Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH blames me for DDs behaviour

209 replies

Plastictreesofgold · 31/08/2026 17:07

Me and DH are married 10 years we have one DD6. She is smart and funny she does well at school/sports has loads of friends etc but like most 6 year olds she can be hard work at home sometimes. She can sometimes react disrespectfully shout and give snappy/rude answers to me and DH usually if she is tired/hungry/frustrated.

Somehow DH blames this on me.

Today DH collected DD from school as he was off I wfh so would usually have her snack ready when they get home and would come down from work for a few mins when she gets in to see how her day was but I couldn't do that today as an urgent work call was scheduled during that time
I asked DH to explain that to DD on the way home (as previously she has had a loud meltdown when I was unexpectedly not available when she got home).
Anyway when my call finished at 4 I went down and DD ran to give me a big hug and squeeze I asked her a few questions about her day and she told me a couple of stories about school.
I noticed DH in a bit of a sulk and when we were alone he said she hadn't told him anything about school and had been snapping at him/being disrespectful. He told me that it was my fault because I made him the bearer of bad news (because he had to tell I was on a work call and would be unavailable)
He told me thar I need to have a chat with her about how she treats him.

Dd has always had a strong preference for me but if I'm honest I think DH without realising it can come across as constantly criticising and negative e.g coming in from work and the first thing he will say is "turn down the music" "pick up those toys" etc rather than having a nice interaction with her first after not seeing her all day. He does it to me also.

I don't think he's being reasonable blaming this on me. I will talk to DD later but honestly I think he should be having the conversation as I wasn't even there to see what she said

OP posts:
BuildbyNumbere · 01/09/2026 17:11

Plastictreesofgold · 31/08/2026 20:46

Yes like last year... why would I bring that up with her now?

Isn’t that why he had to tell her you were unavailable in the first place? So she didn’t have another “meltdown”?

BuildbyNumbere · 01/09/2026 17:09

Macaroni46 · 31/08/2026 17:33

Why is your daughter so inflexible that she needs to be prepared that mummy isn’t available? She sounds a bit indulged and entitled.

Agree … sounds like this is the actual issue. Why did he have to be the “bearer of bad news” in the first place?!?

WhisperingHi · 01/09/2026 15:53

StraightTalkingTina · 01/09/2026 07:09

Her DD didn’t have a meltdown. Why are you saying she did?

OPs DH actually had an issue that the daughter handled it calmly and wasn’t ready to talk school stuff.

OP has a DH problem.

I agree her husband seems immature.

It wasn’t a meltdown, that was the terminology OP used.

ThreeLocusts · 01/09/2026 12:29

Some weird judgy responses here OP. I'm more in your husband's position - he's the louder and chattier person of us two and the kids are chattier with him than with me.

I do think that he has sometimes tried to 'weaponize' his livelier interactions with the kids when we had conflicts between us and that he has actively interfered in my interactions with them, which is shit.

Never, ever have I requested of my husband that he order the kids to interact differently with me. I have requested that he stop talking over me himself and not pretend all is fine if they are actively rude to me, but I bloody well take responsibility for looking after my relationships with my children myself. I think your husband should, too.

Warmlight1 · 01/09/2026 10:40

beaglescurleduplikebagels · 01/09/2026 08:57

I just don’t think the fact that OP is in a meeting is something that her DD needs to be informed about in advance, especially if it then makes her DH the “bearer of bad news”.

As @Delphiniumandlupinssays, maybe it would be better if OP being available wasn’t the default so that if she is around, it’s a nice surprise, but it not, it’s also not a big deal for the daughter.

My thinking is that it would just be easier all
round if the DD didn’t have certain expectations about who is available straight after school, that’s all - it’s not about having fixed ideas about her behaviour as such.

It's his interpretation that that's why she was less than chatty. She's also objectively done nothing other than been a bit quiet.
Kids have all sorts going on internally. One of the things you learnt as a parent is a lot of it is not personal.
Some of these responses sound like they come from the villain in a children's book!!.

Whitedaffodils · 01/09/2026 10:28

helpfulperson · 01/09/2026 10:25

It is interesting that your husband is getting tested for ASD. As a society we are generally tolerant and accommodating of children with ASD but somehow this disappears when they are grownups. If your husband is ASD he may well have have sensory issues meaning a screaming child is harder for him to cope with than you.

You both need to sit down and properly discuss how to manage this. It is not normal behaviour for an NT 6 year old so she may well be ND. So the problem and solutions need to be seen through the lens of both being possibly ND.

Oh ffs she didn't scream at anyone. Why would they be sitting down to discuss anything when the child did absolutely nothing wrong

Whitedaffodils · 01/09/2026 10:26

Bluebeast · 01/09/2026 10:07

Yes but reading other OP posts OP mentions meltdowns and other inflexibility around DD - so I was responding to that not simply the original post.

