Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this scapegoating?

16 replies

loobydoob · 15/09/2026 14:12

There was a big family falling-out about 18 months ago involving one of my sisters and her partner. I don't want to go into every detail because it would be enormous, but there was behaviour from both of them that I found really hurtful and unacceptable. My sister eventually blocked me.

Since then, what has driven me slightly insane is that my parents seem almost pathologically unable to recognise that my sister has any agency in the situation. Everything somehow comes back to what I should do. Why don't I reach out? Why can't I make things easier? Why can't I think about how everyone else feels? Except I'm literally blocked.

I'm now completely excluded from wider family things. My sister can choose not to speak to me indefinitely and that is apparently just an unfortunate fact everyone has to work around. My reaction to being treated like that, however, is endlessly examined.

I'm also about to give birth. After 18 months I've basically reached the point where I've said ok, nobody needs to reconcile. If my sister wants contact, she has my number. When I told my parents I was pregnant I asked them not to tell my siblings but she did anyway.

I've now asked them not to give information/photos/details about my pregnancy and birth to my sisters. They haven't contacted me once throughout the pregnancy. I don't think they're automatically entitled to this infornatiojn when they don't want a relationship.

My mum has basically said she can't do that.

Every time I try to explain this, Mum either changes the subject and nutters something about how she has a onkno name and then eventually she said "youre so difficult i give up.” She hasn't spoken to me since.

I've spent years thinking her behaviour towards me was a communication problem. If I could explain myself calmly enough, clearly enough, fairly enough, surely she'd eventually understand what I was saying.

I'm starting to wonder whether she understands perfectly well but simply cannot tolerate anything that leaves my sister responsible for her own choices. Somehow my sister's discomfort always has to be prevented, even when preventing it means overriding me.

I'm weeks away from giving birth and I'm exhausted by it. I don't even particularly need Mum to agree with my entire interpretation of the family fallout. I just want her to recognise that I'm allowed some very basic boundaries around myself.

Has anyone had this with a parent? Did they ever reflect? What was your approach?

OP posts:
Error404FucksNotFound · 15/09/2026 14:14

Sounds like your sister is the golden child

It may be that you end up having to reduce the amount you share with your parents if they are adamant they arent going to respect your wishes.

hotmumshit · 15/09/2026 14:17

Kindly girl, it sounds like theyve chosen their side and you are now on your own.

Accept things and it will get easier eventually x

GiveOverRover · 15/09/2026 14:20

I just want her to recognise that I'm allowed some very basic boundaries around myself.

You can want this, but she's proved she's not able to meet you where you are. So you need to do what you need to do, and adjust your expectations of whoever you need to. Boundaries are fine, they're around what you will and won't do, not what you want from other people.

So a good one on this would be, I'm not going to be sharing photos and information of the baby because I'm not comfortable with it being sent on to wider family. Not, you're not allowed to send these photos on to other people.

FromaBubblegumTree · 15/09/2026 14:36

...something about how she has a onkno name and then eventually she said...

What does this mean please?

CarbootJunction · 15/09/2026 14:43

When I went into labour with my second child, I begged DH in the car not to let my DM know anything, whatever happened.
I was in a very similar situation as you, OP, and I walked away from them all.
Five years later, (D)sis had stolen all of DM's money, and I was suddenly the golden child at last.

loobydoob · 15/09/2026 14:53

FromaBubblegumTree · 15/09/2026 14:36

...something about how she has a onkno name and then eventually she said...

What does this mean please?

Apologies - swollen fingers! She mutters something about how my sister has a right to know.

OP posts:
Firstruleofsoupover · 15/09/2026 15:05

I'm gonna guess you are the non-scary one out of your siblings. Some parents will do all they can, including twisting the truth, if it means they don't have to go up against a dramatic strong-willed child with a temper, even if that child is in the wrong and one of their siblings is suffering. Sympathies to you in this predicament.

bananaobama · 15/09/2026 15:09

It’s really hard to comment as there are two sides to every story and it’s obvious that your parents believe you are in the wrong

l

ColdAsAWitches · 15/09/2026 15:09

I can't tell how many people you've fallen out with because you keep saying sister/sisters and she/they. However, I think it's a bit unfair for you to tell your mother that she can't talk about her grandkids to her other children. You're all part of her family. You can't dictate what she says to people.

Savvysix1984 · 15/09/2026 15:14

I don’t really understand who fell out and why. Your sister and her partner or your partner?
either way you can’t dictate who someone talks to and what they talk about. It’s just not realistic to expect that in everyday conversation and you’re putting your mum in a terrible position (well you both are) .

BoundaryGirl3939 · 15/09/2026 15:16

It seems like scapegoating. You may be the emotional dumping ground and be expected to absorb all the dysfunction. It's toxic. Step away from it would be my advice.

SpottyPyjama · 15/09/2026 15:18

Asking your mother to hide the fact that she is having a grandchild from her own children is too controlling. A baby arrives into a family, not just the two parents, even if that family isn’t functioning well.

Without more information it is impossible to judge whether you are being scapegoated or not. We don’t know what happened.

purpleme12 · 15/09/2026 15:23

I can't tell if you're the scapegoat or not to be honest from this. I think that would depend entirely on what happened.

But I agree with someone above I'm not sure you can tell your mum not to talk about you with other members of the family. I don't think you can expect her to never talk about you to them if she wants to.

loobydoob · 15/09/2026 15:32

Just to clarify because I think I've worded that badly: I'm not asking my mum never to mention me or pretend she doesn't have another grandchild. I'm asking her not to act as a conduit for private information, photographs or details about my pregnancy, labour/birth that I haven't chosen to share with people I'm estranged from

OP posts:
ColdAsAWitches · 15/09/2026 15:51

loobydoob · 15/09/2026 15:32

Just to clarify because I think I've worded that badly: I'm not asking my mum never to mention me or pretend she doesn't have another grandchild. I'm asking her not to act as a conduit for private information, photographs or details about my pregnancy, labour/birth that I haven't chosen to share with people I'm estranged from

I still say no. You're estranged from however many family members. Your mother isn't. She can talk to who she wants, about what she wants. By telling her what she can talk about with other people you're trying to force her to pick your side, and that's not fair. It's up to you to decide what you want to share with her.

Grumpyoldcat · 15/09/2026 16:01

I think you are putting your mum in a difficult situation. Asking her not to share or tell them anything is unreasonable and unsustainable. Just try to get on with your life and new baby when it arrives without caring who is seeing what photos or info.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread