Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my neighbour is overstepping about plants and cats?

50 replies

dancetojoydivison · 30/08/2026 04:07

Looking for advice, aware there was a post made for April Fools 2 years ago! However this one is genuine.
I have lived in a ground floor flat for 5 years, which has an enclosed walled patio garden. I love the garden and it’s a little haven in the middle of the city. I have enjoyed planting and growing varieties of cut flowers.
I have neighbour next door who has a very similar set up to me, enclosed walled garden and she too enjoys her garden in the same way I do.
Neighbour took on a stray cat approximately a year ago, the cat roams locally to where we live (particularly the abandoned building next door). I too have a cat, he was also a stray, he does not roam and is very much a homebody. He is territorial over the garden and will chase away any other cats who may consider coming in.
My neighbour has become slightly overbearing, in what I should and shouldn’t be putting in my garden. This includes slug killer (pet safe version), coffee grounds, and weed killer. I have always kept her informed when I have used it which gives her the choice of keeping her cat inside if she wishes. Previously she has stopped maintenance workers from weeding areas in the car park as they were using weed killer, went as far as to write a note on the weed killer solution when they went on break naming it ‘cat killer’.
My issue now, I mentioned I went looking for tulip bulbs over text, and she replied with a screenshot of information of tulip toxicity and the complications they can cause to cats if ingested, particularly the bulbs.
My cat has zero interest in my plants (he much prefers sunbathing). I have grown daffodils and tulips for years with cats and had zero issues. I know that this is simply to safeguard her cat however I’m feeling that this is beyond controlling and passive aggressive and her cat is not my responsibility. Her cat also free roams around the area so it doesn’t make any sense for her to be overly concerned about what’s in my garden.
Any advice on how to deal with this?

OP posts:
Cathmawr · 30/08/2026 07:12

I have the greediest cat in the world who eats all manner of stupid things and she has never even considered eating my tulip bulbs.

Agree with beer traps for slugs instead of pellets for the benefit of nature. Do not tell your neighbour though as she will probably report you for trying to get her cat drunk.

Fairyliz · 30/08/2026 07:13

VenusThighTrap · 30/08/2026 04:27

I’m not a cat owner but would cats actually dig up and eat tulip bulbs?!

I’d just ignore the message or reply “good to know” and then carry on your business. As someone said above, if her cat roams tulip bulbs will be low down the list of neighbourhood dangers.

I’ve had cats and tulips for 40 years and in my experience no.
They are much more likely to catch a mouse and bring its decapitated body into the house, but that’s another thread.

Beautifulfriend · 30/08/2026 07:24

she sounds a bit much, but to answer your question, nematodes worked for me. They are safe and effective: https://www.nematodesdirect.co.uk

Buy Nemasys Nematodes from the UKs Leading Supplier

Buy nematodes direct from the UK's leading suppliers of the Nemasys range of Nematodes.

https://www.nematodesdirect.co.uk

Bluenotgreen · 30/08/2026 07:26

I voted YABU because I can’t imagine a life in which I would be negotiating with my neighbours or giving them any info about my garden plans.

Stop discussing this stuff with her. Ignore anything that is intrusive or bossy.

limetrees32 · 30/08/2026 07:32

The love of the cats and gardens will tear you apart...again 🤷🏼‍♀️🤭🫣

Brilliant !

NomNomNominativeDeterminism · 30/08/2026 07:33

Flannelfeet · 30/08/2026 04:21

The love of the cats and gardens will tear you apart...again 🤷🏼‍♀️🤭🫣

😁🎶

Harrysmummy246 · 30/08/2026 07:35

Well I avoid using weedkiller anyway and don't use slug killer as there are bigger impacts on the environment. But I don't have cats to worry about and the dog rarely does much beyond go and sunbathe.
But ultimately, you've given her the ammunition. It boils down to your garden, your choice.

Harrysmummy246 · 30/08/2026 07:36

dancetojoydivison · 30/08/2026 04:21

I’d finished a nightshift, waited for a supermarket to open and they didn’t have them in stock yet. I was just airing frustration at my wasted time. It wasn’t to goad or seek a reaction.
Fully taking on board the advice of not over indulging information. Thank you for the responses.

Far too early to plant them anyway.

Btw if you want a wider choice of tulip bulbs, look at Peter nyssen online (who I suggest to clients)

hididdlyho · 30/08/2026 07:37

It's the risk she takes by having a roaming cat. Even if you complied with her requests (your shouldn't as she's being controlling) she doesn't know what other gardens her cat is visiting and whether they contain toxic plants or chemical treatments.

PersephoneParlormaid · 30/08/2026 07:39

Credittocress · 30/08/2026 04:12

You’re giving her the information to feed this. Stop telling her what you’re doing.

