Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To pin child’s wrists to their side

157 replies

Calmondeck · 18/09/2026 19:59

Friday night picnic in the park with another family. Neighbours from down the street, our kids play together multiple times a week. Often I am the parent supervising, and am usually playful and interacting with the kids, tonight I was happy to have adult company and a chat. The neighbour’s eldest child (aged 5) started picking clumps of grass and throwing them on my head while I was sitting eating. I said no. He continued to pick grass and throw it on my head, at my face, down my shirt, demanding that I come play with him. The mum, in a sing song voice said “oh I don’t think CalmOnDeck is liking that”, he ignored her, continued despite my protests. My DH snapped, “stop, child’s name”. When the child approached me again I held his wrists to prevent him from throwing more grass, and said firmly “I am not playing this game”. His mum then reacted saying “darling, come sit down”.
I feel a bit unsettled because it didn’t feel comfortable telling off someone else’s child, and I wondered whether it was unacceptable to hold his wrists. But I was also completely baffled by his parent’s lack of early intervention. When we got home, my DH thought it was outrageous the child’s parents were so passive, despite me clearly saying no and objecting that food was getting covered in grass.
Was IBU for holding his wrists? Should I have asked his parents to react? Keen to know how others would have handled this

OP posts:
RikthePoet · 20/09/2026 14:21

Releasemeplease · 20/09/2026 13:47

Really?I think you are being very naive here.
Unwanted and uninvited touching of any one can be construed as assault. Certainly here in Scotland. Where , incidently, also corporal punishment of children is a crime. Touching children, and indeed adults, can lay you open to accusations.
And yes there are legal constraints on the use of restriction.

Yes, really.

Touching anyone can be assault.

You can't assault children you are related to and you can't assault children you are unrelated to.

There is no law about "touching children unrelated to you."

likelysuspect · 20/09/2026 13:49

You were right to do it and its not inappropriate. I cant be bothered to read the other responses because I can predict someone will say you virtually assaulted the child.

Dont hang out with them again if she cant parent her own child. It forces another adult to act and then probably get a load of grief for it.

Releasemeplease · 20/09/2026 13:47

RikthePoet · 20/09/2026 13:33

There is no law about "touching children unrelated to you."

Really?I think you are being very naive here.
Unwanted and uninvited touching of any one can be construed as assault. Certainly here in Scotland. Where , incidently, also corporal punishment of children is a crime. Touching children, and indeed adults, can lay you open to accusations.
And yes there are legal constraints on the use of restriction.

RikthePoet · 20/09/2026 13:33

Releasemeplease · 18/09/2026 22:22

Well as someone who is not totally familiar with what the law actually is on restraining children, or even touching children that are unrelated to me I would personally be very wary of doing this.
I don't know why my comnent is controversial. I'm not criticising OP for what she did. I think she had good cause. But I thought the safest and general rule is not to touch other people's children because it is very easy for an adult to be viewed as being in the wrong in situations like this.

There is no law about "touching children unrelated to you."

anotherside · 20/09/2026 13:30

If he was about to throw stuff at or hit your child would it be inappropriate to restrain another child? Obviously not. So same principle applies.

WhatNoRaisins · 20/09/2026 13:08

I don't think that we need to resort to harsh discipline but I don't think you're ever too young to be taught that your actions can impact on other people.

LittleGreenShoots · 20/09/2026 13:04

Oof OP I know how you feel. I recently had to prise my daughters sand truck out of a (I'd guess) 4 year olds hand after he'd grabbed it and ran away with it. No parent in sight for the little boy, nice words and asking him were doing nothing, and my daughter was upset/ I needed to get back to her without wasting too much time. It felt very wrong to force a toy out of another kids hand but if their parent won't parent what can you do really?

PivotPivotmakingmargaritas · 20/09/2026 12:58

wiredandtired · 20/09/2026 12:55

That's not gentle parenting. It's permissive/ lazy/ passive - call it what you will - but gentle parenting is something completely different.

I know…. that’s why I have gentle in quotation marks. As so many parents say they are “gentle” but actually permissive/ lazy aka raising a little brat - I’m a teacher I see it ALL the time - it’s exhausting

wiredandtired · 20/09/2026 12:55

PivotPivotmakingmargaritas · 20/09/2026 12:45

God I’m over “gentle “ / passive parenting.

Had this the other day at a restaurant- not even a known kid he had the salt shaker and was trying to put salt all over my daughter her food - I was batting the salt shaker away while parents watched !!! I wish I had said “hello - do you want to parent!!!”

but I was gobsmacked the situation was happening

Next time

  1. tell the mum can you get him to stop!!
  2. If she/ he doesn’t you pack up go home - her lack of boundaries shouldn’t mean you get grass/ dirt thrown at you!

Also I’d be distancing myself from this friend her perish cherub is only going to get worse!

That's not gentle parenting. It's permissive/ lazy/ passive - call it what you will - but gentle parenting is something completely different.

PivotPivotmakingmargaritas · 20/09/2026 12:45

God I’m over “gentle “ / passive parenting.

Had this the other day at a restaurant- not even a known kid he had the salt shaker and was trying to put salt all over my daughter her food - I was batting the salt shaker away while parents watched !!! I wish I had said “hello - do you want to parent!!!”

but I was gobsmacked the situation was happening

Next time

  1. tell the mum can you get him to stop!!
  2. If she/ he doesn’t you pack up go home - her lack of boundaries shouldn’t mean you get grass/ dirt thrown at you!

