Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School want to trial a part time timetable after just 2 weeks at the school - WWYD?

294 replies

PinkPandaas · 04/09/2026 13:26

DS is in his second week of Year 7. He has ADHD, an EHCP and CAMHS think he has ODD as well although they won't formally diagnose it.

He was permanently excluded from primary school last year and went to a PRU before starting mainstream secondary this term.

It's been a difficult two weeks. Lots of refusing lessons, swearing at staff, walking out of class and generally refusing instructions. He's got a 1:1 but at the moment he's rejecting a lot of the support because he says he doesn't need a "babysitter".

I've had a meeting with school today and they've suggested trialling a part-time timetable for a few weeks. They want him in every morning, then I'd collect him at lunchtime. They said they've noticed he seems much more settled in the mornings and most of the serious incidents are happening in the afternoons. Their thinking is that if he can finish each day on a positive note it might help him build up to full days.

Part of me understands the logic. The other part of me is worried it's just teaching him that if he refuses enough or struggles enough he gets to come home early. His primary school and the PRU used to send him home a lot to "calm down" and looking back I sometimes wonder if he learnt that kicking off meant going home.

I'm also worried about what it means long term. Is this the start of them deciding mainstream isn't going to work? Or is it actually a sensible way of helping him settle?

I'm really torn because I want to work with the school, but I don't want to make things worse by agreeing to something that isn't actually helping him.

OP posts:
Qb2654 · 05/09/2026 17:47

An alternative, if this hasn't been suggested already, is for him to do afternoons and as he is successful bring his start time forward. This works brilliantly for many children as it means they are successful and not getting home early if they misbehave

Loulou4022 · 05/09/2026 18:19

likeafishneedsabike · 05/09/2026 17:31

It’s difficult to know what might be going on behind the scenes. It might be that they have teachers suffering with long term workplace stress and that having such a high needs child is having a negative impact on staff wellbeing. Perhaps they are focusing on staff retention. Attempting to teach a child with these challenges while providing adequate education for 30+ others is not a sustainable workplace condition.

I’ve never known the decision to be based on staff wellbeing!! It’s always been based on the needs of the child. Certainly at the school I work at.

botchartistsunited · 05/09/2026 18:36

Ask school to find an appropriate alternative provision (AP) for the afternoon.
You can then call for an early EHCP review and request that the option for AP is written in.
I have worked with students who have flourished with this type of combined approach to education.

Sirzy · 05/09/2026 18:45

Loulou4022 · 05/09/2026 18:19

I’ve never known the decision to be based on staff wellbeing!! It’s always been based on the needs of the child. Certainly at the school I work at.

I agree.

We may tag team for certain children to ensure that no staff member is trying to deal with it alone but we wouldn’t exclude or reduce timetable based on that.

we spend a lot of time juggling things to meet the needs of everyone but the decisions made are always what is best for the child, or what we hope is for the best for them!

MMUmum · 05/09/2026 18:56

PinkPandaas · 04/09/2026 13:26

DS is in his second week of Year 7. He has ADHD, an EHCP and CAMHS think he has ODD as well although they won't formally diagnose it.

He was permanently excluded from primary school last year and went to a PRU before starting mainstream secondary this term.

It's been a difficult two weeks. Lots of refusing lessons, swearing at staff, walking out of class and generally refusing instructions. He's got a 1:1 but at the moment he's rejecting a lot of the support because he says he doesn't need a "babysitter".

I've had a meeting with school today and they've suggested trialling a part-time timetable for a few weeks. They want him in every morning, then I'd collect him at lunchtime. They said they've noticed he seems much more settled in the mornings and most of the serious incidents are happening in the afternoons. Their thinking is that if he can finish each day on a positive note it might help him build up to full days.

Part of me understands the logic. The other part of me is worried it's just teaching him that if he refuses enough or struggles enough he gets to come home early. His primary school and the PRU used to send him home a lot to "calm down" and looking back I sometimes wonder if he learnt that kicking off meant going home.

I'm also worried about what it means long term. Is this the start of them deciding mainstream isn't going to work? Or is it actually a sensible way of helping him settle?

I'm really torn because I want to work with the school, but I don't want to make things worse by agreeing to something that isn't actually helping him.

Instead of coming home is there somewhere quiet he could work in school in the afternoons with his 1:1 ?

avonleabonbon · 05/09/2026 19:00

So many people making alternative suggestions. School teachers and SENCO’s have experience. SENCO is a formal qualification with knowledge and experience. The suggestion to do mornings only will be made after considering all options and deciding what’s best for the child and what is realistic.

KilkennyCats · 05/09/2026 19:03

MMUmum · 05/09/2026 18:56

Instead of coming home is there somewhere quiet he could work in school in the afternoons with his 1:1 ?