So you just made up a scenario in your own head and gave the OP advice on that made up scenario rather than actually responding to the actual OP?
Name one child in the history of children that hasn't reacted badly to dissappointment at some point previously?
The OP handled this perfectly the child responded remarkably well to the change in routine so I really don't think she needs any of your advice.

helpfulperson · 01/09/2026 10:25

It is interesting that your husband is getting tested for ASD. As a society we are generally tolerant and accommodating of children with ASD but somehow this disappears when they are grownups. If your husband is ASD he may well have have sensory issues meaning a screaming child is harder for him to cope with than you.

You both need to sit down and properly discuss how to manage this. It is not normal behaviour for an NT 6 year old so she may well be ND. So the problem and solutions need to be seen through the lens of both being possibly ND.

Bluebeast · 01/09/2026 10:07

thepariscrimefiles · 01/09/2026 04:12

She didn't scream the house down though. OP's DH was annoyed because she gave OP a big hug when she came down after her call and she hadn't done that to him. He told OP that their DD had been a bit snappy with him, not that she'd had a melt-down.

Yes but reading other OP posts OP mentions meltdowns and other inflexibility around DD - so I was responding to that not simply the original post.

HAPPILYMARRIEDSINCE2012 · 01/09/2026 09:48

CountFucula · 31/08/2026 17:26

He sounds a bit childish and unable to be an effective parent when he is sulking/snapping. But … you sound quite indulgent. Having to prepare her for you not being able to hang out after school is a bit much and make it sound like she rules the house with an iron fist. Is she really that unadaptable? When you say ‘meltdown’ do you mean tantrum? Or meltdown as in you think she might be neurodiverse?

This

SueKeeper · 01/09/2026 09:33

It sounds like a lot of it is the way he communicates, it's not very child friendly, more like he's parenting like it's a job.

A dad who communicates well would have managed expectations better, in a more fun way - maybe tip toeing into the house to not disturb mummy, having a special dad snack, planning a surprise like hiding when mummy did come down, using it as a chance to detour to the park. Not as a bearer of bad news, which is just reinforcing the idea that mummy not being right there is wrong in some way.

The same with loud music, or mess - it's not what he's saying, it's how he says it.

Op, it's on him!!!

Whitedaffodils · 01/09/2026 09:28

ScaryM0nster · 01/09/2026 09:24

You know you’re her favourite. You got him to be the bearer of bad news. You then backtracked on that when they got home, so he looks like the baddie and for no reason.

You're surprised he's a bit miffed. FFS.

Personal view is that parents need to back each other up so if child is being unkind to one then the other needs to reinforce those expectations. You don’t get to be mean to one parent and then get the other one fawning over you. That just fuels the favourite parent thing.

How did she back track?

Whitedaffodils · 01/09/2026 09:27

Melarus · 01/09/2026 09:08

My thinking is that it would just be easier all
round if the DD didn’t have certain expectations about who is available straight after school, that’s all

I think they're managing those expectations quite well, actually - by giving her information and letting her do what she will with it. This time, she processed the information, got used to the idea that Mum wouldn't be downstairs when she got home, and stayed calm about it. Next time, she'll remember that she coped just fine when this happened before, and she'll spend less time being disappointed when she hears the news. Soon she won't be bothered any more.

There's nothing wrong with easing someone in, when you want to modify behaviour or expectations. Think of adults with fear of flying. Do you just keep shoving them on a plane and bollocking them when they panic? Of course not - you give them information ("that noise is just the landing gear retracting") and get them used to it gradually.

I totally agree. Most kids enjoy the familiarity and safety of routine, i used to be a teacher and even kids that are 11/12 loved that I used a visual timetable which showed what subject was coming next. If the usual routine was changing I would let the kids know out of respect and to allow them to manage their expectations. It's absolutely normal for a 6 year old to like a routine and it should be encouraged. She handled it brilliantly when mum wasn't available so we'll done OP and well done DD

ScaryM0nster · 01/09/2026 09:24

You know you’re her favourite. You got him to be the bearer of bad news. You then backtracked on that when they got home, so he looks like the baddie and for no reason.

You're surprised he's a bit miffed. FFS.

Personal view is that parents need to back each other up so if child is being unkind to one then the other needs to reinforce those expectations. You don’t get to be mean to one parent and then get the other one fawning over you. That just fuels the favourite parent thing.

Whitedaffodils · 01/09/2026 09:12

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

Melarus · 01/09/2026 09:08

My thinking is that it would just be easier all
round if the DD didn’t have certain expectations about who is available straight after school, that’s all

I think they're managing those expectations quite well, actually - by giving her information and letting her do what she will with it. This time, she processed the information, got used to the idea that Mum wouldn't be downstairs when she got home, and stayed calm about it. Next time, she'll remember that she coped just fine when this happened before, and she'll spend less time being disappointed when she hears the news. Soon she won't be bothered any more.

