Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to complain after NHS dentist did filling for my 16 year-old?

238 replies

Claryyy · 11/09/2026 23:49

Looking for some advice/perspective on this as I’m absolutely fuming and not sure where I stand legally or ethically with our NHS dentist.

My 16yo DS went for a standard routine check-up on his own today. He’s always had glowing reports and zero issues so I didn't think twice about letting him go alone (his first time alone).

He came home and told me that the dentist found a hole in his back molar. Because they had a free slot right after his appointment, she went straight ahead and did a silver filling there and then. DS said he felt completely pressured into it and didn't really feel like he could say no.

I’m upset about this on so many levels:

  • Lack of consent/consultation: Should the dentist not have spoken to me first? I know he's not a baby anymore, but to go straight from a routine check-up into a procedure without giving him time to process it or talk to a parent feels wrong.
  • Amalgam filling: They gave him a silver amalgam filling. If I’d known, I would have 100% paid privately for a white composite filling. It looks so dark and obvious in his mouth and he's self-conscious about it.
  • Dubious need: Given his track record, I’m genuinely dubious he even needed it done urgently.
  • The experience: He was completely unprepared. He’s never had a local anaesthetic injection in his mouth before and he said the whole thing was terrifying and hurt a fair bit.

AIBU to be furious about how this was handled? Can an NHS dentist just carry out procedures on a teenager without discussing options with a parent or explaining material choices?

Has anyone dealt with something similar, and is it worth making a formal complaint to the practice manager? Would you like help drafting a formal complaint letter to the practice manager once you see what the consensus is on your post?

OP posts:
EvieBB · 13/09/2026 04:58

localnotail · 12/09/2026 08:13

I would be annoyed about amalgam and insist on having it replaced as its toxic.

Its weird to have a filling while having a regular check up tbh. Normally its a separate appointment.

I agree. The only problem with getting it replaced is that that process can release even more mercury in to the body. A safer bet is using a biological dentist to perform this.....but that of course costs ££££
I would be incredibly annoyed with the original dentist! I don't think a child (under the age of 18) should have been given this procedure without first suggesting the child have conversation with their parent - who will no doubt be paying for it in the first place!!

Timeforachange26 · 13/09/2026 08:37

EvieBB · 13/09/2026 04:58

I agree. The only problem with getting it replaced is that that process can release even more mercury in to the body. A safer bet is using a biological dentist to perform this.....but that of course costs ££££
I would be incredibly annoyed with the original dentist! I don't think a child (under the age of 18) should have been given this procedure without first suggesting the child have conversation with their parent - who will no doubt be paying for it in the first place!!

I'm pretty sure it's free for the 16 year old so no the parent wouldn't be paying

And 16 is definitely the age that you can give consent for medical treatment

Timeforachange26 · 13/09/2026 08:53

ThatHangryRubyReader · 12/09/2026 08:34

white filling fine but silver?? I wouldn't be happy with that at all

Do the NHS even do white fillings?

AhBiscuits · 13/09/2026 08:59

Timeforachange26 · 13/09/2026 08:53

Do the NHS even do white fillings?

No, your dentist will give you the option to pay for one though. I had one and it was about £100. Well worth it IMO. I hate the look of the silver ones.

EvieBB · 13/09/2026 12:13

WecanbeheroeslikeBowie · 12/09/2026 08:12

FFS, I'd love to have dental treatment from anywhere but can't afford it.

I'm sorry to hear that....everything has become so expensive and it's a hideous situation for many......but that still doens't mean that it was right to pressurise a mere 16 yr old in to having treatment that their parent was paying for if parent was not happy with a silver filling. I personally think it's out of order for the dentist to have done this

Timeforachange26 · 13/09/2026 12:32

EvieBB · 13/09/2026 12:13

I'm sorry to hear that....everything has become so expensive and it's a hideous situation for many......but that still doens't mean that it was right to pressurise a mere 16 yr old in to having treatment that their parent was paying for if parent was not happy with a silver filling. I personally think it's out of order for the dentist to have done this

Why would parent be paying for free treatment?

EvieBB · 14/09/2026 10:52

Timeforachange26 · 13/09/2026 12:32

Why would parent be paying for free treatment?

Is it free? Even so, I'd be annoyed if the dentist went ahead giving a mercury filling to any child of mine under the age of 16 😡

EvieBB · 14/09/2026 10:52

EvieBB · 14/09/2026 10:52

Is it free? Even so, I'd be annoyed if the dentist went ahead giving a mercury filling to any child of mine under the age of 16 😡

I mean 18!

Timeforachange26 · 14/09/2026 11:21

EvieBB · 14/09/2026 10:52

Is it free? Even so, I'd be annoyed if the dentist went ahead giving a mercury filling to any child of mine under the age of 16 😡

Of course it's free for a 16 year old.and it's his teeth so it's up to him to say if he doesn't want it. If he's unable to do this then may e he should be accompanied ( or taught to say something)

EvieBB · 16/09/2026 13:13

Timeforachange26 · 14/09/2026 11:21

Of course it's free for a 16 year old.and it's his teeth so it's up to him to say if he doesn't want it. If he's unable to do this then may e he should be accompanied ( or taught to say something)

You cannot preempt ever single situation they are going to be in and prepare them for every single eventuality/conversation. That isn't reasonable or possible. I can still be highly highly pissed off that a dentist went ahead and gave my under 18 child a mercury filling. I'd be effing fuming!

BruFord · 16/09/2026 14:30

EvieBB · 16/09/2026 13:13

You cannot preempt ever single situation they are going to be in and prepare them for every single eventuality/conversation. That isn't reasonable or possible. I can still be highly highly pissed off that a dentist went ahead and gave my under 18 child a mercury filling. I'd be effing fuming!

@EvieBB I agree that you can't preempt every situation and that's why, if you're not confident that your teenager is ready to make decisions about treatment, you accompany them to the appointment. I went to the dentist with my DS (17) over the summer for that reason.

Naunet · 16/09/2026 16:16

I was living alone and paying rent and bills at 16! Stop babying him, you're not helping to prepare him for life.

BruFord · 16/09/2026 17:41

Naunet · 16/09/2026 16:16

I was living alone and paying rent and bills at 16! Stop babying him, you're not helping to prepare him for life.

@Naunet Every teenager is different and some take a little longer to mature. My DS is nearly 18 now and far more mature than he was a year ago, he's getting there. DD (21) goes to all her appointments alone.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page