Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To say my DS cant keep missing school because the school “cant cope”??

660 replies

Jacobator · 11/09/2026 13:19

Sorry this is long and probably doesnt make much sense but i am so fed up and dont really know if im being unreasonable anymore.

I have 2 boys, 12 and 9, both have additional needs although they are very different. DS2 has always been harder in school but usually he manages and we have never had anything like this before. Since going back this September he has apparently been having what they call explosive behaviour and he has now been sent home several times. One day they rang me before lunch and said i needed to collect him because he wasnt able to calm down and they didnt have the staff to keep him safe.

I did collect him because what else can i do, but then its happening again and again. Yesterday they rang and said basically they cant meet his needs at the moment. I said well what does that actually mean because he is supposed to be in school and not sitting at home with me because you dont have enough staff.

They keep saying they are not excluding him and that its a “temporary arrangement” while they look at what support he needs. Sorry but if my child is being told to stay at home because school cant cope with him, what exactly do they think an exclusion is??

I have asked about his support plan and whether they have actually done everything that is in it and i get lots of meetings and people saying they are concerned but nobody seems to actually have an answer. I dont want to keep having arguments with the school because obviously DS has to go there and i dont want things getting worse for him, but i also cant just accept him being kept home every time he has a meltdown.

DH thinks im making this harder than it needs to be and says we should look at specialist provision. I know he might be right but i dont want DS2 being put somewhere just because his current school doesnt want the bother. His brother is at the same school and they are very close, and DS2 already feels different enough without being taken away and told he needs a special school.

And before anyone says we should just pay for extra help, we actually do. Between therapy, assessments, things for school, transport and other bits we are spending over £2,000 a month at the moment. Yes i know thats a lot. We arent sitting on a pile of money, it is coming out of our savings and some of the things are because we have been told to get them privately because waiting lists are ridiculous. Im not saying that means the school owes us anything, just that its frustrating to constantly be told to get more support when we are already trying everything we can.

I am not pretending DS is easy. He can be very difficult when he is overwhelmed and i know the other children need to be safe too. But surely the answer cant just be send him home until he behaves normally? He cant learn how to manage school if he isnt actually allowed to be at school.

DH says im refusing to accept that he needs specialist help and maybe i am. I just feel like once we go down that road thats it, he gets labelled and everyone gives up trying to make mainstream work.

So AIBU to be pushing back on this and saying they cant keep sending him home because they “cant cope”? Or am i the one refusing to accept reality here?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Longtimelurker1980 · 12/09/2026 23:58

Jacobator · 11/09/2026 13:35

Thanks, yes he does have an EHCP. It is being followed in the sense that they say it is, although i am not convinced everything in it is actually happening all the time. There is meant to be support in class but its not a 1:1 as such and obviously when staff are dealing with other children things can change.

The meltdowns are mostly when he gets overwhelmed or something changes or he thinks something is unfair. He can shout and throw things and sometimes push things over, but he isnt going round attacking children. He does need help to calm down though and apparently that is the problem because they say they dont have the staff available to do it safely.

I dont want him to hurt anybody obviously, and if he was a danger to the other children then i wouldnt be saying just keep him there regardless. But i do think there is a difference between a child being unsafe and a school not having enough adults to support a child who is dysregulated.

Someone asked about attainment, he is actually doing ok academically considering everything. Hes not top of the class or anything but he is not unable to access the work either. His problems are much more around behaviour, communication and coping with the environment.

We have talked about a resource base before but there isnt one particularly close to us and i dont want him travelling for ages every day either. Also this is what i mean about everyone jumping straight to specialist. We havent even managed to get the current school to consistently provide what is in his EHCP and now we are apparently supposed to accept that mainstream isnt suitable.

As for refusing to pick him up, i honestly dont know if i have the nerve to do that. They make it sound like something awful will happen if i dont come and obviously when they ring you saying your child is distressed you arent exactly going to say no sorry he can stay there.

But i am starting to think maybe i have been too cooperative with them. I just dont want DS to end up being punished because adults cant agree what to do with him.

Addressing only the adults part, how many adults would it take to bring your child under control? And how many would you expect to be available to him and him only? Schools are massively underfunded and adults in rooms very low. In my class I have 7 children with SEN, one with an ECHP, a third very below in their learning. I have one TA in the morning but in the afternoon she is doing interventions. So it’s just me.

We just don’t have the money or adults available to have one or more adults free to deal with a child regularly getting violent. Where do you think these adults are coming from OP?

Arran2024 · 12/09/2026 23:50

cityliving99 · 12/09/2026 23:39

We advertised for 4 TA posts. We didn’t get a single application….

