Too Long Didn't Read.

pinkyredrose · 25/09/2026 12:12

Nd or not DD1 is behaving like a spoilt brat. What consequences does she face for her appalling behaviour?

Also why does she even have 6 sets of airpods to lose?Confused

Krispycrem · 25/09/2026 12:10

HectorPlasm · 25/09/2026 12:05

TLDR

Sorry I don’t understand what this means ?

OP posts:
Krispycrem · 25/09/2026 12:09

Amorica · 25/09/2026 11:35

Is ADHD her only ND issue? I have recently gone through this with a 17 year old with ADHD. Over the years we have struggled to implement the advice of (private, since CAMHS found her needs too insignificant after years of waiting) child therapists while watching things get worse and worse and wondering how the advice was supposed to produce a child who would thrive in society. I finally connected with a psychiatrist who was a bit horrified ( hough she was very professional and did not phrase it that way!) at the things we'd been doing at the behest of therapists.

She had us simply be much firmer on the bad behaviour. Not insisting on her being nice to anyone or becoming friends with her sister, but absolutely not accepting incivil behaviour to others in the family. We changed out approach, laid down strict requirements to be civil (and ignored accusations of favourtism other than to say - these are basic rules and apply to everyone equally). We stopped the over compensating, we told her if she couldn't be civil she needed to go to her room when she was rude to us or her sister. If she refused we left the room and then enforced consequences later when she wasn't so dysregulated (e.g. allowance cut in half, or no ride to friends house, etc.).

Making her deal with her emotions and regulate them in order to get what she wanted was absolutely the best training for college we could have given her. In hindsight, I am so fucking thankful we found that psychiatrist after years of handmaiden therapists and other ADHD experts. I can't tell you how pissed off I am about the fortune we spent on them and their complete lack of expertise in how to help her become a functioning adult. I think advice might be changing now, so hopefully others won't eb so poorly supported, But if you've been doing any placating (and the more time with her sounds like you have), my advice is to stop. Draw a line in the sand. Tell her she's and adult and needs to start adapting to her environment rather than expect it to adapt to her.

But it's not all about the boundaries. Don't keep giving her more the DD2, but keep up 1:1 time. Thank her when she does something she well (but avoid patronizing her!), find ways to encourage her to get out and about doing stuff as a) gives you respite; b) exploring the countryside and having friends is excellent for her and encourages dopamine hits.

This is the eternal struggle with our daughter. She has ADHD and dyspraxia, but I strongly suspect that she has autism as well. She also suspects this, but is extremely distressed at the idea of a diagnosis so we haven’t gone down that road. We are trying to be consistent with the almost ‘we don’t respond to terrorists’ type of approach.

So when she is extreme and behaving badly, we’re trying to refuse to engage but is difficult to withdraw privileges from an 18-year-old. She has her own part-time job etc. Ultimately, I know a lot of her behaviour is down to her poor self-esteem and those feelings of an adequacy in relation to her sister are about how she sees herself.

Ive always re iterated the ‘we need to be civil to each other’ line but DD2 is now ignoring DD1 and whereas I don’t endorse it, I can understand DD2s reluctance to engage with someone so volatile.

OP posts:
HectorPlasm · 25/09/2026 12:05

TLDR

BertieBotts · 25/09/2026 11:56

Have you come across SPACE at all? It might be helpful for your elder DD. I would imagine that some of her unpleasant behaviour is lashing out or rigidity in the moment related to dysregulation/anxiety/discomfort, which is ideally something she would learn not to do and (again ideally, because it's not always this simple) that you should probably aim to not accommodate, although in the short term it can be comforting to understand that it's not likely to be personal or literal. This is really tricky to manage because obviously you don't want them to feel worse, if the cause of their behaviour is them feeling bad. But OTOH the general world won't be especially understanding to any of this. Nobody outside of you, really, will care WHY she is saying/doing something unpleasant or be willing to see the underlying emotion rather than the behaviour. I don't know if there is any kind of course or therapy that would be useful in helping you work out how to navigate this, you could try investigating SPACE, NVR, CPV courses etc. (Although she is not being physically violent, the "vicious" verbal responses to you are along the same lines). She could probably find some therapy (e.g. CBT, DBT) to help herself control and stop the responses or redirect them into something which does not impact on other people, but the problem with this is that there's no point putting her into therapy if she does not want to change this behaviour. SPACE is designed to help even if the child/YP is refusing to engage, because the only thing you change is your own response. But I don't know if it would be right in this case. However it's very easy to find information about it so well worth looking up.

