Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think cats are difficult pets if you hate uncertainty?

38 replies

dancinginthedaylight · 16/09/2026 13:22

Our beloved family cat has gone missing again. He's terrible for this- in summer he disappeared for 3 whole days, it's only 2 this time but we've been out shaking treat bags, calling him, posted on FB local group etc. It's the not knowing that makes me so nervous every time. At the same time, I don't believe in locking a cat in the house just so it's safe as it's a bit unnatural. We all love having a cat so much, but AIBU to think that if you handle uncertainty not well they're a difficult pet to have?

OP posts:
wiredandtired · 16/09/2026 13:25

Can't you get trackers etc these days?

But yes I agree, it's tough when they go missing for days.

dancinginthedaylight · 16/09/2026 13:27

wiredandtired · 16/09/2026 13:25

Can't you get trackers etc these days?

But yes I agree, it's tough when they go missing for days.

Yes absolutely, and I do wish I bought one! It's hard though as our cat hates having a collar etc, I tried a simple collar with his name on and he scratched it off within a few days.

If he does return, and I so so hope so, then I think I might have to get a tracker.

OP posts:
AmIReallyTheGrownup · 16/09/2026 13:30

Our village WhatsApp group is one long “Socks has gone missing, can you check your sheds and garages” then Socks reappears 48 hours later.

Apart from finding it irritating to have owners constantly beseeching others to go out of their way to locate their lost cats, I can’t recall a single cat actually going missing including one who decided to relocate himself to their old home in the next town & was found 6 weeks later.

dancinginthedaylight · 16/09/2026 13:33

AmIReallyTheGrownup · 16/09/2026 13:30

Our village WhatsApp group is one long “Socks has gone missing, can you check your sheds and garages” then Socks reappears 48 hours later.

Apart from finding it irritating to have owners constantly beseeching others to go out of their way to locate their lost cats, I can’t recall a single cat actually going missing including one who decided to relocate himself to their old home in the next town & was found 6 weeks later.

Well, I don't think it's too much to ask to check sheds and garages! I would be happy to do so, it's the neighbourly thing to do

OP posts:
beaglescurleduplikebagels · 16/09/2026 13:33

It is hard, ours is a bit of a wanderer and I always hate it when he doesn’t come in at his normal times.

If you do use a tracker please be careful as collars are a strangulation risk 😩

dancinginthedaylight · 16/09/2026 13:34

beaglescurleduplikebagels · 16/09/2026 13:33

It is hard, ours is a bit of a wanderer and I always hate it when he doesn’t come in at his normal times.

If you do use a tracker please be careful as collars are a strangulation risk 😩

Yes exactly!! And I feel it's so controlling. Our cat has now been missing since Monday at 9am and it's been raining really hard, so I am getting really nervous.

OP posts:
pinneddownbytabbies · 16/09/2026 13:39

I'm not a fan of collars on cats. One of our fosters still has an issue with a nasty injury he got from a collar three years ago. He'd somehow managed to get his front leg through the collar, and rubbed a part of his leg absolutely raw down to the flesh. It was horribly infected, and is still iffy three years later. The fur has never grown back. He had gone awol and if he hadn't been found in time, the infection would have killed him.

Lilyhatesjaz · 16/09/2026 13:44

We did once accidentally shut next doors cat in our garage. Fortunately only over night but I would happily check my garage and shed if a local cat went missing.

largeprintagathachristie · 16/09/2026 13:44

A strong agree from me.
I adopted a stray (he’d been apparently living on his wits for a year - when the owners were traced via his chip they didn’t want him back (!).

So now I have this lovely tabby boy, who clearly loves being “home” but is often out for long periods of time doing god knows what. Overall I spent £67 on collars and bar code “find your cat” schemes for the collars. The cat currently has zero collars - he just comes back without them. The longest one lasted a week. So a tracking device doesn’t seem sensible.

The cat is loving his life. My nerves are often shredded, though. I just tell myself he’s better off than completely unloved and on his own.

BurntBroccoli · 16/09/2026 14:00

dancinginthedaylight · 16/09/2026 13:34

Yes exactly!! And I feel it's so controlling. Our cat has now been missing since Monday at 9am and it's been raining really hard, so I am getting really nervous.

I wouldn’t worry about the rain, cats have their go to places in bad weather.

Hope he’s back soon.

dancinginthedaylight · 16/09/2026 14:03

largeprintagathachristie · 16/09/2026 13:44

A strong agree from me.
I adopted a stray (he’d been apparently living on his wits for a year - when the owners were traced via his chip they didn’t want him back (!).

So now I have this lovely tabby boy, who clearly loves being “home” but is often out for long periods of time doing god knows what. Overall I spent £67 on collars and bar code “find your cat” schemes for the collars. The cat currently has zero collars - he just comes back without them. The longest one lasted a week. So a tracking device doesn’t seem sensible.

The cat is loving his life. My nerves are often shredded, though. I just tell myself he’s better off than completely unloved and on his own.

He lived by himself on the streets for a year?! Gosh cats are resilient aren't they!

Wow a week, so glad he came home in the end. I'm hoping ours will too!

OP posts:
NeverLookInTheMirror · 16/09/2026 14:09

Agreed.

TBH I think it’s generally a case of when something is going to happen to them rather than if.

