Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu feeling uneasy about men taking little girls to the toilet in the womens toilet?

514 replies

Fasdmama · Yesterday 10:57

I've seen this a few times and I dont know what is the right thing to do.
So the other week we were at the cinema. I took my daughter to the toilet and as I was waiting for her a man came out of a cubicle with a little girl and went to wash her hands.
It got me thinking.
I feel uncomfortable a man in the womens toilet. I understand how you'd potentially feel uncomfortable taking a daughter into the mens toilets.
And the only other option in this situation was the disabled toilet but morally thats wrong.

I dont know what I feel is right in this situation so wanted to know other people's opinions.
So yabu: its right for a man to take girl into female toilets
Yanbu: he should take her somewhere else...but where?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Crispsjamtarts · Yesterday 12:13

Why should a little girl go into the men's toilet. What woman would want that. I would prefer a dad to take his girls into the women's toilets and would get over myself.

Crow55 · Yesterday 12:13

stillhiding1990 · Yesterday 12:11

And that level of entitlement is a problem, it’s not a uni sex space.

But perfectly legal and perfectly ok for safeguarding to be a priority for the vast majority of women.

Frankly putting safeguarding second is the pinnacle of entitlement.

Tralalalala88 · Yesterday 12:12

YouHaveAnArse · Yesterday 12:10

I don't really feel that comfortable changing in a place that only has communal changing available with little boys running round whilst I'm entirely naked, no.

Right well then you need therapy if you think a 4 year old is some sort of threat or sexual deviant . I’ve never heard anything so ridiculous

Keeptoiletssafe · Yesterday 12:12

Dads shouldn’t be taking their daughters into the women’s toilet. This appears to be a ‘what about’ argument. There seems to be a series of arguments people are trying out at the moment.

Others include: what about male cleaners, what about mums bringing boys into the toilets.

Male cleaners are cleaning the toilets. They have provisions in place - outer washroom door propped open with a sign etc . It’s not a highly sought after job and we need clean toilets. It also has to be safe for the cleaners, and cleaning can be done at antisocial hours. Cleaners sometimes work in pairs with a man and a woman.

Mums bringing young sons into toilets is obviously not the same as an adult man. A judge said the same in a recent case.

Accessible toilets can be used for anyone who has need of them. I would try and avoid encouraging them for adult + child use. This is because they are mixed sex, private and sound resistant. Any mixed sex private design is less safe for a vulnerable occupant as my research into real life incidents shows. Accessible toilets should be monitored as much as possible. They are supposed to be in high traffic, visible areas so people notice who is going in and out and how long they have spent in there. They are supposed to have working and reachable alarms. If you do use one, and the cord has been tied up, please ensure you untie it so anyone on the floor can attempt to pull it.

Occasionally I come across an accessible design in single sex accommodation that has the floor-to-door gaps and space above the door. These are really useful as they provide non ambulant people the dignity and safety of being in single sex toilets too. Many wheelchair users can transfer by themselves, but if they did need assistance or had a fall, they are not easy places to be trapped in (and the floor can be left in a disgusting state).

Tip: in single sex accommodation you may notice one toilet will have a handrail and an opening outwards door. This is called an ‘ambulant’ toilet and can be easier to use when you have a child with you.

stillhiding1990 · Yesterday 12:12

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:10

I thought you were asking him to leave?

You talking to
me or
micespiders?

Random321 · Yesterday 12:11

stillhiding1990 · Yesterday 12:04

Women who have been raped don’t want to be vulnerable around unknown men . Women need single sex spaces. Women of certain religious beliefs don’t want to be sharing intimate spaces with a man. You can’t think of any risk?

From your viewpoint, everywhere is then a vulnerable place.

Religion shouldn't dictate toilet usage.
Religious believes should not come before a child.

stillhiding1990 · Yesterday 12:11

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:10

I thought you were asking him to leave?

Did you notice the name of the poster who originally said that and think that’s me?

Tralalalala88 · Yesterday 12:11

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:09

I still don’t understand why exposing a little girl to multiple men who are partially undressed, and peeing is less traumatic than an adult woman seeing a fully clothed dad helping his little girl? Please explain why you think the adult woman is at more risk of psychological harm than the small girl being taken into the men’s toilets?

Edited

And what about a man taking his daughter to swimming lessons in a facility where there are no family cubicles. What do you suggest they do then?

stillhiding1990 · Yesterday 12:11

Duckduckgander · Yesterday 12:10

If the man in question is taking his young daughter to the toilet. It tells you he prioritises his daughter's needs over some the preference of some woman who he's never clapped eyes on before.

And that level of entitlement is a problem, it’s not a uni sex space.

Legomania · Yesterday 12:10

Why is it ok for my little boys to go into the men's (when they were young enough that if I was with them I would take them into the ladies) but not little girls?