But then the second thing is that if she is feeling dysregulated/anxious/uncomfortable, that is likely to cause her to misinterpret and skew incoming information, so it could be that she genuinely feels aggrieved and hard done by and isn't able to recognise that this is completely out of proportion to what has actually happened, because it does feel in proportion to her. This is something where medication can help, particularly antidepressants can actually directly affect this kind of perception bias, so it might be worth encouraging her to see a doctor about checking whether her current medication is right for her (are the meds GP or psychiatrist prescribed?) but also ADHD medication sometimes seems to help with this, my vague understanding of it is that it's likely to either be a passive effect, because the ADHD meds alleviate some of the massive executive functioning load which comes with untreated ADHD and leads to exhaustion and burnout. Less exhaustion = less mood dysregulation. And/or, it increases functioning of the emotional "brakes" which allow us to tone down an emotional response from "OMG IT'S A FUCKING DISASTER" to "Oh, that's mildly annoying" as appropriate.

One last thing to add - DS2 is much younger, I do have a 17yo as well so I'm not new to this but it's DS2 who can be explosive in this way - but his can be very similar when he is generally under a high level of stress, and one thing which tends to help with managing it is to have an extremely clear and predictable system of minor sanctions plus clear rules/boundaries (for myself) as to when/how vs when not to engage, and to try as much as humanly possible not to go outside of this, and always to stick to it.

Removing the headphones as you did, I completely understand why you did that and it is logical. But it is the exact kind of thing that DS2 would not understand, and would get more and more wound up by, because it is something decided in the moment, essentially as a retaliation. It's not part of an established response pattern to behaviour. I did the exact same thing the other day - both DS2/3 were arguing about who got to use a console first, and I said they needed to discuss it and agree, which I was prepeared to referee, but because he was all wound up from school and couldn't reach a conclusion in the first 10 seconds, DS2 thumped DS3, so I snapped fine, you've lost your chance, DS3 can go first. DS2 you've lost screentime, you can maybe play later. DS2 has now been fixated on this for the last 3 days, trying to make sense of it because it makes no sense to him, trying to make sense of "If you get hit, then you automatically get first console access" or the perceived unfairness that DS3 "always" gets to go first. At the time that I said it, I was trying to say that punching is not a discussion, it is also not allowed, and since he refused to discuss calmly he lost the chance to have his time, but it wasn't clear at all and it was outside our usual system. I could have twisted it and said OK it's because you lost screen time, which is a usual sanction, but he knows that's not really what I meant in the moment, even if it was part of why it felt like a fair consequence to me at the time.

So bearing in mind it is extremely easy for me to sit here calmly and type this response and I know very well it is not easy at all in the moment, here's an idea of how a more structured response might look.

Last night there was a total screaming meltdown because she had lost about 6 sets of airpods and when I pointed out...
So first of all, stay OUT of a meltdown and do not get involved in fixing problems which are being expressed this way. Obviously if there is screaming, investigate if she is OK, not physically hurt/hurting anyone, there is no immediate emergency, but once you have established there is no emergency, disengage. If she is shouting directly AT YOU or demanding that you fix the problem, SIT ON YOUR URGE TO ANSWER THE QUESTION. If you're anything like me, I have an almost pathalogical inability to ignore a direct question, but sit on it. Even if you can SEE the headphones, do not say this. Your ONLY response to this kind of thing is to state, calmly, "I cannot help you when you are screaming at me. If you would like to talk calmly, I might be able to help." And then take whatever measures you need to hold the boundary of not engaging while she is so wound up, whether it means you stick your own headphones on and ignore her, or put a door between you or whatever.

...she might try and actually find them and still gave her a pair of my wired ones, she then continued to tell me how awful I was etc...
This is why. Because you could actually do everything "right" and solve the problem, but the problem is not that she has lost the headphones. The problem is that she is stuck in a heightened emotional state. She can't engage in useful things like trying to find her own headphones when she is dysregulated like this - this is why she's going after you, even though you want to be helpful!

Any engagement that you give towards the red herring of the lost headphones is oxygen. Any engagement that you give against the unpleasant behaviour is fuel. Her emotion is like a fire at those moments, and will consume all the fuel and oxygen available to her, but it will also burn out when there is none left, because it's just an emotion, and they don't last forever, even when they are explosive and all-consuming like this. The quickest way to help that happen is to starve the oxygen, ie, do not engage with the red herring problem (which is the lost headphones) and try not to add any fuel by reacting to the unpleasant behaviour. IME, reacting to the behaviour, although it's not great, is less of a problem than engaging with whatever the red herring is.

