Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu feeling uneasy about men taking little girls to the toilet in the womens toilet?

514 replies

Fasdmama · Yesterday 10:57

I've seen this a few times and I dont know what is the right thing to do.
So the other week we were at the cinema. I took my daughter to the toilet and as I was waiting for her a man came out of a cubicle with a little girl and went to wash her hands.
It got me thinking.
I feel uncomfortable a man in the womens toilet. I understand how you'd potentially feel uncomfortable taking a daughter into the mens toilets.
And the only other option in this situation was the disabled toilet but morally thats wrong.

I dont know what I feel is right in this situation so wanted to know other people's opinions.
So yabu: its right for a man to take girl into female toilets
Yanbu: he should take her somewhere else...but where?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Tralalalala88 · Yesterday 12:26

Crispsjamtarts · Yesterday 12:23

"Parenting in the most appropriate toilet"? Lol.
By that logic, that would be mean a little girl is safest in the women's toilet instead of going into the gents, with multiple men pissing at the urinals for instance.

But what is the big deal about men pissing in urinals ? Who bloody cares . A little boy will be exposed to the same sight going in. A few men’s backs facing a urinal . So what ? It’s not that different .

FourSevenFive · Yesterday 12:26

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:21

Since she is the one needing the toilet, doesn’t she have the right to use the toilets that align with her sex?

Are you suggesting mothers should take their young sons to the gents? In the end, it is the boy who is using the toilet.

Ilovelurchers · Yesterday 12:25

When I was very little, I am going to guess about five, my dad took my brother and I swimming and used the men's changing rooms, and I saw an adult stranger's penis. It actually did quite disturb and upset me for a while. I am obviously fine now, but it wasn't nice at the time (and we are a family who are fairly comfortable with nudity, so I had glimpsed brother and dad naked before and understood men had different bodies).

Because of the nature of men's toilets, with urinals, I don't think it's OK to take little girls in there and risk them being exposed to full frontal male nudity. It's OK if the gents is cubicle only - that's different.

I also agree that guys shouldn't be in the women's toilets unless there is absolutely no alternative.

Therefore the least worst outcome in this situation is to use the disabled loo (I understand the objections to this, but there is no ideal solution sometimes) . Obviously in many cases this doubles as a family room so that's it's exact purpose! Even when it doesn't, I think using it is the least worst option.

And demand more safe, gender neutral toilets and changing spaces, to acknowledge the fact that dads have daughters, women have sons, people have opposite sex partners who require assistance with toileting, etc etc.

ElenOfTheWays · Yesterday 12:25

anniegun · Yesterday 11:53

Will the people saying "use the disabled toilet" please stop. That is completely unacceptable

Are you disabled? Because I am and I still think a man with a female child should use them rather than impose himself on the ladies loos. Ideally of course, there should be a single user option that isn't disabled access. But there often isn't.

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:23

TinyTempest · Yesterday 12:22

Unless the woman is pissing in the sink, she doesn't need any more privacy than the lockable cubicle door.

But do keep clutching at straws, it's getting quite amusing.

Time for the what about women washing moon cups in the sink comments.

FourSevenFive · Yesterday 12:23

Timeforachange26 · Yesterday 12:18

Ok so if there aren't any disabled toilets or they are locked what should he do?

Men's. She will be with her father.
Young children can go with their parent to use facilities based on the parent's sex.

Crispsjamtarts · Yesterday 12:23

olivepicanto · Yesterday 12:15

Well I'm a woman and would prefer, for my DD's sake, that he parents in the appropriate toilet

"Parenting in the most appropriate toilet"? Lol.
By that logic, that would be mean a little girl is safest in the women's toilet instead of going into the gents, with multiple men pissing at the urinals for instance.

ExtraOnions · Yesterday 12:23

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:19

Men pulling out their penises and having a wee in either individual urinals or the more common trough urinals.

What kind of hedonistic behaviour are you thinking a dad with his little girl is going to attempt in the women’s toilet?

…and the problem with that is? Nobody is waving them around, you see the back of them and then (horrors) might hear someone urinating. It’s hardly the end of days.

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:22

@stillhiding1990

Creepy as hell a woman thinking little girls should be in a male toilet - disgusting

there fixed that for you

Youhadrambledonfor18pages · Yesterday 12:22

He should take her to the men’s - she’s with him so she’s safe.

MaeshoweDragon · Yesterday 12:22

OhBotherSaidPoo · Yesterday 11:04

No man should enter a woman's toilet.
Good men stay out so bad men stand out.
By making an exemption for Dad of the Year and his darling princess, by accepting that she might be intimidated by men, we are overriding the feelings of other women and girls who will be intimidated by him.

I love this... and may steal it (sorry)

"Good men stay out, so bad men stand out"

That is it exactly for me. Can't send our girls to the women's toilet any more. We wouldn't send them into the men's toilet, because of men... now we can't send them into the women's, because of men. Their independent world gets smaller, they stay "infantilised" for longer.