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:10

stillhiding1990 · Yesterday 12:09

And makes his daughter aware that if a woman asks a man for privacy the man can deny that request, great life lesson eh

I thought you were asking him to leave?

YouHaveAnArse · Yesterday 12:10

Tralalalala88 · Yesterday 11:46

What about a little boy seeing it or seeing women naked in a women’s changing room ? Naked bodies exist. It’s a fact of life .

I don't really feel that comfortable changing in a place that only has communal changing available with little boys running round whilst I'm entirely naked, no.

Duckduckgander · Yesterday 12:10

stillhiding1990 · Yesterday 12:06

If you ask a man to leave in a single sex spaces and he disregards the request that tells you everything.

If the man in question is taking his young daughter to the toilet. It tells you he prioritises his daughter's needs over some the preference of some woman who he's never clapped eyes on before.

Crow55 · Yesterday 12:10

The safety of children trumps the discomfort of women who rarely come across fully clothed dads or young boys in the ladies as everybody is tucked away in their own cubicles.

OhBotherSaidPoo · Yesterday 12:10

TallSturdyGirls · Yesterday 12:07

Good women understand that if the only option is the men's with urinals most parents don't want their girls to have to see a load of penises. I don't and I live with 4 men/boys.

My dad took us into the men's. I never saw any penises.
I did see one using a gender neutral loo when a man came out of a cubicle still zipping himself up.

Tralalalala88 · Yesterday 12:10

TallSturdyGirls · Yesterday 12:08

I don't like seeing a load of nobs or even one that isn't my husband's.

Generally people don’t stare at the them the men are facing the urinal and peeing. I couldn’t give a toss if my son sees a load of vaginas and boobs in the woman’s changing room. He’s 4 and he already knows women have different bodies than men. What’s the difference .

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:09

Sirzy · Yesterday 12:06

What exactly do you think men are doing? When they are stood at the urinal nobody can see anything except the back of the man!

I still don’t understand why exposing a little girl to multiple men who are partially undressed, and peeing is less traumatic than an adult woman seeing a fully clothed dad helping his little girl? Please explain why you think the adult woman is at more risk of psychological harm than the small girl being taken into the men’s toilets?

stillhiding1990 · Yesterday 12:09

TinyTempest · Yesterday 12:07

Yes, it tells you he doesn't want his daughter to piss herself.

And makes his daughter aware that if a woman asks a man for privacy the man can deny that request, great life lesson eh

Mushypeasandchipstogo · Yesterday 12:08

Weirdly enough my DH and I witnessed a man take his 6/7 year old daughter into a men’s toilet in a small cafe yesterday- the women’s was only a few metres away -it was my DH who commented that he found this really strange.

ElenOfTheWays · Yesterday 12:08

TheOriginalEmu · Yesterday 11:16

I don’t care who uses what toilet for whatever reason. it’s a toilet. the stalls are private. so i just don’t care.

Good for you. Other women DO care and you don't get to consent on their behalf.
No men in women's spaces. No exceptions. Would you be just as happy if he did this in a women's changing room?

stillhiding1990 · Yesterday 12:08

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:07

So a dad might rape a woman with his little daughter right there? How does this dystopian event even enter your mind?

Ah wish I had your level of naivety, must be nice. Men are predators, women should be entitled to privacy. I give up when it’s women pushing for men to be in single sex spaces, is no one looking out for women these days? Creepy as hell a man thinking he should be in a female toilet - disgusting

TallSturdyGirls · Yesterday 12:08

Tralalalala88 · Yesterday 12:07

It’s not traumatic don’t be ridiculous. What’s traumatic about a man doing a pee ? Children are not sexual beings . Adult men are . Adult men should not be in the ladies . If little girls should not walk through the men’s then little boys should not either .

I don't like seeing a load of nobs or even one that isn't my husband's.

Sirzy · Yesterday 12:07

kittybloom · Yesterday 12:06

For all those say using the disabled loo, what if a disabled person needs access to it? The dad has options. The disabled person doesn't. Comparable to the use of a pram in the wheelchair space. Disabled people count too!

Disabled people don’t matter sadly, threads like this make it clear.

as I said early in the thread disabled toilet facilties are shockingly bad in a lot of places anyway and more people using the only available toilet makes things even worse

FourSevenFive · Yesterday 12:07

Father in women's is moraly wrong.

If accessible doubles as baby change, or other family/unisex facilities are available, it is the obvious solution. Otherwise, men's toilet are the right place.

TinyTempest · Yesterday 12:07

stillhiding1990 · Yesterday 12:06

If you ask a man to leave in a single sex spaces and he disregards the request that tells you everything.

Yes, it tells you he doesn't want his daughter to piss herself.

Swipe left for the next trending thread