Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I want a relationship with my parents that doesn’t involve my sister - AIBU?

56 replies

Endofanerainourtime · 10/09/2026 14:04

I’m early 50s and have reached a point where I honestly don't know whether I'm being unreasonable, or whether I've just finally had enough.

I have an older sister also in her 50s who has had serious problems for many years, including a long history of drug addiction. At one point things were extremely bad and there were frightening incidents involving drugs, drug dealers, my parents' house being damaged, aggression towards my mum, rehab repeatedly failing, financial problems etc.
My parents have always been very involved in trying to help her. They are now in their early 80s and my sister lives with them and relies on them heavily financially/emotionally. They have always been very protective of her and tend to rescue her when things go wrong.

I have spent years being dragged into this. When my parents went away I was often expected to keep an eye on my sister. I've picked her up, searched for her, worried about her, lent her money when there were drug-related problems, had her at my house etc. My Mum also constantly talks about her when I speak to her and she rings them when we do have time together without her. There have been so many incidents over the years that I feel emotionally exhausted by it all. Recently something in me just seemed to switch off. When I hear about another problem with my sister, rather than feeling compassion, I feel numb and angry and think, here we go again.

She is also completely unable to take any criticism or challenge without going off the deep end. This has caused problems in multiple jobs and she has been through a number of them as a result. She can also be extremely nasty towards my mum when she is angry, but then will often retell what happened to my dad in a way that makes her the victim, and my dad tends to believe her version of events.

This is one of the things I find particularly difficult. I feel as though my mum gets the brunt of her behaviour, while my dad is then brought into it and ends up thinking my mum - or sometimes me - is the problem. I have spent years watching this dynamic play out and trying to stay out of it, but increasingly I feel completely exhausted by it.
The latest situation is that I told my parents that | want a relationship with them that doesn't revolve around my sister. I don't want to discuss her problems anymore. I don't want to be involved in monitoring her, rescuing her or being expected to accommodate everything around her.

also said that if she comes to my house and behaves badly or starts an argument, I will ask her to leave. I am not saying she can never come to my house. I am saying that I won't tolerate being treated badly in my own home.

My parents reacted very badly. They said I was being unreasonable, asked why I had "started all this now?” and repeatedly suggested I have counselling. My mum has become noticeably colder with me. My dad is also very angry and I've barely spoken to him.

The strange thing is that I don't actually want to fall out with my parents. They are old, I love them, and I don't want to waste whatever time we have left.
But I don't think I can go back to how things were before, where I felt I had to tread on eggshells around my sister and constantly manage everyone's feelings.

But I am struggling with the fact that my parents are colder with me and seem to think I've caused a family breakdown.

I'm particularly interested in whether people think I'm being unfair to my parents, given their age, and whether I should be making more effort to repair things or whether I should just allow everyone to be unhappy with me

OP posts:
BruFord · 10/09/2026 14:16

You've set your boundaries and all you can do is try to stick to them. You may not be entirely successful but do your best.

I completely agree that at their ages, you don't want to waste the remaining time with them talking about your sister, so don't allow this to turn into a rift. Ultimately, you do have the quiet power as @WildLeader says, they can't make you continue to rescue her. Bluntly, you may not be able to completely cut ties with her until your parents are no longer here, but you can start stepping back by changing the subject when they talk about her, decline to monitor her, etc.

Notquitethetruth · 10/09/2026 14:14

Absolutely not. You have been very tolerant and supportive of your sister and you have now, belatedly, put boundaries in place. Good for you.
You have told your parents how you feel and what for you is acceptable. If they can't accept it then that is on them. You should not have to make yourself miserable so they can be happy.
Their age is irrelevant. Hopefully your sister will step up and take care of them should they need it but I wouldn't be holding my breath for that to happen.

AttachmentFTW · 10/09/2026 14:14

Unfortunately your family have been caught in a tricky dynamic for years. You are finally rebelling against this way of being, because it's not working for you and probably never did.

You are completely right to assert boundaries and say what kind of relationship you do and don't want. It was unlikely that your parents were ever going to react well. Your compliance has been useful to them and they don't want to lose that. But it would come at a cost to you in terms of your emotional health.

Stand strong, hold the boundary (easier said than done). In all likelihood your parents will come to accept your position overtime but it might be rocky road to begin with.

*edited for spelling

PussInBin20 · 10/09/2026 14:13

Why do they think YOU are being unreasonable? Is it because you are their only support and they want to offload to you perhaps? If so I would tell them to get counselling. Why do they think you need it?

Surely having a relationship with your parents doesn’t mean you have to involve a sibling - that sounds normal to me (although I don’t have any siblings so maybe easier for me to say).

Perhaps they foresee that it is going to cause problems for them?

NancyThompson · 10/09/2026 14:09

You haven't been unfair to your parents, they've been extremely unfair to you.

WildLeader · 10/09/2026 14:08

This is dragging you down and they are enabling it. Stay firm and set your boundaries.

at the end of the day, they can’t cut you off because your sister won’t ever be in a position to support them, they need you (more than you need them…)

use this quiet power and make the choices you need to make.

you can’t help someone who doesn’t want to be helped.

Swipe left for the next trending thread