Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to find my friend's behaviour rude and increasingly irritating?

87 replies

whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 17:17

I had a longtime male friend who came over to my house yesterday for my birthday - and I'm finding some of his behaviour increasingly irritating. I'm not sure whether I'm being unreasonable or whether he's actually being quite rude.

The latest thing happened yesterday. I asked him what he wanted to eat as I was planning to prepare some food (I hadn't yet eaten). His response was:

'I don't know. I'll eat whatever you leave behind.'

I thought this was a really odd thing to say. I was genuinely asking what he wanted to eat - not offering him my leftovers!

Anyway, I ate my food and - true to his word, he asked if I was done - and he ate what was left afterwards... then he left the plate and cutlery exactly where they were and made no attempt to clear them up. Then he left.

It's the combination that bothered me. It was my birthday, he was a guest in my home - and I was trying to be hospitable. Instead, I felt as though I was somehow expected to feed him whatever happened to be left and then clear up after him.

There are other things that have started to grate too (because I know the above sounds ridiculous).

We were out with another friend last week and she was telling a story of her recent travels. She mentioned a motorbike and he immediately started making loud motorbike-revving noises. Later she mentioned she was going to a church event and he started singing in a sort of exaggerated choir-boy voice.

It felt very attention-seeking and performative. I mentioned it to the friend afterwards and interestingly... she had noticed exactly the same thing.

We're going out tomorrow with two other people, so I'm now slightly dreading him doing something similarly attention-seeking.

I don't actually want to have a big confrontation with him. I'm more inclined to just stop inviting him to my home and keep things to meeting socially. But I'm annoyed enough that part of me wants to tell him that I found the behaviour rude and inconsiderate.

Would this annoy you - or am I massively overreacting? Yes, I realise the leftovers/plate thing sounds ridiculously minor written down. It's more the overall pattern that is getting to me. There are many more examples - but if I were to list them all, I'd be here forever.

OP posts:
whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 20:31

seahorsessky · 17/09/2026 20:05

None of the things on their own sound bad, weird maybe, though in long friendships, weird things can happen because they've been accepted so long. But it's the fact they're all happening and clearly he's changed, from what you said. He must be a good friend (to be the only one there on your birthday) so find out why he has changed. Ill? Stress? Using something?

Yes. True. As I said in my OP - there are many more examples, but if I were to list them all, the post would be a novel!

He's somewhat local to me - hence why he came over for my birthday - and someone I used to live with in halls many many years ago. But the behaviour has become unhinged - and a number of people have pointed it out. He insists nothing has changed, but who knows.

Yes, a few people have mentioned using something/drugs in this thread. Doubt it - but you never know.

Thank you for your comment. :)

OP posts:
seahorsessky · 17/09/2026 20:05

None of the things on their own sound bad, weird maybe, though in long friendships, weird things can happen because they've been accepted so long. But it's the fact they're all happening and clearly he's changed, from what you said. He must be a good friend (to be the only one there on your birthday) so find out why he has changed. Ill? Stress? Using something?

whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 20:01

MyOliveStork · 17/09/2026 18:45

How old is he?
sounds very immature behaviour

He's 45!

OP posts:
whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 20:00

Fifiesta · 17/09/2026 18:55

Perhaps your friendship has just had its time?
He seems very strange, I’m assuming it wasn’t so apparent before…

Yes, I think this is what it is. It was all soooo weird. He's 45 years old, mind you. I've known him 13 years.

OP posts:
SayDoWhatNow · 17/09/2026 19:27

Yikes, very weird indeed.

Could it be some icky fetish he has going? Or is he particularly paranoid and wanted to be sure it wasn't poisoned?

Either way, very odd and I would feel quite uncomfortable with it!

Chilly80 · 17/09/2026 19:17

Sounds like he could have an eating disorder or be on a diet

Fifiesta · 17/09/2026 18:55

Perhaps your friendship has just had its time?
He seems very strange, I’m assuming it wasn’t so apparent before…

TishToshByGosh · 17/09/2026 18:52

It sounds to me as though he's eccentric - simple as that.

He doesn't sound especially performative, as this is behaviour he is exhibiting one-to-one - you haven't said he's all over social media doing 'I'm crazy, me!' posts about his exploits.