I imagine he’s refusing to, what with all the swearing and walking out of class.

roaringdragon · 05/09/2026 19:05

Unfortunately, not all schools are supportive of SEN and not all have a proper understanding of SEN law (or choose to disregard it). It isn’t mandatory to have the NPQSENCO prior to beginning the role as a SENCO, so, no, not all hold a formal qualification. While many schools make lawful decisions in the best interests of pupils, not all do, which is why unlawful informal exclusions is not a rare problem.

PensionPTake · 05/09/2026 19:21

DaisyJohnson · 05/09/2026 17:27

Learning support assistants are underpaid, overworked human beings who have feelings, and typically do not enjoy being harassed, insulted and sworn at for hours on end. It's absolutely right that someone who is being hostile, rude and aggressive to other people should understand that other people don't like that.

And why do so many LSA's make the assumption all send children are like that?

PensionPTake · 05/09/2026 19:23

avonleabonbon · 05/09/2026 19:00

So many people making alternative suggestions. School teachers and SENCO’s have experience. SENCO is a formal qualification with knowledge and experience. The suggestion to do mornings only will be made after considering all options and deciding what’s best for the child and what is realistic.

😂

Loulou4022 · 05/09/2026 19:39

Sirzy · 05/09/2026 18:45

I agree.

We may tag team for certain children to ensure that no staff member is trying to deal with it alone but we wouldn’t exclude or reduce timetable based on that.

we spend a lot of time juggling things to meet the needs of everyone but the decisions made are always what is best for the child, or what we hope is for the best for them!

Absolutely agree.
I’m usually nursery based but a couple of years ago I scooted across to year 1 in the afternoons to support a child out of class.

MadeInTheNorth · 05/09/2026 19:51

EmpathicBoyMum · 05/09/2026 09:46

You need to call an emergency EHCP review and think about a specialist setting. Contact your local Sendias. It is tough changing schools but you need the right setting. ps look at PDA as opposed to ODD as it usually is more accurate.

This. Ask for for a review. I totally feel for you as I used to have to make these difficult decisions for children who were struggling so much in mainstream. Sometimes the only way they could cope was to do half days in mainstream then transfer to specialist in the afternoon. But provision is so patchy.
Basically you have to keep on at the school and the LA to fight for specialist provision. Be honest about the impact it is having at home on you too.
Wish you all the best x

cloudbabies · 05/09/2026 20:05

go for a Sen school op, you will find he becomes a different kid

Arran2024 · 05/09/2026 20:05

drspouse · 05/09/2026 13:31

This is exactly what we did with my DS who WAS violent towards me.
He isn't any longer.
It works.
You do get an escalation while they realise you are serious.
You just keep warning them "you are doing your maths... remember your expectation is no kicking... When you've done that it's X box time"

I imagine I have a much clearer idea of what this mum is dealing with than you do. We are also adopters with two DCs with ADHD.

Edited

You obviously have your own experience to draw on but I know many boys who did not respond well to boundaries like this. They are all grown up now. Some are/ were in prison, despite their parents' efforts. Some badly hurt their parents.

I think it is very dangerous for strangers to suggest that people take steps, completely unsupported and unsupervised, which could actually cause them real harm.

Anyway it sounds to me like there is a lot more than adhd going on here.

AlmostAutumn26 · 05/09/2026 20:07

You have said he won't take his meds sometimes - you are his parent. You need to ensure he does take his meds and you need to be honest with school that you are not ensuring he has his meds when he comes in.

Giraffe888 · 05/09/2026 20:33

Phineyj · 05/09/2026 08:05

Hi @Giraffe888 I don't want to derail the thread but I suggest you take much closer ownership of the EHCP process (if it turns out the school hasn't actually requested one, you can do so yourself as a parent - IPSEA have a template letter on their website you can use).

Thank you for your reply. School have applied as I’ve been part of the whole process. Just before the summer holidays the LA wrote to me to confirm they agree to assess him for one. He’s already had an ed psych assessment earlier in the year so he’s already crossed some of the hurdles

Giraffe888 · 05/09/2026 20:42

roaringdragon · 05/09/2026 09:10

If you haven’t heard anything at all since the school supposedly requested an EHCNA, I would check it has actually been done. I suspect the did t actually request an EHCNA. If it hasn’t, request an EHCNA yourself. On their website, IPSEA has a model letter.

If it has, you need to chase the LA, they are in breach of the timescales. If chasing doesn’t work, you need a pre-action letter.

Is alternative provision in place as well as part-time school?

