Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is not an activity in primary school

223 replies

Summertime2006 · 19/09/2026 10:59

My son's class were asked to bring in a white plain tv as they were going to be doing designs. The teacher did not go into detail about these designs and what they would be about.

I asked my son if he had a nice day and just general conversation about what they are using the t shirts to design. I assumed it would be for an art project.
He told me that actually it was for geography and they were all designing t shirts for a climate protest.

I was a little taken a back because I thought schools were not suppose to get involved with politics or activism.

Now before people start, yes I think the climate is important and yes we all need to do our bit for the world. However I think there is a time and place and I don't think a primary school geography class is that place for the teacher to put it upon the children.

Aibu?

OP posts:
Mothership4two · 20/09/2026 12:30

Talk to the teacher to get some clarification maybe? I'd be incredibly surprised if the school was organising a protest especially without parents knowledge! He may have worded it badly. How old is your son?

Personally I would have used it to talk to him and ask him what his views are.

Ladyfromthehill · 20/09/2026 12:11

Timeforachange26 · 20/09/2026 08:19

I'm pretty sure we were told that in the early 80s

And... we DO live in a defintiely more unpleasant climate than in the 80s. So they were not wrong.

Ladyfromthehill · 20/09/2026 12:10

have they booked a coach to disrupt a WE play and throw soup at a painting in National gallery?
if not, I think you need to brew youself camomille tea and chill, as you dont seem to understand what political activism even means.

Tryagain26 · 20/09/2026 11:28

Surely all they are doing is being made aware of the dangers of climate change, and being made to think about it in a creative way. I think it's a very reasonable use of time combining geography with art and design, and awareness of current issues.

elh1605 · 20/09/2026 11:26

I would imagine it was used as something different yo get the children enthusiastic about and probably presented to the rest of the school in an assembly. My daughter took part in a 'peaceful protest' about therapy dogs in school around school in yr5 and loved it said it made it more "real' and understood more about the suffragettes. Teachers are always so tied to school/DofE rules that when they think outside the box they get moaned at🤬

lebin · 20/09/2026 11:25

xyzandabc · 19/09/2026 11:02

I don't really see it as any different to 'make a poster about climate change' which would be a normal primary school activity. They are just using a different medium.

I very much doubt they are going to take them to stand out on the street shouting and holding placards.

Completely agree with this.

EmmaB1309 · 20/09/2026 11:11

Yabu

MyLimeGuide · 20/09/2026 08:33

So is the teacher buying a load of those special pens to draw on t shirts? Or are they designing graphics on a computer to be printed on special iron/heat press on paper?

Timeforachange26 · 20/09/2026 08:21

HatStickBoots · 20/09/2026 07:30

It’s not about the parents though is it? It’s for the children. The shirts will only “get chucked in the bin” if the parents insist on doing so and what message does that give to your child?The children will learn a lot while doing this project and why shouldn’t they be allowed to keep their shirts afterwards? They’ll probably enjoy the process and want to keep it.

More likely they won't give a damn and I it's not chucked away it still will never be worn again

Timeforachange26 · 20/09/2026 08:19

sherbetlemonade · 20/09/2026 00:05

If we don't do something about climate change, those children in primary school now will be living in a very different and unpleasant world by the time they reach old age.

I'm pretty sure we were told that in the early 80s

TheKeatingFive · 20/09/2026 07:50

HatStickBoots · 20/09/2026 07:30

It’s not about the parents though is it? It’s for the children. The shirts will only “get chucked in the bin” if the parents insist on doing so and what message does that give to your child?The children will learn a lot while doing this project and why shouldn’t they be allowed to keep their shirts afterwards? They’ll probably enjoy the process and want to keep it.

Why make parents buy t shirts that aren’t wanted or needed though?

Shedmistress · 20/09/2026 07:31

HatStickBoots · 20/09/2026 07:30

It’s not about the parents though is it? It’s for the children. The shirts will only “get chucked in the bin” if the parents insist on doing so and what message does that give to your child?The children will learn a lot while doing this project and why shouldn’t they be allowed to keep their shirts afterwards? They’ll probably enjoy the process and want to keep it.

I was a pretty sharp snarky kid and that is the first thing I'd have asked the teacher.

HatStickBoots · 20/09/2026 07:30

Shedmistress · 20/09/2026 07:09

What do you think getting parents to buy tshirts that will just get chucked in the bin, and painting them will actually do for climate change?

It’s not about the parents though is it? It’s for the children. The shirts will only “get chucked in the bin” if the parents insist on doing so and what message does that give to your child?The children will learn a lot while doing this project and why shouldn’t they be allowed to keep their shirts afterwards? They’ll probably enjoy the process and want to keep it.

BogRollBOGOF · 20/09/2026 07:28

Upcycling an old, used t-shirt, fine. Buying a new one is ironically wasteful of the planets resources and parent's money.

I like a pp's suggestion of upcycling card to make banners as that's not generating additional waste or costs.