Then the LA needs to fund a specialist place. It is the LA's responsibility to provide the education in the ehc, not the school's.

roaringdragon · 12/09/2026 23:45

That is why it is important for the 1:1 to be detailed, specified and quantified in F of the EHCP. Then the LA has a duty to ensure it is provided and it can be enforced. When faced with enforcement action, LAs can pull their finger out and fund at a higher level, potentially a much higher level (e.g. one child I know had their TA in school funded at the level of the teaching MPS because that is what it took to fulfil their duty), and that attracts more candidates. Talking generally rather than about the OP’s case specifically, they can also fund a higher staffing ratio, again attracting applicants who may accept the role 2:1 but not 1:1. The LA can recruit directly, which for some schools attracts more applicants.

cityliving99 · 12/09/2026 23:39

Arran2024 · 12/09/2026 23:26

Home schooling means the LA doesn't have to provide any education. There IS a solution for this child somewhere, only the LA has to sort it out. It could be that the school needs more TA hours, more TA training, or the boy needs a different sort of provision, like in a unit. No parent in the UK is expected to have to home school a child.

We advertised for 4 TA posts. We didn’t get a single application….

Arran2024 · 12/09/2026 23:26

Home schooling means the LA doesn't have to provide any education. There IS a solution for this child somewhere, only the LA has to sort it out. It could be that the school needs more TA hours, more TA training, or the boy needs a different sort of provision, like in a unit. No parent in the UK is expected to have to home school a child.

roaringdragon · 12/09/2026 23:16

cityliving99 · 12/09/2026 23:12

But as you know the system isn’t working.

EHE wouldn’t suddenly make the system work better for the child, though. Quite the opposite.

cityliving99 · 12/09/2026 23:12

roaringdragon · 12/09/2026 22:58

The obvious thing would be to homeschool.

It wouldn’t be ‘the obvious thing’ for anyone who understood how the SEN system works.

But as you know the system isn’t working.

SALaw · 12/09/2026 23:11

Kirbert2 · 12/09/2026 19:12

Availability is sparse across most of the country. It's a well known issue.

He won't be on a waiting list because it will be the LA's responsibility to find him a specialist place if that is what he needs. They will expect evidence from the school that they can't meet his needs.

It is a long process, especially as LA's can be difficult and some parents have to go all the way to tribunal.

Edited

My point is that it’s a long process that the OP hasn’t begun yet. It’s not about availability (at least not at this stage), as the OP hasn’t accepted that a special education setting is needed.

roaringdragon · 12/09/2026 22:58

The obvious thing would be to homeschool.

It wouldn’t be ‘the obvious thing’ for anyone who understood how the SEN system works.

cityliving99 · 12/09/2026 22:47

DontBuyAnotherBook · 12/09/2026 22:38

Technically schools are babysitters as well. No I wouldn't be happy to see other children have their education disrupted but if this is the only education my son is getting then yes he would be staying at the school. How is being stuck at home waiting months or years for a specialist school going to help him?

If he is not learning anything, and is desperately unhappy why would you do this to him? He will throw this back at you when he is older.
The obvious thing would be to homeschool.
It would be easy because you would only have one child to deal with, not 30.

jo19 · 12/09/2026 22:40

His problems are much more around behaviour, communication and coping with the environment.

If he’s struggling with the environment then maybe mainstream isn’t the right fit for your son. He’s obviously unhappy, his classmates will be scared by these outbursts and the teaching staff will be exhausted trying to manage his behaviour, worried about the next trigger and the fact they are unable to properly teach 29 other children.
Inclusion in mainstream isn’t always the answer.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 12/09/2026 22:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Technically schools are babysitters as well. No I wouldn't be happy to see other children have their education disrupted but if this is the only education my son is getting then yes he would be staying at the school. How is being stuck at home waiting months or years for a specialist school going to help him?

croydon15 · 12/09/2026 22:25

OP can you meet the new teacher and try to diplomatically explain what the previous teacher was doing and how it worked, also explain at the school meeting that the new teacher style doesn't seem to suit your DS.
The school needs to provide the support that your DS needs but unfortunately the funds are not there to pay for 1:1 which is where the problem lies, sorry OP it's so difficult.

cityliving99 · 12/09/2026 22:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

dracn · 12/09/2026 22:10

So many of the country’s problems are summed up in some of the responses to this thread.

Everyone knows what they are “entitled to” and sod everyone else.

Cardisncocktails · 12/09/2026 21:51

Phineyj · 12/09/2026 19:04

How is it entitled to expect the school to deliver what's in the EHCP?

Clearly the EHCP is undeliverable by the school AT THIS POINT. They aren't saying they won't try, but they have to get resources to do so. Meanwhile the school also has an important responsibility for the safety and educational needs of the other children. They matter too.

Twittable · 12/09/2026 20:28

I think you need to get a meeting organised with the school (senco and teacher included) and discuss the situation as it stands and ask for their help. EHCPs are a legally binding document but schools are, in general, finding it hard to recruit suitable staff and many existing TAs are working with multiple EHCPs as well as a good chunk of SEN without EHCPs in a single class for a very low wage.