Obviously there are cats which live into old age, and my last two both did, but when you consider that the average age of a cat is something like 8 years it’s evident that more come to harm young than don’t.

MaryMayMiss · 16/09/2026 14:33

Get a GPS tracking collar, we have tried many of them and have found Tractive to be the most reliable. Gives you peace of mind.

CatsRuleMyLife · 16/09/2026 14:47

Can you cat proof your garden? I'm going to do that when I move (can't with current garden) to reduce my worry. I hate not knowing where mine are although most of the time they're just fast asleep under the thick garden bushes.

EmmaB1309 · 16/09/2026 14:47

Yes I agree but a tracker is an excellent solution! If your cat will wear a collar that is. I know not all will.

TheGoodOnesAreAllGone · 16/09/2026 14:54

I think it depends on the temperament of the cat and how long you've had them.
My 2 seem to love being at home, they don't tend to be out more than a few hours at a time max. We feed them at set times so they tend to come back for that if they're out.
My tortoiseshell is female and won't go in other people's houses, doesn't go far from home at all. She was 10 months when we adopted her and she's 6 now.
The orange one on the other hand frequently visits neighbours and I know some of them feed him. He's very active and inquisitive but knows where his home is. We adopted him when he was 5 months old, he's nearly 5 now.
I do think adopting younger cats makes a difference as they probably don't remember life as a stray so are much more settled.
Mine don't have collars either and I wouldn't introduce them at this age as they wouldn't tolerate it.

scalt · 16/09/2026 15:03

We got cat-proof fencing from Katzecure, which takes the form of horizontal poles along the top of the fence which rotate freely, so the cat cannot climb over. It was expensive, but it's kept him in for five years. We did this after he had been injured by a car (he did recover with treatment, a neighbour found him, and called the number on his collar, so it saved him).

I expect the cat haterz will soon be along to tell you that cats are feral beasts which murder birds and shit in other people's gardens, that they should be licenced, kept indoors at all times, and that they are a menace.

HorseandHeron · 16/09/2026 15:08

pinneddownbytabbies · 16/09/2026 13:39

I'm not a fan of collars on cats. One of our fosters still has an issue with a nasty injury he got from a collar three years ago. He'd somehow managed to get his front leg through the collar, and rubbed a part of his leg absolutely raw down to the flesh. It was horribly infected, and is still iffy three years later. The fur has never grown back. He had gone awol and if he hadn't been found in time, the infection would have killed him.

Many collars now have a snap mechanism that releases them if they are under strain. Our rescue cat got through three collars in his first week, then settled down and has kept his collar on for months, but if it caught on something it would ping open before it could trap him in any way.

BillyDidIt · 16/09/2026 15:14

Cats going missing would stress me out.

I'd never thought of them as a worry as in my experience mine are so ridiculously predictable it's almost annoying! None of them have ever gone missing except once but I could hear him somewhere and he was locked in a neighbour's garage.

I hope yours comes home asap.

OnTheTop · 16/09/2026 15:17

We have car proofed our back garden for this exact reason. It’s so stressful when they wander and we’ve lost a cat on the road 😢

I hope your cat comes home soon.

coldcalling · 16/09/2026 15:21

scalt · 16/09/2026 15:03

We got cat-proof fencing from Katzecure, which takes the form of horizontal poles along the top of the fence which rotate freely, so the cat cannot climb over. It was expensive, but it's kept him in for five years. We did this after he had been injured by a car (he did recover with treatment, a neighbour found him, and called the number on his collar, so it saved him).

I expect the cat haterz will soon be along to tell you that cats are feral beasts which murder birds and shit in other people's gardens, that they should be licenced, kept indoors at all times, and that they are a menace.

They are a bit of a menace to be fair 😁

Cat-proofing sounds like a good solution. Did your cat take long to get used to it?

dancinginthedaylight · 16/09/2026 15:27

Thank you all so much for your replies! Thing is , our cat is an absolute outdoor lover and very brazen. He constantly brings mice home and he has stayed out long before, he's very adventurous. I do hope he comes home soon. He's perfect as he is but ideally I'd love it if he was more of a homebody- like some of you write up thread, your cats rarely go out, I can't even imagine that (I'd love it though!)

OP posts:
dancinginthedaylight · 16/09/2026 15:33

coldcalling · 16/09/2026 15:21

They are a bit of a menace to be fair 😁

Cat-proofing sounds like a good solution. Did your cat take long to get used to it?

We can't really cat proof our garden due to the layout and nature of it (too difficult to explain haha)

OP posts:
amigafan2003 · 16/09/2026 16:36

We built a catio and installed some aerial walkways that span out into the garden through the trees. We also have leads and take them for walks.

Cats shouldn't be outside due to the impact they have on the local wildlife, unless they are farm cats used specifically for rodent control.

pinneddownbytabbies · 17/09/2026 10:29

HorseandHeron · 16/09/2026 15:08

Many collars now have a snap mechanism that releases them if they are under strain. Our rescue cat got through three collars in his first week, then settled down and has kept his collar on for months, but if it caught on something it would ping open before it could trap him in any way.

I still don't like them though. Whoever had put the collar on him had used a basic one. When they come to me they get microchipped and the collar goes in the bin.

It is amazing just how many people still don't microchip their cats. None of the last 5 had been done.