It's up to you whether you want to tolerate his behaviour - you shouldn't feel under any obligation to host him, your boundaries are yours to draw.

If he's generally a good friend, a kind, decent person who is there for you, personally I would tolerate some odd behaviour, but it's for you to judge whether the friendship is worth it.

bt1234 · 17/09/2026 18:48

Omg he sounds like someone I went on a few dates with years ago
He took me to the theatre and he started shouting things out (Like you'd do at Rocky Horror but it was not Rocky Horror!). He did various other things like the motorbike noises. I wonder if it's the same man??
I presumed it was caused by extreme social anxiety/ND

springintospring26 · 17/09/2026 18:45

whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 17:49

It wasn't really about the 'choice' of meal that bothered me. I've hosted people plenty of times where I've already started cooking etc... (the only thing I need to know in advance is of any allergies). It's not that deep.

It was his behaviour about what happened afterwards that I found so odd. He insisted on me not plating him up anything - to the point where it got awkward given how much he was resisting.

Then the fact that he ate from my plate - and left the plate and cutlery there for me to literally pick up after him as he left.

I get it now. I really feel
for you and wouldn’t wish to start diagnosing him. However he’s an absolutely weirdo and I’d not want to be alone with him if I were you. Very strange, very controlling and very rude

MyOliveStork · 17/09/2026 18:45

How old is he?
sounds very immature behaviour

persephoneee · 17/09/2026 18:43

He is probably in the club of ND people that are all around us every day, probably including ourselves too.

HollyhocksandPeons · 17/09/2026 18:41

whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 18:23

Exactly. But given how agitated he got about it - I was genuinely freaked out.

Normally, I wouldn't give a fuck. I'm a host, I'm eating... you're all getting a plate - and then some. (It's also a 'thing' in my culture!) No one leaves hungry. Everyone gets enough food to last them for days! But his behaviour seemed really off - like deranged/weird/bizarre. Never really seen anything like it.

So you proceeded eating on your own?

MsPrufrockk · 17/09/2026 18:39

whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 18:23

Exactly. But given how agitated he got about it - I was genuinely freaked out.

Normally, I wouldn't give a fuck. I'm a host, I'm eating... you're all getting a plate - and then some. (It's also a 'thing' in my culture!) No one leaves hungry. Everyone gets enough food to last them for days! But his behaviour seemed really off - like deranged/weird/bizarre. Never really seen anything like it.

If it was just the two of you at your house on your birthday, I'd assume you're really close friends?

So I'm struggling to understand why you just accepted this behaviour without saying anything or putting your foot down?

PussInBin20 · 17/09/2026 18:27

Was he on drugs? Sounds like a right nutter.

BMW58 · 17/09/2026 18:27

Yeah he's weird as fuck!

I'd have just said WTF why are you being so odd?

whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 18:26

honeylulu · 17/09/2026 18:19

Yes that's so weird. He would have been out of luck with me, I always scoff everything in my plate and anyone who tries to grab some when I'm eating is at risk of being stabbed with a fork.

But eeewww, hovering over you grabbing your food and then eating leftovers with used cutlery yet having insisted he didn't want a plate of his own. Is it some strange misguided politeness do you think? Where he doesn't want you to serve him? Or is he one of those people who's always trying to lose weight but thinks calories from leftovers and nicked food doesn't count (hello mother!)

Leaving the plate is less bothersome. I wouldn't expect a guest to clear up though it's nice if they offer.

The singing and sound effects just sounds annoying. He probably thinks he's hilarious.

I purposely didn't eat my food because I knew he was just wanting it. I just nibbled away - and then he went for it. There was literally no other way to get him to eat. He said over and over and over again - to the point of getting agitated about it - that he wanted no food. I thought it could be because he filled up on all the starters I had made... but nope. He still ate from my plate... despite me cooking more than enough food for both - and then some!!!

OP posts:
whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 18:23

HollyhocksandPeons · 17/09/2026 18:19

Normal thing to do is to plonk a plate in front of him. And let him eat or leave it. When I host, I would not dream of sitting and eating if a guest does not have a plate with the same food in front of them. It is then up to them if they eat or push the food around the plate, but I can't stuff my face in front of a guest with no plate in front of him.