Also I’d be distancing myself from this friend her perish cherub is only going to get worse!

wiredandtired · 20/09/2026 12:38

CleverlyBeery · 20/09/2026 12:30

Telling your kid not to throw grass isn't a "conflict" to be avoided, ffs!

If she doesn't do basic parenting she'll have a lot more conflict in store.

Children do actually need discipline. It's harmful to have no idea what boundaries are, and to try and work them out for yourself as a child, which is why adults need to be clear and consistent.

Yes it's exhausting, but that's a consequence of having a child. Quite a well-publicised one!

Yes. There are two points to address here, though -

  1. The child needs boundaries, clearly.

  2. Whether OP should have taken it upon herself to physically restrain the child.

I would have just said more firmly to the parent "Please can you stop him" rather than restraining him myself, in the first instance.

If the parent still did nothing and he carried on, then maybe, but really I probably would have just got up and moved away.

CleverlyBeery · 20/09/2026 12:30

Telling your kid not to throw grass isn't a "conflict" to be avoided, ffs!

If she doesn't do basic parenting she'll have a lot more conflict in store.

Children do actually need discipline. It's harmful to have no idea what boundaries are, and to try and work them out for yourself as a child, which is why adults need to be clear and consistent.

Yes it's exhausting, but that's a consequence of having a child. Quite a well-publicised one!

NovemberMorn · 20/09/2026 12:29

I think you deserve a medal for your restraint.
Well done.

wiredandtired · 20/09/2026 12:22

I wouldn't have touched him personally.

The mother was being really passive by the sound of it, so I do understand why you did it, but it's never ideal to physically restrain a child if you can avoid it.

When he carried on after being told not to, I would have firmly said to the mother, "Can you stop him doing this, please?"

If she didn't respond then I would have got up and moved out of the way. I suspect the mother would take some action at that point.

If she didn't, then potentially at that point (and only at that point) I would physically move him away from me if he carried on, or maybe leave the picnic.

It sounds like the mum is struggling, so could you talk to her about how you manage your kids' behaviour, or if you have any strategies she could try?

Calmondeck · 20/09/2026 12:15

My grip didn’t hurt him at all, it was just to stop him throwing more. I held the wrists because both of his hands were full of grass ripped up at the root, so dirt everywhere.
The mum has told me she’s exhausted by parenting and that she’s conflict avoidant. Maybe that’s why her response was so subdued.

OP posts:
NancyThompson · 20/09/2026 11:58

JLou08 · 19/09/2026 09:53

This is ridiculous. No one assaulted anyone but if OP did assault a child there is not a chance that she could get off with self defense over a 5 year old throwing grass. She should have just walked away.

The child was not assaulted.

No wonder we have a brat epidemic.

WhatNoRaisins · 20/09/2026 11:45

I wonder how kids who are never corrected while the adults just move aside to let them carry on feel when they get older and people stop tolerating their shitty behaviour. It must be a huge disappointment.

Bitsostuff · 20/09/2026 11:18

YABU to be worrying about this. What was the alternative? Run away? Sit there smiling like a limp lettuce whilst he chucks stuff at you?

sherbetlemonade · 20/09/2026 11:17

LoafofSellotape · 19/09/2026 10:19

I wouldn't have touched someone else's child,I would've stood up and moved out of the way and continued to stand until the mother reprimanded him.

The mother wasn't going to do that though, was she? She was being far too namby pamby with him.

If children won't do as they are told, then sometimes they need to be physically prevented from lashing out, hitting, and throwing things. OP was fine to do that.

BluebellBeth · 20/09/2026 11:12

SockPlant · 20/09/2026 08:24

you'd have been in for a long stand i feel.

And another boy learns that awful behaviour is tolerated and women have to move. [slow handclap.]

Edited

So would it be ok for a dad to do this to a girl? And another girl learns men are allowed to put hands on them if they don't behave exactly as wanted [slow handclap]

SockPlant · 20/09/2026 10:53

yeah there is a complete and utter pattern of girls and women overriding boy's and men's wishes. It starts early

LoafofSellotape · 20/09/2026 10:02

SockPlant · 20/09/2026 08:24

you'd have been in for a long stand i feel.

And another boy learns that awful behaviour is tolerated and women have to move. [slow handclap.]

Edited

Oh please,I've known plenty of little girls who are equally as irritating. I wouldn't have stood for long as I would've moved or gone home.

SockPlant · 20/09/2026 08:24

LoafofSellotape · 19/09/2026 10:19

I wouldn't have touched someone else's child,I would've stood up and moved out of the way and continued to stand until the mother reprimanded him.

you'd have been in for a long stand i feel.

And another boy learns that awful behaviour is tolerated and women have to move. [slow handclap.]

BeEagerRubyBird · 19/09/2026 11:45

Tvradiorentals · 19/09/2026 08:51

I’m kind of relieved after reading the full OP. When I read the opening title I was picturing a poor child running around with the cuffs of their jumper secured to the waist of their trousers with a couple of safety pins. Now that would have been a step too far 😆

When I read the title I thought hmm dubious but could I possibly do that to my little non-stop fiddler?? 🤔 Tempting!! 😜

LaidOnYourBackWithTheBoyWithTheArabStrap · 19/09/2026 11:37

I would be mortified if one of my kids behaved that way and chucked dirt at you once, let alone repeatedly. You gave the fucking stupid parents a chance to sort their kid out and they didn’t bother. I certainly wouldn’t socialise with those dickheads again.