Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to find my friend's behaviour rude and increasingly irritating?

87 replies

whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 17:17

I had a longtime male friend who came over to my house yesterday for my birthday - and I'm finding some of his behaviour increasingly irritating. I'm not sure whether I'm being unreasonable or whether he's actually being quite rude.

The latest thing happened yesterday. I asked him what he wanted to eat as I was planning to prepare some food (I hadn't yet eaten). His response was:

'I don't know. I'll eat whatever you leave behind.'

I thought this was a really odd thing to say. I was genuinely asking what he wanted to eat - not offering him my leftovers!

Anyway, I ate my food and - true to his word, he asked if I was done - and he ate what was left afterwards... then he left the plate and cutlery exactly where they were and made no attempt to clear them up. Then he left.

It's the combination that bothered me. It was my birthday, he was a guest in my home - and I was trying to be hospitable. Instead, I felt as though I was somehow expected to feed him whatever happened to be left and then clear up after him.

There are other things that have started to grate too (because I know the above sounds ridiculous).

We were out with another friend last week and she was telling a story of her recent travels. She mentioned a motorbike and he immediately started making loud motorbike-revving noises. Later she mentioned she was going to a church event and he started singing in a sort of exaggerated choir-boy voice.

It felt very attention-seeking and performative. I mentioned it to the friend afterwards and interestingly... she had noticed exactly the same thing.

We're going out tomorrow with two other people, so I'm now slightly dreading him doing something similarly attention-seeking.

I don't actually want to have a big confrontation with him. I'm more inclined to just stop inviting him to my home and keep things to meeting socially. But I'm annoyed enough that part of me wants to tell him that I found the behaviour rude and inconsiderate.

Would this annoy you - or am I massively overreacting? Yes, I realise the leftovers/plate thing sounds ridiculously minor written down. It's more the overall pattern that is getting to me. There are many more examples - but if I were to list them all, I'd be here forever.

OP posts:
whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 17:50

HopeSpringingHigh · 17/09/2026 17:47

As bizarre as his behaviour was . ( and I'd see it as him taking control. ) I don't understand why you gave him the power? Why not plate him up a bit and say " no guest of mine is eating leftovers. "

He insisted on me not plating him up anything - to the point where it got awkward given how much he was resisting. I'm aware that it's hard to articulate to those not in the room, but it was just so weird.

OP posts:
whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 17:49

springintospring26 · 17/09/2026 17:39

So you asked him what meal he wanted. Did you give him choices? It sounds totally bizarre. I can honestly never imagine a situation where I’d be having this conversation with a friend around for my Birthday. It would be ‘ I’m cooking a lasagne/ steak/ stir fry whatever. Is that ok with you?

It wasn't really about the 'choice' of meal that bothered me. I've hosted people plenty of times where I've already started cooking etc... (the only thing I need to know in advance is of any allergies). It's not that deep.

It was his behaviour about what happened afterwards that I found so odd. He insisted on me not plating him up anything - to the point where it got awkward given how much he was resisting.

Then the fact that he ate from my plate - and left the plate and cutlery there for me to literally pick up after him as he left.

OP posts:
HopeSpringingHigh · 17/09/2026 17:47

As bizarre as his behaviour was . ( and I'd see it as him taking control. ) I don't understand why you gave him the power? Why not plate him up a bit and say " no guest of mine is eating leftovers. "

whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 17:44

springintospring26 · 17/09/2026 17:39

So you asked him what meal he wanted. Did you give him choices? It sounds totally bizarre. I can honestly never imagine a situation where I’d be having this conversation with a friend around for my Birthday. It would be ‘ I’m cooking a lasagne/ steak/ stir fry whatever. Is that ok with you?

I had a whole host of options - about 3-4 meal choices as well as food already out before he showed up (for him). I ended up making a choice that was preferable for me since he couldn't decide. I obviously made enough for 4 - despite there being only 2 of us.