...even after I went and found her a pair.
I took the wired ones off her and said fine if you can’t be civil you can’t have them but I was called abusive because I took her earphones she needs to wind down
So what happened here is that you gave her fuel by reacting to the behaviour, and so she has now shifted tack because her emotion-fire has latched onto this new thing to be angry about instead. But again, whatever her emotion has latched onto which is the nearest thing to be angry about is a red herring. The problem is not that she doesn't have headphones, it's that she's gone into an emotional firestorm. I am guessing that if you tried to reason and explain that it was her own fault you took the headphones back, that would have just prolonged the argument, and you already know this, so what most likely stopped it in the end was you realising she was beyond reason and disengaging - at that point if she had nobody else to bother, it likely didn't last that much longer before fizzling out (even if she was then stewing in feeling that everyone hates her and is denying her the tools she needs to regulate etc).

This whole approach might feel cold or uncaring, but it is actually not, because you're not withdrawing your support/help, you're just postponing it, and most problems are not that urgent. It was a really really important thing I had to learn. It has basically been transformative. I was getting stuck in wanting to validate and hear the emotion/communication, even when the delivery wasn't perfect, because I had in my head that when a child or YP is in meltdown, they are not capable of talking/discussing calmly - and that's absolutely true!! They are not in the headspace to be able to do that. But there is also very little which is truly urgent enough that it is worth giving oxygen to the emotional outbursts. I think I thought that when a child/YP is in that kind of emotional state, they can't calm down without my help, but firstly, they will. Even if the meltdown goes on for an hour, it will eventually end. If nothing else, carrying on and screaming is exhausting and you physically could not keep it up. Secondly, engaging with the red herring which is the problem does not help them calm down anyway, because they will still have all this residual feeling that they want to vent at me. And I'm actually teaching them a really concerning message which is that if they want a solution, they had better scream and shout, or hit, and demand because that's one sometimes-successful method of getting it, because it is genuinely hard for them to think of or follow through on any solution when they are in an emotionally heightened state. But the message that I actually want to teach long term is that you can't solve a problem when you feel like this, the first step is to calm down. I struggled with this part because as you are probably aware, a child/YP in this kind of state won't hear that at all, and probably doesn't know how to calm down and may well believe that they can't. So if you are struggling with this or you feel that you do need to engage somehow, the thing to keep in mind is to engage only with the problem of the emotion being too high rather than engaging with the problem of the lost earphones, or whatever the red herring is. So, validation of the feeling without offering advice or solutions, sympathy without verbal input at all, (all the great stuff from the HTT books) modelling biomarkers of a calmer mental state such as deep/slow breathing, keeping your own voice low/slow and quiet, your movements slow etc. If it works for her, you can suggest things like breathing exercises or other ways to calm down but NOT as a solution to the red herring issue - e.g. if she is saying I need the headphones to listen to music etc - don't suggest speakers, or singing, or alternatives to listening to music. This can be tricky to find the line, which is why IME it's usually best just to not talk at all, and only offer nonverbal sympathy like holding out my arms for a hug, or to pretend to be very engaged in something else myself.

Also - don't get into the trap of she tones down her voice a little bit as an attempt to get you to engage, but you can see she's not really calm yet, or you start to discuss it and she instantly raises her hackles and dismisses the solution again - just say something like sorry love, I don't think we can talk about this yet, I do want to help, let's (have something to eat/have a break/get some space) first - and then don't take it personally when she flounces or insists you're refusing to help. You could obviously recognise her effort in calming herself down if that would be received OK, and sometimes when they have come down from the high level screaming/ranting/raging down to an irritable/petulant type place they can be more amenable to suggestions of things which might get them into a better space for discussion.

9/10 the "problem" disappears once they are calmer. 1/10 when they are calm they are actually willing to have a reasonable discussion and make an effort to try themselves. It does help.

I am late for school run, so I think the ending of this is a bit abrupt, but hopefully it makes sense.

Minasama · 25/09/2026 11:51

This resonates strongly with me, mine are exactly the same but a little younger. My father refuses to come for lunch because of their bickering.

I have started to be very firm. It is only semi-working but I have told the girls they need to be civil with each other, they are too old now to behave that way and it isn’t nice for other people. It’s not acceptable to speak to your sister that way. I try to balance it with support for why they might be feeling that way.

