Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to challenge school regarding 'rewards trip'?

30 replies

Gooseegando · 18/09/2026 10:22

'Rewards trip' in about a months time. Paid for and based on a list of requirements including no more than 1 absence. (Hate these things)

DS was very ill last week and had 1 day off, spent in bed with me tending to him.

Yesterday his mate who he spends all his time in school and after school, vomitted in class and was sent home. DS inevitably started doing the same last night so obviously isn't in school today.

So he has had 2 days off which excludes him from trip on paper (no refund of money paid if 'rules broken' btw so money down drain we can't really afford)

However he has been genuinely ill with something that is obviously contagious AND last year he struggled so badly with attendance that his yearly percentage was under 40%

Last year he had severe MH issues that had him under emergency measures with the GP and CAMHs.

He went down school refusal path and it was horrific.

School didn't expect him to come in on time at all, they said as long as he comes in at somepoint in the day, thats ok with us. He had CAMHs meetings, in school counselling, other hospital appointments due to physical issues (inc diet because of dramatic weightloss and stress related skin flare ups that are on going) He was averaging 2 to 3 days a week OFF school

He basically didn't attend school at all the last month of the year and school just gave up, as did we, towards the 6 weeks holidays.

So since Sep 3rd he has been getting up every morning, getting dressed. Getting to school on time (a few lates of 10 mins or so but compared to 11am etc before holidays)

He has been trying so hard and this morning he was so stressed and wanted me to take him onto school so he could be seen to be very ill and 'sent home' in hopes that wouldn't affect his rewards trip.

But I couldn't, in good conscience, send him in knowing he had caught this from his friend and so could pass it on to someone else.

If school come back and say he has lost his place on the trip WIBU to try and challenge it based on the fact he cannot possibly be expected to attend with a spreadable virus and the fact he has tried so hard over the last 2 weeks to turn EVERYTHING around??

The difference between last term and this term is night and day and although I can see that on paper he has 'failed' the criteria already, compared to last year he has made an incredible improvement and that should be taken into account?

This is all hypothetical as they haven't said anything yet but am just thinking ahead whether to just accept it if they decline or try my luck?

On one hand the rules are the rules but he has also only missed school because of genuine illness and its advised to stay home if vomiting?

Urgh. Why do they do these rewards trips at all?

Also so unfair to not get a refund!

Am not complaining about the school directly BTW (just these rewards trip thing so many of them seem to do now) they have been amazing with DS. So supportive in trying to help him and understanding what he has been going through (which also makes me think they might be willing to change the goal posts a little with him?)

OP posts:
runnerducky · 18/09/2026 11:07

Personally if they say he now can’t come I would take him out that day and do something even better. Although I’m in Scotland so no fines or anything to contend with. Not sure how easy it is to do that in England.

runnerducky · 18/09/2026 11:05

These attendance rewards are shit because kids who genuinely have attendance issues aren’t going to magically start attending for them and it just punishes kids who have no control over whether they are ill or not who attend 95% of the time anyway.

They should be behaviour or academic based or not at all.

Gooseegando · 18/09/2026 10:59

Credittocress · 18/09/2026 10:32

It’s annoying, but if other kids see them breaking the rules for him I don’t see how they can then enforce them with others?

If you disagree with the principle of reward trios you shouldn’t have signed him up in the first place. It’s a bit rum to find your principles only when you’re child misses out.

I understand this but what was I supposed to say to him?

"Look I know that you want to go on this trip and you are trying your hardest, you are getting up every morning and getting to school but I just don't believe that you will be able to keep it up for 6 weeks without a single discrepancy so I'm not paying for you to go"?

That would be horrible!

I'd basically be telling him that I don't believe he has the ability to do something he wants to try and achieve. And he has been trying.

Hes not refused school once.

To go from the daily battles we had last term to him being up and dressed on time every single day is nothing short of amazing.

OP posts:
TallagallaPenguin · 18/09/2026 10:41

Those criteria are horrible. Genuinely ridiculous given people get ill. I hate attendance awards - really discriminatory. I know what they’re trying to do but that basically makes it like you can’t win if you have a couple of days actual sickness.

Our school did reward trips for attitude and behaviour- in their reports they get two marks for each subject, a “how well they’re doing academically” mark and an “attitude to learning” score - ie arrives on time, engages, respectful, makes an effort etc. So “turning up to class” is a part of it but you wouldn’t get dinged for being ill for a few days. And it’s not just the smarter kids - anyone who puts effort in with good behaviours can get it. It seems much more reasonable.

Credittocress · 18/09/2026 10:32

It’s annoying, but if other kids see them breaking the rules for him I don’t see how they can then enforce them with others?

If you disagree with the principle of reward trios you shouldn’t have signed him up in the first place. It’s a bit rum to find your principles only when you’re child misses out.