Exactly. But given how agitated he got about it - I was genuinely freaked out.

Normally, I wouldn't give a fuck. I'm a host, I'm eating... you're all getting a plate - and then some. (It's also a 'thing' in my culture!) No one leaves hungry. Everyone gets enough food to last them for days! But his behaviour seemed really off - like deranged/weird/bizarre. Never really seen anything like it.

OP posts:
honeylulu · 17/09/2026 18:19

Yes that's so weird. He would have been out of luck with me, I always scoff everything in my plate and anyone who tries to grab some when I'm eating is at risk of being stabbed with a fork.

But eeewww, hovering over you grabbing your food and then eating leftovers with used cutlery yet having insisted he didn't want a plate of his own. Is it some strange misguided politeness do you think? Where he doesn't want you to serve him? Or is he one of those people who's always trying to lose weight but thinks calories from leftovers and nicked food doesn't count (hello mother!)

Leaving the plate is less bothersome. I wouldn't expect a guest to clear up though it's nice if they offer.

The singing and sound effects just sounds annoying. He probably thinks he's hilarious.

HollyhocksandPeons · 17/09/2026 18:19

whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 17:58

He didn't want a plate. At all. He had already had all the starters that were laid out before he got there. When I insisted on plating him up - since he was coming over for dinner - he got increasingly agitated about it... to the point where it was so bizarre.

When he ended up eating from my plate... and I insisted again... the same thing happened.

Normal thing to do is to plonk a plate in front of him. And let him eat or leave it. When I host, I would not dream of sitting and eating if a guest does not have a plate with the same food in front of them. It is then up to them if they eat or push the food around the plate, but I can't stuff my face in front of a guest with no plate in front of him.

whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 17:59

EmeraldShamrock000 · 17/09/2026 17:58

I would have made two portions rather than one, someone waiting in my plate would freak me out.
He hasn’t much self control with his outbursts. He could have been stoned or have an impulse control problem, you’ve got the ick, the friendship is over.

I did exactly that. I made enough for 4 - and there were 2 of us.

OP posts:
whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 17:58

HollyhocksandPeons · 17/09/2026 17:55

So you started earing your meal - what did you put on his plate? Nothing? No plate? Thiis is so weird. And not because of him.

He didn't want a plate. At all. He had already had all the starters that were laid out before he got there. When I insisted on plating him up - since he was coming over for dinner - he got increasingly agitated about it... to the point where it was so bizarre.

When he ended up eating from my plate... and I insisted again... the same thing happened.

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock000 · 17/09/2026 17:58

whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 17:35

Oh no, it wasn't that. I had plenty of food/snacks laid out already - but I asked him what MEAL he wanted, since I was cooking. (Which was why he came over... since I said I was cooking). I think that's also my gripe, because I'm always hosting/cooking/baking etc... and go to a lot of effort. (Not just yesterday, but always). I wouldn't invite someone over... and them have them watch me eat. LOL!

I did indeed naturally offer to make more of what I was cooking, but he said 'no'. He said to make one portion for me - and he'd eat whatever I didn't. Hence the bizarreness.

Edited

I would have made two portions rather than one, someone waiting in my plate would freak me out.
He hasn’t much self control with his outbursts. He could have been stoned or have an impulse control problem, you’ve got the ick, the friendship is over.

HollyhocksandPeons · 17/09/2026 17:55

So you started earing your meal - what did you put on his plate? Nothing? No plate? Thiis is so weird. And not because of him.

HopeSpringingHigh · 17/09/2026 17:54

whendovescry26 · 17/09/2026 17:50

He insisted on me not plating him up anything - to the point where it got awkward given how much he was resisting. I'm aware that it's hard to articulate to those not in the room, but it was just so weird.

I suppose what I mean is . From the get go. Rather than you asking him whst he wants . What about what you want? It was your birthday. Perhaps in future be less open and accommodating with people. Because now it seems you're annoyed but Perhaps you were too nice in the first place ?
Its very odd behaviour on his part- almost quite passive aggressive. He used your used cutlery?