I think I am/we are seeing the results of the lack
of high expectations, strict boundaries and authoritative parenting of the past few years.

My husband and I were guilty of this, we now realise that kids don’t just behave, you have to teach them to with strict consequences for not complying.

My sister and I hated each other at times, we behaved because we were clearly expected to and we were scared of our father so we did what our mum said.

In adulthood we are the firmest of friends, because there was a strong bedrock of civilised behaviour to build on.

Modern parenting trends are doing a lot of us no favours. Yes autism makes it hard but if you are functioning you still need to know how to behave with other people.

Krispycrem · 25/09/2026 11:50

DisappearingGirl · 25/09/2026 10:07

I actually think you're already handling it as well as you can - it's just an unfortunate situation.

As you say, with an autistic teen it's a fine line between struggling and badly behaved, and you seem to be getting the best balance you can by ignoring some of it but also putting in boundaries e.g. with your headphones.

I have teen DDs who are completely different to each other. Currently DD2 is more shouty and argumentative, which means we end up shouting at her more. She sometimes implies we think DD1 is the perfect one, which is tricky to deal with, as of course we love them both equally, it's just that DD2 is usually the one who is currently ranting!

You sounds like nice parents to me.

Edited

Thank you, we are trying our best but it’s desperately tricky

OP posts:
HectorPlasm · 25/09/2026 11:41

It does seem quite clear that you prefer your younger dd, so I'm not surprised that's coming across to your eldest, who likely doesn't know how to cope with it.

What a load of tosh - doesn't read like that at all

Amorica · 25/09/2026 11:35

Is ADHD her only ND issue? I have recently gone through this with a 17 year old with ADHD. Over the years we have struggled to implement the advice of (private, since CAMHS found her needs too insignificant after years of waiting) child therapists while watching things get worse and worse and wondering how the advice was supposed to produce a child who would thrive in society. I finally connected with a psychiatrist who was a bit horrified ( hough she was very professional and did not phrase it that way!) at the things we'd been doing at the behest of therapists.

She had us simply be much firmer on the bad behaviour. Not insisting on her being nice to anyone or becoming friends with her sister, but absolutely not accepting incivil behaviour to others in the family. We changed out approach, laid down strict requirements to be civil (and ignored accusations of favourtism other than to say - these are basic rules and apply to everyone equally). We stopped the over compensating, we told her if she couldn't be civil she needed to go to her room when she was rude to us or her sister. If she refused we left the room and then enforced consequences later when she wasn't so dysregulated (e.g. allowance cut in half, or no ride to friends house, etc.).

Making her deal with her emotions and regulate them in order to get what she wanted was absolutely the best training for college we could have given her. In hindsight, I am so fucking thankful we found that psychiatrist after years of handmaiden therapists and other ADHD experts. I can't tell you how pissed off I am about the fortune we spent on them and their complete lack of expertise in how to help her become a functioning adult. I think advice might be changing now, so hopefully others won't eb so poorly supported, But if you've been doing any placating (and the more time with her sounds like you have), my advice is to stop. Draw a line in the sand. Tell her she's and adult and needs to start adapting to her environment rather than expect it to adapt to her.

But it's not all about the boundaries. Don't keep giving her more the DD2, but keep up 1:1 time. Thank her when she does something she well (but avoid patronizing her!), find ways to encourage her to get out and about doing stuff as a) gives you respite; b) exploring the countryside and having friends is excellent for her and encourages dopamine hits.

KaleidoscopeSmile · 25/09/2026 11:34

Lookatmelookatmedontevenlookatme · 25/09/2026 09:26

ND people tend to have a very powerful sense of injustice, they see younger siblings being treated differently with lower expectations and they feel very aggrieved. Could that be at the root of the golden child perception?

You’ve said one child is ND and the other not. Making comparisons between them won’t help, they aren’t the same. One is facing challenges in daily life that the other isn’t. I think you have to accept they aren’t going to be friends at the moment and not force them together. Things may well change in the future.

Misplaced "powerful sense of justice" perhaps. People's perception of the truth isn't always the actual truth and ND people aren't Marvel superheroes with more sensitive perception than NT people

There's nothing at all in any of OP's posts to suggest that the parents had lower expectations for DD2. Not being an obnoxious shit, possibly

Paganpentacle · 25/09/2026 11:33

DebbieSavage · 25/09/2026 08:44

Being neurodiverse is incredibly hard in a world that is not set up for our comfort. You should sit your other daughter down and in no uncertain terms that she is lucky to be neurotypical and not to antagonise her sister in any way. Her life will be hard enough as it is.