I am currently a TA but this will be my last year as I cannot afford to continue. Last year I was a sole TA in a class with more than 10 of the children on the SEN register. I struggled to fit in every intervention and therapy required but did the very best I could. This year we have less need within the class but the ones we do have are loud and violent. Again, I’m already running myself ragged trying to do all the interventions, support, therapeutic input and teaching lower ability groups maths. I’ve already been spoken to rudely by two separate parents who both assumed I spend my days photocopying or looking for lids for glue sticks and ignoring their children when actually their children kept me out of the classroom for most of the week between them due to needing help to redirect and calm after overwhelm multiple times. We have a lovely calm and quiet classroom with a softly spoken teacher, we are aware of triggers and try to keep everyone safe but these huge outbursts still happen.

It’s tough for everyone involved but open, honest communication with the school is key to better support.

Dimeto · 12/09/2026 20:24

“I havent actually been inside the new classroom properly. I have seen it from the doorway but thats about it. I might ask if i can have a look because maybe there is something obvious that none of us have thought about”

As a hearing aid wearer I am now well aware that different floor coverings make a huge difference to noise levels. Carpeted floors, soft fabrics, etc help to mute sounds whereas tiled floors can make sounds very harsh. Definitely worth checking!

rainbow9713 · 12/09/2026 20:23

Jacobator · 11/09/2026 13:35

Thanks, yes he does have an EHCP. It is being followed in the sense that they say it is, although i am not convinced everything in it is actually happening all the time. There is meant to be support in class but its not a 1:1 as such and obviously when staff are dealing with other children things can change.

The meltdowns are mostly when he gets overwhelmed or something changes or he thinks something is unfair. He can shout and throw things and sometimes push things over, but he isnt going round attacking children. He does need help to calm down though and apparently that is the problem because they say they dont have the staff available to do it safely.

I dont want him to hurt anybody obviously, and if he was a danger to the other children then i wouldnt be saying just keep him there regardless. But i do think there is a difference between a child being unsafe and a school not having enough adults to support a child who is dysregulated.

Someone asked about attainment, he is actually doing ok academically considering everything. Hes not top of the class or anything but he is not unable to access the work either. His problems are much more around behaviour, communication and coping with the environment.

We have talked about a resource base before but there isnt one particularly close to us and i dont want him travelling for ages every day either. Also this is what i mean about everyone jumping straight to specialist. We havent even managed to get the current school to consistently provide what is in his EHCP and now we are apparently supposed to accept that mainstream isnt suitable.

As for refusing to pick him up, i honestly dont know if i have the nerve to do that. They make it sound like something awful will happen if i dont come and obviously when they ring you saying your child is distressed you arent exactly going to say no sorry he can stay there.

But i am starting to think maybe i have been too cooperative with them. I just dont want DS to end up being punished because adults cant agree what to do with him.

I would advise that when they call you, you have it in writing from them (can be via email) the time they called, and why they needed you to collect him at this time.
It is really hard and I say this as a parent of an autistic child, who is academic but cannot access education currently......... she is 13 and was fine in primary school, but the environment of secondary school she cannot cope with.
So long story shirt if your son is struggling in the mainstream primary environment, I would guess that things will only get harder as he gets older. Now I am not a professional and I don't have a crystal ball to show yours and your sons future...... but if school are saying they cannot meet his needs I would not disregard specialist provision. I am actually fighting for it for my daughter now. There are specialist provisions that still offer academics such as GCSE, not a lot granted but they are out there.
The school needs to stop telling you to collect him and that they can't meet his needs, and go to the Local Authority and tell them, that even with the current EHCP they are unable to meet his needs.
I wish you all the best and I really do sympathise with you

DontBuyAnotherBook · 12/09/2026 19:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Actually it is the school's. They have to provide him with an education.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 12/09/2026 19:40

DontBuyAnotherBook · 12/09/2026 19:23

How can I take responsibility for my son's behaviour in school especially if that behaviour is due to being autistic? He is disabled.

Of course it is the old chestnut of it is bad parenting instead of autism.

Trillie · 12/09/2026 19:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Phineyj · 12/09/2026 19:26

roaringdragon · 12/09/2026 19:17

You can ask for a costed provision map.

That would be a good idea in this case. It might help show if anything was in place last year that's been removed.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 12/09/2026 19:23

GoldenSandy · 12/09/2026 14:54

Nobody is talking about stomping in puddles. We are talking about regular major disruption, explosive behaviour. Absolutely parents should take responsibility for the behaviour. Who else should?!

How can I take responsibility for my son's behaviour in school especially if that behaviour is due to being autistic? He is disabled.

roaringdragon · 12/09/2026 19:17

Phineyj · 12/09/2026 19:14

They will. Unfortunately it's between the school and the LA how much it is and how it's spent. Parents don't have a right to the information as far as I know.

You can ask for a costed provision map.