Climate change is an appropriate part of Geography and Science to learn about.
Protest is an appropriate part of Citizenship/ PSHE/ "British Values" to learn about. This is a good topic for these concepts because it's about a scientific fact.
There are a lot of strands of the curriculum including Art being brought together.

The line into being political would be crossed if the "protest" was affiliated with a group such as Just Stop Oil.

Shedmistress · 20/09/2026 07:09

sherbetlemonade · 20/09/2026 00:05

If we don't do something about climate change, those children in primary school now will be living in a very different and unpleasant world by the time they reach old age.

What do you think getting parents to buy tshirts that will just get chucked in the bin, and painting them will actually do for climate change?

Sartre · 20/09/2026 07:07

They’ll have been learning about climate change activism which is entirely reasonable and through this, the teacher thought it would be fun to design a protest tshirt. I have no idea what your gripe is but it’s silly and you need to get out more.

ArabellaScott · 20/09/2026 07:05

sherbetlemonade · 20/09/2026 00:05

If we don't do something about climate change, those children in primary school now will be living in a very different and unpleasant world by the time they reach old age.

Can assure you many if not most children are very aware of the issues. To.the point of anxiety.

I do wonder if there's much point given how little action most governments (and people, really) are willing to take. A hard balance to strike.

ArabellaScott · 20/09/2026 07:03

Changeisstillpossible · 19/09/2026 14:18

@ArabellaScott one of my kids liked to challenge everything he was taught.

When the class was told to write a piece on global warming (as the terminology was back then), he negotiated with his teacher and was allowed to research and write about global cooling instead.

Sounds like a great exercise. A good teacher should encourage exactly that kind of debate and criticsl thinking.

JMSA · 20/09/2026 00:59

YABU and ridiculous.

sherbetlemonade · 20/09/2026 00:05

If we don't do something about climate change, those children in primary school now will be living in a very different and unpleasant world by the time they reach old age.

ThisGutsyQuail · 19/09/2026 23:52

Just by the way, cotton is an environmental disaster.

CalamityJane81 · 19/09/2026 20:59

Grumpyoldcat · 19/09/2026 14:21

I hardly think climate change is a political controversy. Only nutcases dont believe it is a real issue. It is taught later on too. Also this is a way of introducing children to rights (and responsibilities).

I agree mostly. Worth noting though that it’s quite hard to fit the curriculum in as it is. Any teacher will tell you that they need to catch up on lots of lessons because of all the extra curricular events that happen. I don’t think this would be a hill to die on but I do think OP is correct to be a little skeptical and keep a close eye on what is being taught.

BeOchreDog · 19/09/2026 20:03

NeverDropYourMooncup · 19/09/2026 19:14

Ask a charity shop to give them unwashed clothing that is given to the ragman because it's too poor quality, dirty and damaged to be anything but shredded? Or find a mythical item of damaged but not too damaged and won't get a kid teased for having tatty clothing to repair, miraculously happen to use up boxes of food (got to check no nuts or other major allergens were stored in them) or cleaning products (but watch out for allergies), don't forget to tip away the last of the contents so they're wasted, and then produce another collage of rubbish that will definitely go straight in the bin?

Inspired.

Have you ever volunteered at a charity shop? I run a charity clothing exchange, loads of clothes are perfectly clean but are frayed, a little bobbled or just a bit wash faded that go for rags. There are also loads of old fashion curtains, table clothes etc donated that go to rags. There is no reason that these can’t be cut into strips of fabric for reuse in a banner.

Schools forever ask for small boxes or plastic containers for craft projects, collages can be recycled and no additional waste is produced.

Upcycling outgrown or damaged clothes is a perfectly normal project for a design class.

All are actually supporting the curriculum regarding reuse and global warming rather that actively harming the environment because it’s easier.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 19/09/2026 19:14

BeOchreDog · 19/09/2026 18:13

A tiny bit of creative thinking from the teacher could have fulfilled the design technology brief - ask parents to bring in a damaged item of clothing that could have been patched/repaired and painted, asked a charity shop for a bag of rags to cut up as fabric scraps to make a banner, ask for a bag of dry household recycling to make posters. It’s lazy and uninspired teaching.

Ask a charity shop to give them unwashed clothing that is given to the ragman because it's too poor quality, dirty and damaged to be anything but shredded? Or find a mythical item of damaged but not too damaged and won't get a kid teased for having tatty clothing to repair, miraculously happen to use up boxes of food (got to check no nuts or other major allergens were stored in them) or cleaning products (but watch out for allergies), don't forget to tip away the last of the contents so they're wasted, and then produce another collage of rubbish that will definitely go straight in the bin?

Inspired.

dizzydizzydizzy · 19/09/2026 19:07

squarecrow · 19/09/2026 14:19

Sorry are you suggesting they are protesting facts in schools now?

Climate change is a fact. It can’t be protested. People protest about policies, which involve beliefs and opinions. Again, the word “protest” implies that it is not about “raising awareness” otherwise the wording would be “awareness campaign” not “protest”.

Yes I agree that protest implies politics but I I’m pretty sure it won’t be a protest. I think the OP’s Dc has got the wrong end of the stick.