You have my sympathies. Please don't let your neurodiverse daughter down.

Nope.
And I say this as someone who is ND.
Its a reason... not an excuse.
The world does not and will not revolve around her and she needs to find ways to cope with that.

Dollymylove · 25/09/2026 11:28

AlexandraCarrington · 25/09/2026 09:03

You should sit your other daughter down and in no uncertain terms that she is lucky to be neurotypical and not to antagonise her sister in any way.

What is dd2 doing to antagonize her sister? From op it sounds as if she's just trying to keep out of the way.

DD2 seems to be antagonising DD1 by merely existing.
At 18 perhaps its time DD1 made alternative domestic arrangements

Treebaubles · 25/09/2026 11:27

I have a similar situation with my DD and DS, although they do get along, mainly because my DD is so very laid back. You say your DD changed at puberty, have you looked into PMDD? It is very high in girls and women with autism and/or ADHD. My DD has recently been diagnosed with it, an although she didn’t get rages as bad as your daughter, she was highly strung and it really affected her mental health.

Chamallo · 25/09/2026 11:25

Needanadultgapyear · 25/09/2026 09:19

You could be describing my sister and I accept I am your DD2 and the older one.
I was seen as more resilient and more able to cope than my DSis and expected to tolerate her melt downs with no apology afterwards.
It has taken me longer to get to your DD2’s point in fact it only happened this summer.
But how I feel and how your DD2 feels I probably suspect is I am done with being my DSis’ punching bag, from being expected to be understanding etc. I have taken a step back from her and slightly cooled to my parents too.
I accept my DSis’ ND ( and quite a lot of my families), but it doesn’t give her free rein to behave badly and I am no longer enabling it.
My DSis seems to make everything and competition and probably thinks I was the golden child, but in fact repeatably I just had to get on with stuff myself because DSis needed my parents more. Even when there was ways of supporting us both because my DSis would make such a fuss about wanting things exactly the way she wanted them with no compromise I was just left to manage.
I would appear the golden child as whether I was resilient or not originally I had to become so. I acknowledge that my parents are proud of everything I have achieved, but it came at a cost.

I’m also DD2 and it took me years to get to the point of OP’s DD2 of just detaching. I left home and then moved countries ASAP but was just running away really until I was about 30 when I openly told my parents I wouldn’t accept it anymore. At 39 they are still holding out hope we’ll somehow make friends and be loving sisters, but I wish they would just respect my boundaries.

OP, my Nan used to say “if you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all”. I think that should be the only rule that you enforce between the sisters. And don’t make them share a room on holiday! Then focus on your own relationship with each, not their relationship with each other.

To be honest it sounds like you’re doing a decent job in a difficult situation.

Makebelieveanotherlife · 25/09/2026 11:17

Tablesandchairs23 · 25/09/2026 10:01

I wouldn't concentrate on their relationship. But the behaviour of dd18. ND or not this behaviour is unacceptable.

This. She seems to rule the roost there. I wouldn’t blame dd2 for cutting contact with her as an adult. And be careful op, she might with you as well of you don’t hold dd1 accountable for her truly vile behaviour. The real world has far less tolerance for this and she is going to get a massive reality check later on.

Sussexserpents · 25/09/2026 11:14

Bellesbest · 25/09/2026 08:22

Both are behaving abysmally for 6 year olds let alone women

I don’t know what to suggest… they sound bored either way too much time on their hands. Are they students? Working?

What did the 16 year d do that was abysmal??

ChihuahuaChica · 25/09/2026 11:13

DebbieSavage · 25/09/2026 08:44

Being neurodiverse is incredibly hard in a world that is not set up for our comfort. You should sit your other daughter down and in no uncertain terms that she is lucky to be neurotypical and not to antagonise her sister in any way. Her life will be hard enough as it is.

You have my sympathies. Please don't let your neurodiverse daughter down.

Why the hell should everyone pander to the ND kid and the NT one have to walk on eggshells?
I say this as an AuDHD woman, mother of 2 x AuDHD girls.