There's nothing wrong with easing someone in, when you want to modify behaviour or expectations. Think of adults with fear of flying. Do you just keep shoving them on a plane and bollocking them when they panic? Of course not - you give them information ("that noise is just the landing gear retracting") and get them used to it gradually.

Howmanycatsistoomany · 01/09/2026 09:02

Projectprincesschaos · 31/08/2026 17:15

Schoo no where at? It’s bank holiday in UK.

It was a bank holiday in England, not all of the UK!

beaglescurleduplikebagels · 01/09/2026 08:57

Warmlight1 · 01/09/2026 08:47

You have some very fixed ideas which are not that realistic about how children should act. Kids are very different from each other. But most children respond to routine and predictability. OP is showing she's providing that. That's all.

I just don’t think the fact that OP is in a meeting is something that her DD needs to be informed about in advance, especially if it then makes her DH the “bearer of bad news”.

As @Delphiniumandlupinssays, maybe it would be better if OP being available wasn’t the default so that if she is around, it’s a nice surprise, but it not, it’s also not a big deal for the daughter.

My thinking is that it would just be easier all
round if the DD didn’t have certain expectations about who is available straight after school, that’s all - it’s not about having fixed ideas about her behaviour as such.

Warmlight1 · 01/09/2026 08:49

I really want to tell responders to get off this kid's back. There's no child behaviour problem here.

Warmlight1 · 01/09/2026 08:47

beaglescurleduplikebagels · 01/09/2026 08:26

My point was that she shouldn’t have to be prepped in advance in order for her not to get upset. Mum being stuck in a meeting should be just one of those things, not something dad needs to prepare her for before she gets home.

You have some very fixed ideas which are not that realistic about how children should act. Kids are very different from each other. But most children respond to routine and predictability. OP is showing she's providing that. That's all.

Delphiniumandlupins · 01/09/2026 08:45

It's lovely that you can usually take a quick break from work when your DD gets home but it might be easier for everyone if you vary things a bit and let your DH be responsible more often. Then if she does have a loud reaction she won't be interrupting an important work call and you can challenge the behaviour when it happens. Also, if your DH normally collects DD from school he knows how talkative she is on the way home so maybe she was being rude/sulky?

Timeforachange26 · 01/09/2026 08:38

Happyjoe · 31/08/2026 23:25

Yes it is. She's 6, she's still learning to control her emotions - that's what the development stage is for 6 year olds. Also, I am never ever going to think a six year old, excited to see her mum is a bad thing, only on MN eh.

And tolerate? Lol, why do you think she wanted her husband to tell her child before hand? To avoid it. What's better? To warn her then it's no issue and all calm or punish her severely for being a six year old when it was all avoidable in a kind manner? The daughter, no doubt will grow up, learn how to control herself and I daresay the teenage years of barely grunting at her parents when she comes home will be here soon enough!

Edited

Tolerate the tantrums. Any of mine behaving like that at 6 would've been sent to their room until they had calmed down as they obviously needed the space to compose themselves. Although tbh they'd had mostly outgrown tantrums by the time they were 5

beaglescurleduplikebagels · 01/09/2026 08:26

Whitedaffodils · 01/09/2026 08:06

But it didn't cause a tantrum, the child didn't react badly at all. She quietly played away until mum finished work what more do you want from?

My point was that she shouldn’t have to be prepped in advance in order for her not to get upset. Mum being stuck in a meeting should be just one of those things, not something dad needs to prepare her for before she gets home.

Melarus · 01/09/2026 08:14

I can't see how telling a small child that their routine will be changing today is lax parenting. It's just giving them information.

Based on this thread, you'd almost think some people would rather not tell the DD so she could go ahead and have a meltdown, which would give them a chance to punish her and "nip it in the bud", thus demonstrating their superior parenting skills.

Anyway, I think it's likely that the DH here is uncomfortable with the way the OP is the preferred parent. He doesn't like being second best. The DD no doubt subconsciously picks up on this, perhaps feeling she's disappointed him, and is more subdued with him. It's a self-perpetuating cycle that's really hard to break. You have my sympathy, OP, but it's on your DH to change his attitude, not you.

Whitedaffodils · 01/09/2026 08:06

beaglescurleduplikebagels · 01/09/2026 07:27

Because she shouldn’t be shouting and looking for her mum when she’s not immediately available.

Mum being free from work and ready for a hug is obviously a nice thing but it shouldn’t be something that causes a tantrum when it doesn’t happen.

She’s six, not two.

But it didn't cause a tantrum, the child didn't react badly at all. She quietly played away until mum finished work what more do you want from?