This

Harrysmummy246 · 30/08/2026 07:39

dancetojoydivison · 30/08/2026 06:11

I’ve tried copper trim, beer traps and eggshells and nothing is effective! If you could extend advice on this I’d be so grateful.

Encourage wildlife into garden such as blackbirds and thrushes. Consider plants that are more slug resistant. Accept that nature isn't perfect
Go out at dusk, hand pick off and get rid (over into your neighbour's garden???)

geumsun · 30/08/2026 07:49

Another one chiming in with lay off the slug and weed killer. Copper rings do work for me, but largely I plant slug resistant plants because I can't be arsed to fight slugs. I weed by hand.

I have roaming cats. The only thing I would never plant is lillies.

parietal · 30/08/2026 08:23

Nematodes are very effective for slugs. Also wool slug barrier that is now in many garden centres.

Grumpyoldcat · 30/08/2026 08:28

Ignore. Ive never seen my cat eating my tulips. I do try to use alternatives to weedkiller nowadays because it harms bees. She sounds like she is on some sort of crusade so not a lot you can do.

Seymour5 · 30/08/2026 08:34

We have a small front garden, it has spring bulbs, including tulips in it, under a layer if bark. It also has quite a bit of cat crap. I have scattered orange peel, bits of garlic, sprayed with citronella and lavender essential oils, all to no avail. One feline visitor has even chosen a wooden planter for a loo. Some days, as soon as I open the front door I can smell it. Any suggestions to stop it happening?

OhMyGoodieAunts · 30/08/2026 08:37

I have issues with slugs too. Just much everything, even things like foxgloves. I now have a survival of the fittest policy and only plants that survive the slugs life in my garden. This is a bit limiting tho.

I had a cat and he never ate random things in the garden. The only plant I’d wouldn’t have planted would be a lily.

InWithPeaceOutWithStress · 30/08/2026 08:40

Make your community more welcoming to hedgehogs to cut down on slugs. Hedgehogs need gaps in fences / walls and in order to roam gardens and eat the slugs.

mondaytosunday · 30/08/2026 08:44

Goodness. I have two cats and plant whatever I like and while when they were kittens avoided anything they might chew they are beyond that phase now. I had over 40 tulips planted a couple years ago.
Don’t tell your neighbour what you are doing. If her cat roams it can get into any garden so she can hardly dictate what goes on everywhere.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 30/08/2026 08:58

We have a few roaming cats in the neighbourhood and the only thing I avoid planting is lilies. I would love a tree lily but it’s not worth the risk as I know the cats use our garden as a thoroughfare.

I lob all our coffee grounds out on to the garden.

dancetojoydivison · 30/08/2026 08:59

Thank you for all your advice in regards to slug prevention! I have a few cans of red stripe that will hopefully do the trick, and will absolutely try the pampas grass. Pest control from birds is not an option, her cat ‘hunts’ and has caught magpies before. We have previously had a discussion of me wanting to put in a bird bath, however that idea was quickly shot down as we both weren’t keen on encouraging birds in to a ‘lair’ if you will. I have suggested a bell on her cats collar (she wears a tracker) however nothing has come of it.
We don’t have much wildlife around except a few foxes with being in the city, but I was completely ignorant on the wider effects of slug killer.
Naturally I am an over-explainer, and I guess this just boils down to me being overly concerned that she may see me as negligent by having plants that are recognised to be toxic to cats. But ‘good to know’ is the perfect response to any unwarranted feedback!

OP posts:
UniquePinkSwan · 30/08/2026 09:03

I wouldn’t say another word to her. Her cat is not your problem

Aparecium · 30/08/2026 10:21

Seymour5 · 30/08/2026 08:34

We have a small front garden, it has spring bulbs, including tulips in it, under a layer if bark. It also has quite a bit of cat crap. I have scattered orange peel, bits of garlic, sprayed with citronella and lavender essential oils, all to no avail. One feline visitor has even chosen a wooden planter for a loo. Some days, as soon as I open the front door I can smell it. Any suggestions to stop it happening?

Silent Roar
https://amzn.eu/d/03hnpp44

You will need to first remove all cat poo, and possibly the top layer of soil in your planter. If the bark chippings are soaked with urine you’ll have to replace them first.

parakeet · 30/08/2026 10:26

Reply with thumbs up then ignore.

SomeOtherUser · 30/08/2026 10:30

Voted YABU because I would hate a nearby neighbour using weed killer regularly - if you are not doing that, I take it back! It's the impression I got from your post, however.

Regarding tulip bulbs, I'd not tell her about things anymore as she sounds a little overzealous.

TheLambtonWorm · 30/08/2026 10:48

I would send her back a screenshot of catio. If she doesn't want her cat getting hurt by external factors she keeps it inside. The slug pellets are foul though so, you both suck.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page