Maybeitllneverhappen · 25/09/2026 11:09

I think you need to give DD2 lots of attention as I fear in a couple of years you won't see her for dust. I imagine she is looking at the situation as her sister is a nightmare and her parents prioritise and pander to her, giving her more time and attention. You need to put a lot more focus on her for a while or you won't see much of her post 18. It would also be a bit like toddler training for DD1; if you're nice/behave well, you get attention, but if you tantrum you don't. I know she's ND, but she's also an adult.

latetothefisting · 25/09/2026 11:08

Bellesbest · 25/09/2026 08:22

Both are behaving abysmally for 6 year olds let alone women

I don’t know what to suggest… they sound bored either way too much time on their hands. Are they students? Working?

What? What on earth has DD2 done? There's literally nothing about her actually doing anything in OP's thread apart from saying she doesn't want her sister to come to something - which makes perfect sense to me, why would she want someone there who actively makes her life a misery and who can't be trusted to behave?

Sounds like she's avoiding her sister as much as possible to try and avoid arguments, which is probably the best thing she can do! Although even then she's still getting called names in the middle of arguments that are nothing to do with her.

Not to mention she legally is still a child, not a woman.

CherryBlossom321 · 25/09/2026 11:06

Any ideas, OP, why DD1 is currently so dysregulated? Are there any factors that may be contributing such as friendship struggles, intense romantic relationship, academic pressure? If it offers any reassurance, we’re an ND household and my 14 and 18 year old girls also currently don’t connect, or relate positively with one another - but that won’t necessarily be the case forever, you know? It might just be too much for them right now.

Cutletcake · 25/09/2026 11:03

Very difficult OP and exhausting.

No one child can dominate the house is my opinion.
I have NT children and it can be challenging.

But I have never accepted bad behaviour.
DD1 sounds a bit like a house terrorist and everything is on her terms.
DD2 no longer cares about being around her, which actually is her choice.

DD1 needs a much firmer line to be held.
In the real world she will be avoided by others because everything is about her.
ND is often coupled with huge selfishness in my experience, however in this house I have pushed back hard not to accept it.

It is exhausting and I feel very sorry for you.

I would in your place tell them both that you have had enough and to keep out of each other's way.

Stop trying to fix things and find your pissed off anger.
Start making life a bit less comfortable.
Your health will undoubtedly be impacted by this stress.
You need to mind yourself.

LAMPS1 · 25/09/2026 11:01

Is it possible that you have made so many adjustments within the family unit in favour of DD1 that she has come to rely on it/expect it/feel entitled to it. And rail against it when she doesn’t get her own way or have things on her own terms.

Your priority objective should be to enable her to live independently.
Only you know how much of her conduct is down to her disability and how much she is milking it to get her own way. Either way she can’t behave like this outside of the home without making extra problems for herself. So now could be the time to let her realise that she has to go the extra mile to make adjustments herself instead of relying on her family to always take the hits.

Do you think you could become a bit firmer and stop picking up the pieces all the time. Sounds as if you are spoon feeding her instead of letting her find out the hard way. A neurodivergent teen still needs to fall occasionally so that she learns how to pick herself up and make her own logical connections for next time.
Sounds like she needs to face a few more consequences from her own argumentative actions.
Is she just in a habit now of being deliberatly contradictory ?

For example, after a quick reminder about practising respect and family compromise, you could say something like …..”DD1, I expect no argument, and no back chat from you for the rest of today. Any sign of argument or disrespect to any of us and this will be the consequence….. Up to you to show us you can at least try to stop causing conflict. Life is extra hard for you we know that, but now that you are older, that simply means you have to learn faster and be a whole lot more thoughful about not letting your disability hurt anybody else around you.

I feel sorry for DD2 in this situation. 5 years living in this stressful relationship could well have shaped her differently.
I would try to minimise any negative effect on her and certainly ensure that she never has to share a room with her older sister on holiday again.
All the best OP.

Totaldramallama · 25/09/2026 11:00

Sounds like my sister tbh. I was younger and she was an absolutely awful teenager. No diagnosed neuro divergence but I wouldn't be surprised if she had some kind of personality disorder. My parents tolerated it. I was a lot earlier going, no trouble, no arguments, and basically just got on with life while everyone tip toed around my sister. Absolutely awful but there is no situation that won't leave dd1 feeling slighted because that is how she perceives the world from the sounds of it, she is the victim and everyone else is at fault.

Floatlikeafeather2 · 25/09/2026 10:58

TruffleSlinky · 25/09/2026 08:29

Why is DD2 behaving abysmally?

This, @Bellesbest . In what way is the younger daughter behaving badly?