Make men's toilets more like women's. Make men's toilets safe for all. Stop providing "solutions" for men that use women's spaces.

TinyTempest · Yesterday 12:22

stillhiding1990 · Yesterday 12:09

And makes his daughter aware that if a woman asks a man for privacy the man can deny that request, great life lesson eh

Unless the woman is pissing in the sink, she doesn't need any more privacy than the lockable cubicle door.

But do keep clutching at straws, it's getting quite amusing.

TheyWereFriendlyCreatures · Yesterday 12:21

This would be solved by getting rid or urinals. Men don't need them, they don't have them at home.

Tralalalala88 · Yesterday 12:21

Random321 · Yesterday 12:16

Yet more sweeping generalisations.

Men are not predators. Some are but it's completely disingeous to make such a sweeping statement.

Woman are entitled to privacy - the cublic door provides it.

A man bring his young daughter to the toilet is not creepy.

Your view of the world is distorted.

It’s selfish and entitled is what it is . My father managed perfectly with me and my sister bringing us to men’s when we were kids . What the hell do you think goes on in men’s toilets that is so traumatic ? Even if they catch a glimpse of a mans body that is not traumatic

FourSevenFive · Yesterday 12:21

The toilet examlple sounds innoccuous, but it is a perfect slippery slope.

1)if the men's toilet are so bad for a little girl with her father, how long before someone comes with the idea that father should take his little son to the women's toilet - quoting the very same reasoning?

2)what will happen when father takes her swimming somewhere with open floor changing room? Will he go through women's with her as well?

Men, young men and men with children are still men.

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:21

MiceSpiders · Yesterday 12:15

She is more than welcome to stay or to use facilities suitable for her to be accompanied by a man

Since she is the one needing the toilet, doesn’t she have the right to use the toilets that align with her sex?

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:19

ExtraOnions · Yesterday 12:15

What sort of Roman style hedonistic behaviour do you think goes on in a shopping centre toilet ?

Men pulling out their penises and having a wee in either individual urinals or the more common trough urinals.

What kind of hedonistic behaviour are you thinking a dad with his little girl is going to attempt in the women’s toilet?

Timeforachange26 · Yesterday 12:18

OhBotherSaidPoo · Yesterday 11:04

No man should enter a woman's toilet.
Good men stay out so bad men stand out.
By making an exemption for Dad of the Year and his darling princess, by accepting that she might be intimidated by men, we are overriding the feelings of other women and girls who will be intimidated by him.

Ok so if there aren't any disabled toilets or they are locked what should he do?

Random321 · Yesterday 12:16

stillhiding1990 · Yesterday 12:08

Ah wish I had your level of naivety, must be nice. Men are predators, women should be entitled to privacy. I give up when it’s women pushing for men to be in single sex spaces, is no one looking out for women these days? Creepy as hell a man thinking he should be in a female toilet - disgusting

Yet more sweeping generalisations.

Men are not predators. Some are but it's completely disingeous to make such a sweeping statement.

Woman are entitled to privacy - the cublic door provides it.

A man bring his young daughter to the toilet is not creepy.

Your view of the world is distorted.

MiceSpiders · Yesterday 12:15

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:13

You’re not just asking a man to leave, you’re asking the young girl to leave with her carer because her carer happens to be her dad.

She is more than welcome to stay or to use facilities suitable for her to be accompanied by a man

olivepicanto · Yesterday 12:15

Crispsjamtarts · Yesterday 12:13

Why should a little girl go into the men's toilet. What woman would want that. I would prefer a dad to take his girls into the women's toilets and would get over myself.

Edited

Well I'm a woman and would prefer, for my DD's sake, that he parents in the appropriate toilet

ExtraOnions · Yesterday 12:15

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:09

I still don’t understand why exposing a little girl to multiple men who are partially undressed, and peeing is less traumatic than an adult woman seeing a fully clothed dad helping his little girl? Please explain why you think the adult woman is at more risk of psychological harm than the small girl being taken into the men’s toilets?

Edited

What sort of Roman style hedonistic behaviour do you think goes on in a shopping centre toilet ?

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:15

stillhiding1990 · Yesterday 12:12

You talking to
me or
micespiders?

you. It was ask a man to leave now it’s ask a man for privacy- they aren’t the same

MiceSpiders · Yesterday 12:15

TinyTempest · Yesterday 12:01

And then what?

When he rolls his eyes and ignores you I mean?

He will at least realise he is isn't wanted there and that at least some women will speak up. Men don't need to be everywhere no matter how much they want to be.

The faux naivety on this thread is astonishing

NullaEffugium · Yesterday 12:13

stillhiding1990 · Yesterday 12:06

If you ask a man to leave in a single sex spaces and he disregards the request that tells you everything.

You’re not just asking a man to leave, you’re asking the young girl to leave with her carer because her carer happens to be her dad.

Swipe left for the next trending thread