School have applied as I’ve been part of the whole process. Just before the summer holidays the LA wrote to me to confirm they agree to assess him for one. He’s already had an ed psych assessment earlier in the year so he’s already crossed some of the hurdles

last year school sent home the work that he would have been doing in the afternoon and he completed the work at home with me (two of the days was just PE and the other three days were either topic or art)

they are out of the timescale but that’s due to the summer holidays, does that count?

roaringdragon · 05/09/2026 21:32

Giraffe888 · 05/09/2026 20:42

School have applied as I’ve been part of the whole process. Just before the summer holidays the LA wrote to me to confirm they agree to assess him for one. He’s already had an ed psych assessment earlier in the year so he’s already crossed some of the hurdles

last year school sent home the work that he would have been doing in the afternoon and he completed the work at home with me (two of the days was just PE and the other three days were either topic or art)

they are out of the timescale but that’s due to the summer holidays, does that count?

There are some exceptions to the timescales. The exceptions are where it is impractical for the LA to comply with the timescales because:
a) the LA requested advice from the school during a period beginning one week before a date the school closes for 4+ weeks and ending one week before it re-opens and it isn't practicable for the LA to comply within 6 weeks.
b) like above but about early years.
c) exceptional personal circumstances affect you or DC during that time period.
d) you or DC are absent from the LA for 4+ weeks during the time.

Even if one of the exceptions applies, it isn’t a green light to do as they wish. They must comply as soon as practicable.

There’s not enough information in your post to say for certain if an exception applies or not. I thought your original post made it sound like you thought the school had requested a EHCNA earlier in the year but that might not be the case from your second post. What week are you on/when was the EHCNA requested? Did the LA comply with the 6 week timescale for informing you they were going to assess? Has the LA requested advice and information from the school yet, and if they have, when did they do that? Have you been on holiday for 4+ weeks? Were there exceptional circumstances that affected you/DC?

Have you requested all the necessary advice and information e.g. SALT, OT, CP? Is the existing EP report up to date and sufficient for EHCP purposes?

Work sent home doesn’t relieve the LA of their duty to provide s19 provision. You can request alternative provision.

drspouse · 05/09/2026 22:23

Arran2024 · 05/09/2026 20:05

You obviously have your own experience to draw on but I know many boys who did not respond well to boundaries like this. They are all grown up now. Some are/ were in prison, despite their parents' efforts. Some badly hurt their parents.

I think it is very dangerous for strangers to suggest that people take steps, completely unsupported and unsupervised, which could actually cause them real harm.

Anyway it sounds to me like there is a lot more than adhd going on here.

Are you suggesting that the OP give her DS exactly what he wants in case he is violent?
You clearly don't know anything about behaviour.

k1233 · 06/09/2026 00:42

I'd be getting rid of all computer games and if he has a phone, it would be a brick. Games are not a necessity. Coming home to play Xbox is just a reward for poor behaviour. Coming home to be bored makes school not so bad.

Aubin7 · 06/09/2026 01:37

Possibly a good idea. His bad behaviour is disrupting others' learning. Maybe he could build it up to a full day over the year.

BCBird · 06/09/2026 04:28

I have read your update. I am sorry to hear he has been violent with you. I know this is not uncommon. Do you have any support from.outside agencies? Is his dad on the scene?
In terms of just doing mornings, can you ask he does afternoon lessons at school, but in another room? Teachers set the work and he is supervised elsewhere. This is a pain for the teachers, i know I am a teacher, however sometimes it means the lesson can be taught potentially uninterrupted so a bit of extra work justifies the gain. Explain that no work will get done at home and why. Also, I would make the school completely aware what his behaviour is like at home. Do the school believe they can meet his need? Do they know of any different setting that will suit him.better? Work with them. They won't want to exclude him. I hope you can access support.

Aussiemum87 · 06/09/2026 06:00

It’s not the start of them deciding mainstream isn’t going to work. Mainstream ISN’T working already. There’s a lot of factors to think about that include the disruption for other kids and distress to the teachers.

Wishingthingsweredifferent38 · 06/09/2026 07:39

Have they confirmed that the dose of his meds in the correct one for him? I’m not a doctor, my son has ADHD and is medicated. He’s in year 4 now and the meds are the only way he is able to access school. We went on a reduced timetable in year 2, he was in an hour a day (sometimes 2) for 6 months and I home schooled while worked the rest of the time. It wasn’t until the end of this period that I got the right dose for meds and then he was able to manage a whole school day. The meds significant reduced the anger, violence, rudeness, disrespect. He’s honestly a different child now. I know every child is different, and I am by no means saying this will be the answer to your problems, but it may be worth looking at the meds.

Ikeepforgettingmykeys · 06/09/2026 08:04

roaringdragon · 05/09/2026 09:07

I don’t know why you think that. The Equality Act definition hasn’t changed since the Equality Act came into force.

The EA did not change but how people interpret it - and what is assumed it covers - certainly has.