He kept saying he didn't want to eat - and then halfway through me eating - he asked if I was 'done' - and ate from my plate. I STILL offered him his own plate/portion - since there was so much food - and he said 'no'.

OP posts:
Mouldemort · 17/09/2026 17:41

People who say "oh, whatever is easiest" or "I don't mind" when you ask them how they want their tea are infuriating. I've taken to saying "What would make me happy is to be able to give you something that you really like. You will need to tell me what that is." I would also ask a friend to clear up or help me if it's appropriate.

As for this guy, if you actually like him and know him well enough, sit down and tell him what your issues are. Ask him to listen until you have finished and not be defensive. Then see if you can work it out. If you aren't that good a friend, I would wind down the friendship.

springintospring26 · 17/09/2026 17:39

whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 17:35

Oh no, it wasn't that. I had plenty of food/snacks laid out already - but I asked him what MEAL he wanted, since I was cooking. (Which was why he came over... since I said I was cooking). I think that's also my gripe, because I'm always hosting/cooking/baking etc... and go to a lot of effort. (Not just yesterday, but always). I wouldn't invite someone over... and them have them watch me eat. LOL!

I did indeed naturally offer to make more of what I was cooking, but he said 'no'. He said to make one portion for me - and he'd eat whatever I didn't. Hence the bizarreness.

Edited

So you asked him what meal he wanted. Did you give him choices? It sounds totally bizarre. I can honestly never imagine a situation where I’d be having this conversation with a friend around for my Birthday. It would be ‘ I’m cooking a lasagne/ steak/ stir fry whatever. Is that ok with you?

whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 17:35

springintospring26 · 17/09/2026 17:33

I’m not sure. It sounds bizarre that you left your guest without food while you ate. Why didn’t you just make double what you made yourself? It’s hard being asked by a host what you want to eat. I mean I’d actually want lobster but obviously wouldn’t ask for that.

Oh no, it wasn't that. I had plenty of food/snacks laid out already - but I asked him what MEAL he wanted, since I was cooking. (Which was why he came over... since I said I was cooking). I think that's also my gripe, because I'm always hosting/cooking/baking etc... and go to a lot of effort. (Not just yesterday, but always). I wouldn't invite someone over... and them have them watch me eat. LOL!

I did indeed naturally offer to make more of what I was cooking, but he said 'no'. He said to make one portion for me - and he'd eat whatever I didn't. Hence the bizarreness.

OP posts:
whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 17:33

Shinyandnew1 · 17/09/2026 17:30

He sounds strange!

Generally, as you get to know someone, if you find them odd, the friendship will struggle and die a death.

You are still friends with him though, so what has happened? Is this new behaviour?

I don't know if I have just noticed it more. In recent times, I've been doing a lot of inner work - and have been stronger with my boundaries/protecting myself - so perhaps I'm just noticing it more - but then again, other people have also noticed/commented on his behaviour - so I don't think it's just me being hyper-aware of it.

OP posts:
springintospring26 · 17/09/2026 17:33

I’m not sure. It sounds bizarre that you left your guest without food while you ate. Why didn’t you just make double what you made yourself? It’s hard being asked by a host what you want to eat. I mean I’d actually want lobster but obviously wouldn’t ask for that.

Shinyandnew1 · 17/09/2026 17:30

He sounds strange!

Generally, as you get to know someone, if you find them odd, the friendship will struggle and die a death.

You are still friends with him though, so what has happened? Is this new behaviour?

whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 17:22

TFImBackIn · 17/09/2026 17:19

That would really irritate me, tbh. What the hell's he doing with those noises and why does he want to eat from your plate?

It was bizarre. I can't put my finger on it. It feels like some attention seeking behaviour/lack of consideration etc...

Before anyone assumes, he's not struggling financially etc... it's not a case of him feeling ashamed/not being able to afford food or anything etc...

OP posts:
TFImBackIn · 17/09/2026 17:19

That would really irritate me, tbh. What the hell's he doing with those noises and why does he want to eat from your plate?